Showing 1 through 10 of 47 reviews
"Very Good Stolky Excellent"
Excellent consistency Very Good taste Draw was Good Burn excellent will be one of my Favorites
Wilfredo in NYC February 10, 2014
I got one as a freebie with my last order. Burn, draw, appearance all ok - taste, not so much. I laugh when I read the snobby reviews of some that read like a hint of nutmeg, fresh baked cookies with warm milk and cinnamon and a purring kitty This Rothschild would be burning rubber, with an overwhelming flavor like loud rap music and raw sewage. The foulest thing I ve ever tasted.
Greg in Idaho November 22, 2013
"Excellent Mild Smoke"
I have probably tried a dozen different cigars over the last couple of years, but I keep coming back to the Baccarat Rothschild. It is clearly a mild smoke, but perfect for the occasional smoker who wants flavor, but doesn't want to wake up to the taste of last night's cigar. The wrapper has a barely discernible sweetness, and generally this stick has a good burn and draw. Sadly, there are 2-3 badly wrapped sticks in each box of 25, but for the most part the burn, draw and consistency are quite good. An excellent value and good smoke.
Sam in Atlanta September 3, 2013
Mild. Clean burn. Will buy again.
Andrew in August 9, 2013
I literally have zero complaints about this one. Clean burn, and very smooth cigar. Would definitely buy again.
Austin in Manchester, MD July 1, 2013
"Very Nice In Every Way"
Being rather new to enjoying cigars I found this cigar to be mild yet filled with flavor. Draw was very nice. The construction allowed for an easy even smoke. And for the price I feel it would be hard to beat.
Herb in Dana Point Ca. April 30, 2013
"Quality equals the price"
I will admit that I enjoyed the first cigar that I smoked out of the 5-pack. The rest were quite unreliable though. My 2nd and 3rd were poorly put together so I ended up getting bits of leaf in my mouth. The last two cigars burned really well but the taste was very bland and I did not get the full flavor I expected from other reviews. I would not buy this cigar ever again.
Ben in Nashville, TN May 4, 2012
"Tastey Short Smoke"
This is a perfect smoke with coffee. I don't know how to describe it but the taste sensation together is outstanding. Really good flavor for such a mild inexpensive smoke.
J in Arizona May 1, 2012
I was pleasantly surprised with this stck. The burn was consistent all the way through, taste was nice and mild. Got a little bitter towards the end. But all in all after a couple months in the humi it turned out to be a pretty damn good cigar.
Austin in Virginia June 5, 2011
"Low quality, ok for price"
I was excited after reading some reviews thinking this could end up being a nice cheaper smoke, unfortunately I was wrong. I was shocked by the poor quality of the the wrapper and especially the cap. It began falling apart before I could even light it up. I like the sweetened cap as a nice change, and the draw was nice and easy, but the flavor was flat at best and I practically had to re-light the thing every time I set it down to turn a page of the newspaper. Overall I think unless you want to practice smoking a robusto in 15 minutes and see how many smoke rings you can blow, there are better smokes for the price.
Arturo Z in Chicago, Il April 19, 2011