CAO America Reviews
Showing 21 through 30 of 51 reviews
CAO America Potomac
"bought 5 and wish I had bought a box"
CAO America Potomac
without question this is a fantastic smoke. I tried one at a local lounge one day and bought a 5 pack but later wished i had just bought a box. great flavor and burn ....
Dustin B in New Jersey September 26, 2010
"On the mark"
CAO America Potomac
The CAO America starts out with a nice blast of pepper and wood.. Leather makes an appearance then gives way to coco and coffee as the pepper fades but never says goodbye. The flavors shift nicely down the stick. The smoke is rich, creamy and chewy. Complex, delicious and a must try. .....93.
Cigarme in San Francisco, Ca. September 18, 2010
"A Excellent Smoke. No a Fantastic Smoke!!!!"
CAO America Potomac
Bought 5 after reading about all the blends that make this one up. everything from the cool pinstripe wrap to the thick size was calling out this should be a great smoke. and what a treat it was.I could not put it down. smooth and complex, full of flavor and not heady at all. smoked 3 now and with each one I tell myself get a box. excellent construction perfect burn, a real beautiful cigar, a must try see for yourself..
Ken in Sammamish Washington June 30, 2010
"Very good Cigar"
CAO America Bottlerocket (3)
I am fast becoming a fan of CAO cigars. Bought one of these from my local shop to try before buying a box. This particular cigar is a lot bigger ring gauge than I normally smoke. Cut fantastically. Pre-smoke draw was sublime with a very creamy-nutty flavor which stuck around through the entire stick. The taste was almost that of peanut butter. The second third picked up some very subtle leather and wood notes. The final third picked up the strength of all the flavors above. Had correct the burn a couple times, but nothing major. All in all I will be purchasing many more cigars in this line, just in a smaller ring gauge.
PathsOfDarkness in Utah May 24, 2010
"Fair taste. Poor burn!"
CAO America Potomac
I won a 3-pack via auction and smoked all three during one week. They were difficult to keep lit and not up to the usual CAO standard!
Philip in Glendale, California March 23, 2010
"CAO brings it on!"
CAO America Bottlerocket (3)
I have not smoked many CAO cigars, but I'm glad I gave this one a try. Since I smoked the America Potomac, all I want is more of them! I don't usually get all emotional about a cigar, but I can say I've been thinking about this one since I had her. I would like to see some more deals for this cigar so I can give her a home!
MadRobusto in New York March 15, 2010
"one of the worst"
CAO America Bottlerocket (3)
I normally like CAO cigars, but don't bother with this one. Horrible draw, below average taste and I finally gave up after my mouth got tired trying to smoke this one.
Quaker in Reading, pa October 24, 2009
"the good and bad"
CAO America Bottlerocket (3)
draw was great, the finish was incredible. had a graet cherry chocolate nut finish.the bad part was halfway down, the two types of wrappers were seperating !!! should of stuck to one wrapper.
aj in trenton,nj May 14, 2009
"Poor Draw"
CAO America Bottlerocket (3)
Not much else to say with a draw like this.....
James G. in Cranberry Twp., PA April 24, 2009
"Garbage!!"
Previous Next
I bought these to save for when I wanted a special cigar. I'm really glad I didn't have a time to share them, because I was pissed when I tried to smoke it. Looks great - nice presentation, attractive band and construction - problem is the thing is a lousy excuse for a cigar. Bland taste, won't stay lit, I only smoked half of it, then gave up and got one of my cheapies out of the humidor to try and erase the memory of this loser.
I don't post negative reviews lightly. And I buy a lot of cigars through this site. This one really irritated me. For 8 bucks I expect a special cigar. This wasn't as good as the one dollar Famous Nicaraguans I bought last week, and wasn't a tenth as good as the less than two dollar Flor de Olivas I smoke every day.
Total loser. Do not waste your time, or money on this.
RTS in Wyoming April 11, 2009



