H Upmann 1844 Reserve Reviews

Showing 1 through 10 of 10 reviews

H Upmann Reserve Belicoso

"Top 25."

Here's a fine cigar that made CA's top 25 list last year. The blend of the cigar has been changed and for the better. Creamy billows of leather and almonds with a burn your fingers off finish. Rich but not a strong smoke. Just right!

Earl in Tennessee May 10, 2013

H Upmann Reserve Robusto

"smooth and consistent"

very smooth all the way through. had hints of ground coffee, caramel and almonds. Really enjoyed this smoke, would recommend it to beginners and novices alike. Not spicy at all yet full on flavour. A good "go to" cigar. These will age very well in the humidor. I have tasted the cuban blends of Upmann and this cigar exceeded all my expectations.

Saint Germaine in Australia March 18, 2013

H Upmann Reserve Belicoso

"a cut above...."

I smoked a sampler and had a robust 5/50 size good right down to the nub great flavor and burn ...will buy more..

JOE in springfield pa. January 18, 2013

H Upmann Reserve Robusto

"Consistently good smoke"

The entire H. Upmann line gives consistent quality, flavor and aroma. The Reserve Maduro is outstanding and the 1844 line gives an even burn with pleasant woody flavor and aroma---just outstanding!

Mark in Columbia, Missouri July 4, 2012

H Upmann Reserve Robusto

"Class apart!"

The 1844 has a very smooth taste with a wood flavour that lasts almost till the nub. Highly recommend it for beginners!

Prasad in Bangalore July 1, 2012

H Upmann Reserve Lord Rothchilde

"Marvelous smoke, it's now my current favorite"

What a great find this little gem was. Out of 7 cigars I smoke, 5 of them will likely be H Uppmann Reserve Lord Rothchildes. I consider them to be significantly better than the regular H Uppmann #100 Robusto. Great taste without being overpowering, and no negative aftertaste. Burns very well, too.

Mark in Minneapolis September 19, 2007

H Upmann Reserve Double Corona

"My favorite so far"

Ok, I hate to say this, because almost every cigar on this web site has great reviews...but....I really love this cigar. It had a taste that I could pick apart, appreciate. Very nutty, and I could almost say cashew/macadamia nut nuttiness. I know that sounds stupid, but thats what I was tasting almost the entire time. Its a long smoke, and its a big, powerful one. Not for beginners, and I'd reccomend eating before smoking this one. It just about kicked my butt and I usually dont smoke anything but big maduros. Maybe it was just me though....try this stick!

Justin in TN September 16, 2007

H Upmann Reserve Double Corona

"Great Cigar at a Fair Price"

When you consider the price, these are some of the best cigars anywhere. They really are a lot like their Cuban counterparts at a fraction of the price. A little fuller than the average H Upman, they are refined, balanced and complex. A cigar to sit back and enjoy with a good coffee.

Bob in MA July 1, 2006

H Upmann Reserve Double Corona

"The best yet."

Just got this one in a sample bunch. A very pleasent smoke. Good flavor and draw. I plan to keep a bunch of these in my humidor. Goes great with Johny Walker Red Label!

Thomas Cosden in Maryland December 9, 2005

H Upmann Reserve Sir Winston

"Excellent!!"

I haven't smoked one of the Sir Winstons yet, but did get to try a Reserve Torpedo out of a sampler pack! I'm not one to go on and on about how the cigar tasted like nuts, chocolate or berries with a hint of this or that (if you get my drift?)!! The cigar is either bad, good, great or excellent , and the reserve torpedo exceeded my idea of an excellent cigar!! Flavor was medium to full and excellent, aroma was super, held an ash (white) extremely well, and I thought I was going to have to go to the doctor for burnt fingers!! (I hope the Sir Winstons that I won in an auction are as good!!) I give the Reserve a 9 and a half! Not for the smoker who only smokes mild or mild to medium, unless you are ready to make the jump to a "REAL" cigar!! I'll put this cigar up against Cohiba or Trinidad's and come away with a better taste and aroma, plus save a bundle!! lol

Pappy Hewitt in Las Vegas, NV August 11, 2005