Creme De Jamaica Churchill Reviews [view details]

Give us YOUR review!

Showing 1 through 10 of 10 reviews

"The best"
I have 40 different cigars samples from here and this is the best better than Davidoff I say and this is all I buy
Aaron in Wisconsin July 1, 2011
"An even mild smoke,but nothing special."
An even mild smoke,but nothing special.
Mark in Wisconsin January 10, 2009
"Excellent"
I can't beleive I found my old cigar after all these years. They were intoduced to me by Iwan Reese, of 3 star pipe tobacco fame, in his Chicago shop. Then they made in Jamaica, as was Mac and Royal Jamaica. I haven't been able to find them for 15+. Mac, Royal, and Creme were all the same then but now this one is the old Jamaican aroma of spice. AAA+. Mac lost that aroma. Mr. Reese taught me the flower of the aromas was the reason to some these. It sounds like everyone else doesn't know how to smoke. Tast is irrelevant. The cigar should last for and hour or two by just burning the outer wrapper and diving into the flowery tobacco aroma. Never draw or suck on it! That just gives you a hot burnt taste in your mouth. Just let it burn. These are the best!
Rick in Illinois September 7, 2008
"A.M. W/Joe"
When paired with a cup of coffee it's the only cigar that has given me some vanilla tastes. When paired with anything else they still have plenty of flavor yet mild.
LFS in You Knighted States July 9, 2007
"50 % of the cigars were bad."
I liked the cigars in a sampler, so they were ordered.....what a mistake. Very inconsistent in quality, actually not even half drew right and were abandoned in frustration. I'd never order them again.
Dan Jorgensen in Oceano, Ca January 13, 2007
"Decent, but leaves somthing to be desired"
Recently bought a five pack on Cigar Auctioneer. I found them to be hard to draw, but otherwise a decent smoke for what was paid. I found the taste to lean toward a creamy coffee, but lacking much in spice. I also found the churchill to be a rather hot burning stick. Not something I would buy again, but I will try the robusto.
John in Laurinburg, NC September 5, 2004
"Great cigar for the money!"
I bought a box of the Creme de Jamaica Churchill cigars after a friend gave me one to try on a fishing trip. I thought is was a very good smoke and enjoyed it to the end. I have been just as pleased with the box I bought from Famous. I did find that letting these cigars age in the humidor for a month or two improves the taste. Great cigar for the money!
Robert L. Rubalcaba in Rancho Mirage, California March 5, 2004
"Big in size, but the runt of the litter!"
After smoking and enjoying a good many cigars from the Creme De Jamaica stable, my advice is to avoid the Churchill. Despite a pleasant (if unexciting) taste, the uneven burn and lousy draw makes the effort a bit too much after a 9 hour work day. CDJ generally has their act together when it comes to the Robusto or Lonsdale, but the Churchill is only for the masochists among us! Big in size, but small in enjoyment.
Frederick R Heitman in Charlotte, NC March 4, 2004
"good cigar, poor consistancy"
Got a couple of these in a sampler and liked them enough to order a box. A third or more were plugged to the point of being un-smokeable. No price is right for cigars that go in the trash.
Rodney Woodcock in Arlington, Washington August 27, 2001
"Terrible draw"
Terrible drawing cigar. Not a bad taste.
Dennis in Columbus, Ohio August 16, 2001
Customer Ratings

10 Burn (77) 100
Poor - Excellent

10 Consistency (75) 100
Poor - Excellent

10 Draw (72) 100
Poor - Excellent

10 Appearance (84) 100
Poor - Excellent

10 Taste (78) 100
Poor - Excellent

10 Construction (75) 100
Poor - Excellent


Cigar Auctioneer - Name your price and catch auction fever!
Its time to PUMP UP the savings
Cigar Sniper