Showing 21 through 30 of 42 reviews
Too mild and sort of blah tasting to me. The wrapper is entirely too delicate, the end caps all split either upon cutting or about 1/3 through smoking. Am ageing the rest without the cellophane to see if that improves the end-cap splitting problem. Highly Overrated cigar in my opinion.
Arcadia Point in 472.1LMR April 11, 2007
Been wanting to try the Baccarat for a while and was able to purchase this with a deal and, well, was very dissappointed. Did not like the taste of the wrapper and it went downhill from there. Will give the rest away.
Russ in Delaware March 10, 2007
I just had my first one the other day during lunch break. If I had more time I might have lit up another. It was a very pleasing smoke. I thought it had nice construction, consistent draw, mild aroma, and puffs of creamy smoke. I would recommend you give this one a try. 2 Thumbs Up! Can't wait to try the Maduros next!
Kevin Brown in DE March 3, 2007
"One of my favorites and thats saying a lot"
I really do love this cigar. The look of it is a sporty yet classy look and I love the slogan of the game. The taste is like nothing else, I love a good cigar taste and as far as flavors go I usually am not a huge fan. This cigar does an incredible job of balancing the flavor on the wrapper and the good leaf taste. The draw is not very tight but I will tell you this, it works perfectly for this cigar. Some times when the draw is lose I do not like it but it fits this smoke. I always, always have a few of these in my humidor and I am going to start buying boxes of these because of the frequency that I smoke these.
Ted in West Chester PA November 8, 2006
"Sometimes you don't get what you pay for."
It's true . . . . sometimes you don't get what your pay for and with the Baccarat Rothschild you get much, much more than you paid for. What a great little smoke. This would have to be my everyday cigar if I was going to have one, but I like diversity more so I don't have a "single" everyday cigar, but this sure is a cigar I COULD smoke everyday.
John Buckley in New Hampshire July 24, 2006
Terrible burn and taste, might as well buy Swisher Sweets if you like the flavored tip.
Can't always judge a cigar by price but you get what you pay for with this one!
Gary in Kentucky July 13, 2006
Just finished my first box. Of all the other brands of cigars that I have smoked over the past year, the Baccarat Rothschild has been the most consistent of all. I can always count on having an enjoyable smoke when I light one up. Burn is even, draw is easy and the taste although mild is always the same.
Norm in Malden, MA December 2, 2005
"Not a bargain cigar at any price!!"
This was one of the worst cigars I have ever had. Mild flavor should not mean tasteless, the flavor of this is what I think rolled up newspaper would taste like. The burn was terrible, cigar kept going out and if you smoked hard enough to keep it lit it burned extremely hot! Would not waste my money on another of these at any price.
Jeff in Colorado November 24, 2004
"Sweet Short Smoke"
Great short smoke. Even burn, great ash and smooth flavor. Sweet cap even made my wife like to try it out, with the mild strength she asks for one once in a while.
Cooldaddy in South Jersey September 20, 2004
"Excellent cigar, BUT I'm not a mild cigar smoker"
This was an all around excellent cigar with a superb appearance(perfect to impress the ladies) BUT I personally am not a big fan of mild cigars. I do recommend this cigar to anyone who likes mild cigars because it had perfect construction, excellent appearance, nice draw and flawless burn.
Eric Williams in Keokuk, Iowa August 22, 2004