Good Days Factory Rejects Reviews

Showing 1 through 10 of 10 reviews

Good Days Churchill

"Pick Something Else"

Not worth the savings. Had much better luck for a daily smoke with machine-made cigars like Philly Titans or GyV. More expensive per stick but they burn twice as long. These things are poorly made and burn fast.

LifeOnAString in NE May 21, 2013

Good Days Robusto

"A Good Machine-Made"

First and foremost, these are tiny little robustos, think of them like big swishers. Burns fast so its good for a quick smoke, construction is inconsistent and iffy at times but they hold together. The taste is sweet and fills the air with a vanilla scent that I've gotten compliments on. Overall this is a really good deal for the price:quantity, I have found these to be a good replacement to Backwoods.

MIchael M. in Salem, OR May 10, 2012

Good Days Perfecto

"Cheap price, cheap cigar. Not bad but not good."

I'm a college student so money is a rare commodity which makes these a perfect buy. The size makes it so it is a nice quick smoke and the quality is consistent given that they are rejects. The problems are usually small blemishes of wrappers or of the caps and nothing that compromises the draw and smoke much. The burn isn't the best and will usually go uneven. The plus really is the price and the size which for me means a quick smoke which is usually what I like. For the price, you get what you paid for, quantity over quality.

Graham in Rochester, NY March 11, 2012

Good Days Churchill

"My regular smoke"

Smoke'em everyday. This is a great buy.

Frank D in New Mexico January 13, 2012

Good Days Robusto

"only machine made for me"

This is the only machine made I smoke. It's a great choice when you don't have the time to sit and enjoy an hour long smoke.

Dewayne in Arkansas October 29, 2011

Good Days Churchill

"Great machine made cigar"

Best machine made cigar I have found, good size, quality & price. Largest size machine made cigar I could find. Secret for me is to remove wraper & let cigar dry out before smoking.

Joe N in Linden, NJ September 9, 2011

Good Days Churchill

"A pleasant surprise"

I'd run low on heco a mano's and tried a box of these on a whim. The construction on the head is terrible, so I clip 'em. Out of the box they tasted like lightly mentholated cardboard, but after a few months unwrapped and held at 70 RH they present a light and powdery floral flavor that I find very pleasant. Excellent cigar when you're down with a cold and you need the comfort, but just can't handle that Indian Tabac Super Fuerte. Good in the parlor, lost out of doors.

Rainman in Franklin MA June 17, 2011

Good Days Perfecto

"excellent value cigar"

If you are forced to smoke 'inexpensive' cigars as I am, these cigars give great value for their cost.

michael frysinger in virginia April 22, 2011

Good Days Perfecto

"just a nice everyday smoke"

When I first started developing a taste for cigars I went to my local tobacco shop with a walk in humidor. I bought a good days Churchill for $1.76, a three dollar cigar, a five dollar and an eight dollar cigar. I found that I preferred the good days. Now with my collection at over 700 I still find that the Good Days Perfecto is a nice 35 min walk with the dog, mild and tasty.

Barry Sherwood in Bloomington MN January 14, 2011

Good Days Robusto

"Gag me with a spoon"

Initial sweet taste. Packed loose. Burns fast. Too hot. Tried as introductory cigars to new smokers but they did not like them. What the heck can I do with the rest of the box?

Juan in Ohio September 24, 2010