Showing 1 through 10 of 25 reviews
"Not the Best"
I ordered 5 of these because I like some of the other Drew Estates smokes. May be good for some, but did not live up to my expectations. Still have 2 left and waiting to pawn them off on a friend to see if he likes them
Robert A in South Carolina September 17, 2012
"Eh... Skip it."
I've tried and liked a few other Acids, but not this one. I'll give credit to the construction. But, the taste is really pretty unpleasant. Kuba Kuba is far better, as is the Toast. Skip this one.
Jason in Colorado August 19, 2012
The aroma of cloves permeate this cigar. I had forgotten the great taste of cloves when I picked up one of these beauties. It was a dream to smoke and so very smooth.
James in Oregon July 24, 2011
"They kind of "Grow on You" if you try them enough"
I've burned thru a five pack and then some, and I'm getting a box for my morning walks. I don't get all those tastes; leathers, mangos, and the ever-present toasted hays and caramels so often quoted in cigar reviews. They burn well enough, give good smoke, and are pleasant. Nuff said!!!
Bert in Deep in the Heart of Texas December 28, 2010
"Thought I was smoking a clove... not my cup of tea"
Thought I was smoking a clove... not my cup of tea.
Adam P in Texas February 21, 2010
"Mild, pleasant smoke."
A very enjoyable mild cigar. The aromas of these Acids are one-of-a-kind, to say the least. I always enjoy an Acid. Great for after dinner because the smells and flavors are like a nice dessert. This is the most mild one I've sampled. I prefer the more full bodied, Kuba Kuba. But this is a nice one to have in your humidor as it's not too overpowering. Other Acids should be kept in a separate humidor or sealed in the wrapper.
Marty in Chicago, IL November 14, 2009
Well I have now smoked every Acid they have made.
This was my first liquid and it was great, not like the sweetness of thier other cigars, but I found it to be a very enjoyable cigar anyway. Its a quality cigar and like a Cuban it could be smoked to the NUB.
joe di in mass November 14, 2009
"Eh....it's still an Acid"
I tend to agree with other reviewers. Being a fan of Acid sticks I tried to give the benefit of the doubt to this smoke. While construction and burn are Acid quality , overall flavor was bland and uneventful. This stick is not up to par with the rest of the Acid line, Kuba Kuba, EO Larry , the One , all super smokes.
st.jim in Arlington March 29, 2008
"I'm a big Acid fan!"
Acids are great cigars, but I feel Drew Estate missed the mark with this one. The draw is extremely tight , so much so that I thought it was a fluke. So, I got another one to see and the draw was very tight on the second one also. What little smoke I could pull tasted decent at best but the aftertaste was somewhat bitter and a little sour. I have to say, like all Acids, it did smell nice and burned evenly but doesn't come close to making up for the rest. The 1400cc, Kuba Kuba and Cold Infusion Tea are all great cigars and the Extra Ordinary Larry and One are exceptional. Stick to those if you are trying Acid cigars for the first time.
Joey in Phoenix July 18, 2007
"One of the best Acids that I've ever smoked"
I recieved a my secret stash collection and while I enjoyed all four of the cigars, one stood above the rest. The Acid Liquid is a smooth smoke with a great ash and a such a consistent flavor that I burned my fingertips more than once trying to get that last little bit out of it. Great morning smoke in the field. I give it two thumbs up.
Nathan S. in Columbia, SC October 15, 2006