Don Tomas Clasico Reviews

Showing 21 through 30 of 65 reviews

Don Tomas Clasico Robusto

"Fantastic First"

I had my first cigar two weeks ago, and it was the Don Tomas Clasico Robusto. since then, i have had the CAO La Traviata, and the Pinar Del Rio Oscuro Robusto. In hindsight, the Don Tomas had the smoothest and tastiest flavour and draw, excellent consistency, an excellent burn, and superior construction. absolutly a cigar i will come back to.

T.e.Cs in Toledo, Ohio October 8, 2010

Don Tomas Clasico Robusto

"Have to agree; excellent every day cigar"

For the price, I have yet to find a cigar that is as consistant as these in terms of construction, burn and taste. There may be better and more full-bodied maduros out there, but I would never be ashamed to give one of these to guest.

JD in Saint Paul September 16, 2010

Don Tomas Clasico Robusto

"Great smoke for price!"

This is my everyday cigar. Great smoke and good value. Consistent quality and a good burn. Girlfriend acceptance factor is high, as she loves the aroma these give!

Bill N in Illinois September 10, 2010

Don Tomas Clasico Robusto

"Military"

This Maduro was quite a surprise upon my first order. The outer wrapper is truly oily and rich and the smoke is first class for such an economical buy. If you're looking for that lunchtime repose, or an after work rehash with a glass of a blended scotch, this cigar is right on target. I found it to smoke evenly and deliver a reliable taste throughout the body of the cigar. You know it's good when you'll risk burning those fingers! I will continue to purchase these box by box due to its reliability and economic value for an every day smoke.

Skeep in Germany September 5, 2010

Don Tomas Clasico Rothschild

"Excellent, consistent smoke at a great price"

I've smoked about a dozen of the Rothschild maduro Don Tomas clasico cigars and was amazed at the consistency and great quality of each cigar for the price. The solid white ash is reminds me of the best Cubans I've enjoyed. Maybe not the most robust taste, but far from bland in a more moderate range of flavor. An excellent 45-60 minutes stogie that I will always keep in my humidor.

Robert in Ann Arbor September 3, 2009

Don Tomas Clasico Robusto

"Great bargain..........."

very good smoke for the price......one or two had some draw issues, but over-all, not bad...will order again.

FT in Florida July 26, 2009

Don Tomas Clasico Coronitas (10)

"A Good Little Quicky"

A nice little smoke for the price. I had been doing Ashton Senoritas, but find these to be a bit milder and more to my taste. I'll stay with these for a while.

W Mitchell in MD July 9, 2009

Don Tomas Clasico Robusto

"Blind Test"

So one night, a couple buddies and I decided to taste a couple of our cigars without the original bands and numbered bands instead. Non of the numbers were the same for each smoker so we couldnt smoke the same cigar at the same time- we did this independently I should mention- Don Tomas was one of our smokes that consistently among all of us was rated among the top 2 out of 6 premium handmade cigars. Excellent smoke, consistent, light start strong finish, and very aromatic even to the nonsmoker. And well priced.

Rob in Iowa May 28, 2009

Don Tomas Clasico Presidente

"...big..."

Having had the Rothchild version of the Classico line, I should have known better. This is a fine looking cigar, great draw but it's just like smoking the smaller brother - a bit harsh and non-descript on taste. Being a larger cigar, it's cool and ok at start but once you pass the midpoint, it becomes noticiably harsh.

Joe in Ottawa Canada May 8, 2009

Don Tomas Clasico Presidente

"WORKING CLASS CIGAR"

SIMPLY ONE OF THE BEST DEALS OUT THERE. NICE DRAW WITH SUPERIOR SPICY FINISH. I SMOKE THESE WHILE MOWING WITH MY WALK-BEHIND HYDRO. GREAT WITH RED WINE!!!

SCOTT K. in HUNTERSVILLE, NC March 21, 2009

Previous Next