Showing 1 through 10 of 67 reviews
|
"These are not very good"
Not sure what you guys are smoking but these ... more
Not sure what you guys are smoking but these smokes are not good at all. They burn unevenly, they are not very consistent at all.
After you fire one up they are quite bitter and don't settle down until halfway through the smoke. They smell good out of the humidor, but disappoint bog time.
I found the wrapping to be uneven and veiny and the wrapper coming off.
The taste after reading all the previous reviews led me to believe that this would be like having a Padron or Rocky Patel maduro, not even close. They taste like leather with a hint of earthiness, not chocolate, coffee, nothing.
I'll not be buying these again. less
Jim in Oregon November 14, 2009
|
"Perdomo has done it again"
Plenty of beautiful blue smoke, with a great... more
Plenty of beautiful blue smoke, with a great draw and even burn. TRY THEM you WILL love them. less
M Landers in Portland November 10, 2009
|
"wow loved it"
frind of mine has been smoking these for a bi... more
frind of mine has been smoking these for a bit and said he loved them. He gave me one and now i am hooked great cigar. less
Hap in tinley park September 29, 2009
|
"An excellent cigar for the mild cigar smoker."
Perdomo is one of those companies that makes ... more
Perdomo is one of those companies that makes perfection look simplistic. The Lot 23 is a wonderful, mild cigar that goes well with a good cup of coffee or whiskey. Enjoy them, as much as i always have. less
Thomas in Irmo September 15, 2009
|
"The train stops here"
This was one of the first cigars I've ever sm... more
This was one of the first cigars I've ever smoked, and it really took me on to smoking and encouraged me to try other cigars. The entire time through my journey, this cigar has been my standard and remains my standard for everything I should look for in a cigar. I tried another one this past weekend for the first time since that first cigar and..."aaaah" say no more. The train stops here at the Perdomo Lot 23 for me. Cigars that are more expensive simply are not worth it.. less
in September 15, 2009
|
"Did not dissapoint..."
I thought I try the Lot 23 from a sampler pac... more
I thought I try the Lot 23 from a sampler pack I bought. It looked like a nice well constructed short smoke. Out of the wrapper, it was firm and smelled good. Nice oily wrapper. First light was smooth and it drew perfectly. Lots of creamy smoke, cool and full of spice and earth. Flawless burn with a nice medium kick. I would consider a box of these, for the price I could imagine myself smoking a bunch of them. less
Phil in Illinois September 13, 2009
|
"Nice Cigar"
I got them today and tried one tasted good. I... more
I got them today and tried one tasted good. I liked the flavor but I'm letting them acclimate in my humidor should mellow out flavor. Just such a large cigar it takes all day to smoke.
I would recommend this cigar. less
Randy in Northern California August 25, 2009
|
"My absolute favorite"
1 word, perfect. perfect draw, perfect burn, ... more
1 word, perfect. perfect draw, perfect burn, perfect ash, i love them. Some quality time in the humidor makes them even better. less
Eric in New York August 12, 2009
|
"Dependable stubby stick. Rewards with every puff."
It gets my rating of GFS. These are dependab... more
It gets my rating of GFS. These are dependable fat little smokes. 9 out of 10 that came from the box would reward you with a wonderful taste and something that I think is just as important a scrumptious passive burn. Like all cigars that I have ever purchased there will be the occasional medium to bad smoke. Things like a bad wrap that makes the draw to hard or a really bad burn that has the ember half way up one side and not the other. The 1 out of 10 in this box was maybe just a little off on flavor. Get a box and impress your friends without breaking the bank. I will be ordering another box very soon. Enjoy. less
Paul in Bastrop Texas August 11, 2009
|
"Smooth and Creamy"
Mild,smooth,creamy smoke with good draw and n... more
Mild,smooth,creamy smoke with good draw and nice ash. The only thing keeping it from being a ten is taste. Somewhat bland. However I would recommend these to anyone. less
Wayne in Walling August 6, 2009
|