Premium Cigars at Discount Prices! Order Toll Free: 1-800-564-2486 Contact Us
Sign Up

Black and Mild By Middleton Reviews

Showing 1 through 10 of 61 reviews

Black & Mild By Middleton Short (5)
I ve never had such an issue with my favorite smoke as MUCH as what I m experiencing now. It seems that at least 1/4 - 1/2 of the cigars have not been evenly tucked into the plastic tip causing an air draw instead of cigar draw . If it s not an issue with the tip, it s an issue with the entire cigar leaf not meeting all the way round the cigars. What s going on? Is the assembly line too fast to care? Where is the end raters ? Do they not SEE what is so visible obvious?
Leila J in Summersville, WV May 9, 2014
Black & Mild (5)
i love the original plastic tip back %26 mild cigars they need too make the vanilla ones available in stores so i can but them 2 i love black %26 milds
steve in madison March 30, 2014
Black & Mild (5)
A friend of smokes these and I believe they are not cigars at all. They re made with pipe tobacco, which is much more appealing than those smelly cigars. If I were to take up smoking again, it would be black and mild. I'm sure they taste as good as their aroma.
Cynthia in NY January 11, 2014
Black & Mild By Middleton Royale (5)
"black%26milds forever"
Gave black%26milds a chance will stay with pipe tobacco cigars all the time never going back to any other brand mike in ct 11/11/13
mike in ct November 11, 2013
Black & Mild (5)
"going back to black%26milds"
Gave black%26 milds another try will be going back to them all the time their smooth taste good and have a good draw and the price is good mike in ct. 11 11 13
mike in ct November 11, 2013
Black & Mild (5)
"best smelling... "cigars"?"
Just amazing. I can't believe they're so cheap! Can't go wrong if you like the taste and smell of pipe tobacco, and want something cheap to have fishing! Or when you don't have 2 hrs. the natural scent is so strong, you might want to have some in your humi just to keep it smelling fresh
der in mn April 12, 2013
Black & Mild By Middleton Short (5)
"Trying to pull through the cigar?"
I use to smoke the first black and mild cigars because they were short and were a good cigar.Then yall started making the black and mild shorts which were fine to start with but then they have gotten to where I can get a pack of 5 and can only pull through 2 out of the whole pack.I have been smoking black and mild cigars for about 30 years now.I started with the long ones and went to the short ones now.I have 5 packs of the shorts left and after I finish them,that's if I can find one of them I can pull through,I am going to try and find a different cigar to smoke that is easier to pull through. Thanks for ruining my most favorite cigar.
scotty barber in wilmington,nc March 19, 2013
Black & Mild By Middleton Royale (5)
"High prices"
Your price is too high. I can buy them in stores at home cheaper and don't have to get them in quantities.
Dale in Van Buren,Ar. March 15, 2013
Black & Mild By Middleton Wine (2)
"Once lit, tastes and smells like a cigarette."
I haven't smoked much. I've spent most of my years smoking E-Cigs as I was trying to avoid the negative effects of smoking actual tobacco, but everyone knows that there's no real substitute for a good smoke. If you enjoy Black %26 Milds, this is an amazing pack for you, as I'm sure that this one is very similar to the others. Flavor-wise, it tastes fantastic before it's lit. Taking a pre-drag I can taste an amazing grape-flavored wine. Smells just like that too. After I've lit it, I get the standard cigarette taste and smell that I've come to dislike. Don't get me wrong, if you like that sort of thing, it's a great deal. If you don't, try to find another product. I would totally buy these again if I wanted a quick smoke.
John in Florida March 10, 2013
Black & Mild (5)
"Save your money."
A friend brought a pack of these over--he doesn't smoke normal cigars, I do--and I tried one. I've heard about these forever. I usually smoke $10 cigars...these taste like cheap, generic, artificially-sweetened dirt. Save your money. Yeah, real cigars cost a bit. A good cigar (i.e., Oliva Serie V Torpedo) is worth every single penny. you get what you pay for, and in the case of black & milds, that's dirt and cancer paper.
Jon in Nashville February 16, 2013
Iron Horse
5-Pack Frenzy...just got a lot crazier!