Acid Liquid Reviews [view details]

Give us YOUR review!

Showing 11 through 20 of 23 reviews

"The great outdoors.."
The woody rich tones of this cigar work in perfect harmony with fresh air. A great cigar to smoke outside. Camping, fishing or just on a walk, this one will bring you home to Momma.
Teodoro in Minneapolis March 20, 2006
"Not Typical of an Acid Cigar"
This was the worst cigar I have ever smoked in my life. It tasted bad from the beginning to the end. This cigar is not typical of an Acid... Awful Tasting and a bad smoke!
Ben Vana in March 6, 2006
"Worst of all known bad"
Not a hint of tobacco. Like smoking an incense stick. Sickening.
Michael Mullins in Houston, Tx September 1, 2005
"Not what I expected from an Acid"
I was expecting the aroma and unique flavor of an Acid; what I got was an average cigar with only a hint of flavor. Nice smoke but not an Acid.
Brent in Louisiana August 9, 2005
"Great cigar but not the Acid sweetness"
I received this cigar in the "my private stash" collection. This is a great smoke, but it lacks the famous Acid "sweetness" of the other Acid cigars. Its was an enjoyable smoke that burned well, with a creamy white smoke. Once you get past the lack of sweet flavor and think of it as a regular cigar you will enjoy it.
Jason in California July 15, 2005
"OK"
Started off harsh. Then mellowed out niceley in the middle. Then it got harsh again the last 2 inches. This cigar had a few good hits - never really had great, powerful flavor. Really mild when it wasn't harsh. I wouldn't get it again. I let it set and took infrequent hits hoping it would get better - never did.
Mike in California February 9, 2005
"Tasted More Like Potpourri To Me"
The fact that there are positive comments out there about the Acid line just goes to show that everyone has different tastes. I got a large sampler that included 4 different Acid line cigars. I tried them all, and didn't get near half done with any of them. They pretty much made me nauseous from the smell. My suggestion to anyone curious about these cigars is to smell it first. I realize that it is poor Cigar etiquette to sniff cigars before buying, so don't touch your nose to it, you won't have to anyway; just touch the wrapper and then smell your fingers. If you are still interested, give it a try. If it smells like bad incense, ask yourself if you want to smoke bad incense.
Shawn in Orange County, CA January 13, 2005
"Unconventional - Yes - But I Love This Cigar !"
Very, Very Different but what a great smoke! Burns perfectly, great taste, nice aroma. Maybe not for everyday, but a great smoke
David Allen in Lake Mary, FL October 22, 2004
"A unique smoke - try it at least once"
This cigar is not nearly so perfume-like as everyone thinks. Though fresh out of the cellophane it does have a very unique and "incense-like" quality, the smoke itself imparts just a subtle amount of the unique blend of oils and botanicals that Drew uses. I thoroughly enjoyed the smoke and I'm glad there were two of them in the sampler. Were it not for the $$$ of the Acid line, this could easily find a long-standing place in my humidor. Every smoker should try Acids at least once. Though most smokers agree - you'll never know a cigar until you try it at least 3 times...A fine smoke - I'll be coming back for more!
B in Seattle, WA September 25, 2004
"An instant Acid love affair"
My first experience with Acid cigars and now I'm hooked! The smell before lighting was what drew me to the CLOSED box at my cigar store. Opening the lid was a feast for the nose and lighting it just made it better. A smooth draw and great taste through and through I was surprised at how the essential oils and flavors blended nicely with the full flavor of the top notch, slow burning tobacco not over powering at all. From the moment I picked it up I didn’t want to put it down. I can’t wait to try the rest of the Drew Estates line.
Network13 in Fort Lauderdale, FL November 4, 2003
Previous Next
Customer Ratings

10 Burn (79) 100
Poor - Excellent

10 Consistency (80) 100
Poor - Excellent

10 Draw (80) 100
Poor - Excellent

10 Appearance (84) 100
Poor - Excellent

10 Taste (75) 100
Poor - Excellent

10 Construction (82) 100
Poor - Excellent


On Sale - See whats on sale now and save!
Machine Made Cigars