Macanudo Cafe Reviews

Showing 1 through 10 of 156 reviews

Macanudo Cafe Hyde Park

"Good construction, terrible taste."

The taste was sour, bitter, and even tart. Not worthy of another try. Stay away unless you are eating or drinking to mask the taste.

TT in NJ May 9, 2013

Macanudo Cafe Gigante

"great cigar, great price"

I have been smoking cigars since 1980 and am one of those long-time medium- to full-bodied aficionados who appreciates a mild cigar of excellent quality from time to time, always in the larger ring gauges. This Macanudo, the 6x60 Gigante, is the perfect mild cigar, consistently tasty and friendly, start to stop, rich and creamy without ever being overpowering. It is a wonderful experience with impeccable draw and construction. It has a nutty, earthy, slightly leathery flavor, like top-grade coffee with a smidge of real cream. If you like the steadfastness of a legend, say a Lincoln, a Caddy, or a good old Imperial, if you like the Hoyo Excalibur Number One, or the Montecristo, you will fall in love right down to the nub.

Steve in Saltsburg, PA April 19, 2013

Macanudo Cafe Miniatures (8)

"Great for a Short Smoke"

Tasty short smoke and gets better as you go. If you don't smoke it like a cigarette it will not be harsh due to its size. You might get one that's rolled to tight but not so often.

JayBee in N.J. March 27, 2013

Macanudo Cafe Court (Tubes)

"Macanudo Courts a perfect choice"

When I'm in the mood for a mild cigar, the Macanudo courts are always winners. Great tasting cigar, mouth watering.

Tony M. in New York March 20, 2013

Macanudo Cafe Court (Tubes)

"Macanudo Court's"

Ignore the mediocre reviews. This cigar is in the top 10 best cigars I've ever had; and I've had a lot of cigars! For me, the Macanudo Court is FLAVOR. When I smoke this, I taste the strong calm flavor of natural tobacco; on other cigars it's often the taste of someones personal attempt to make a special or cheap cigar. To me this cigar is the true taste of tobacco.

Mark J in Santa Barbara March 18, 2013

Macanudo Cafe Court (5)

"Great."

Great little smoke.After lunch or after dinner. Anytime.......

Jim Spillman in Sheridan,Wyoming February 25, 2013

Macanudo Cafe Caviar

"Nice smoke when you don't want a big one."

These are a great tasting, burning, and drawing little cigar for the money. They are mild and creamy and have a lot of smoke. Perfect for the drive home or the cold MN winters when being outside for a long cigar means freezing your weenie.

Doug in St. Cloud, MN January 21, 2013

Macanudo Cafe Ascot (10)

"Not constant quality"

I have smoked Macanudo Cafe for about 5 years and they started out good but in the last 2 years there quality has dropped. They are a good cigar but I get some that have a pin hole or they won't draw I think the tobacco is to moist but over all they are a good cigar they just need more quality control on making them.

Repairman in Ohio January 17, 2013

Macanudo Cafe Gigante

"My #1 Smoke"

This fat one takes home the cake for me, burns nice and even and tast well balanced from begining to end, a wonderful tast and leaves me satisfied not looking to smoke somthing else to get my fix. Love it man

James in San Antonio Texas December 13, 2012

Macanudo Cafe Baron De Rothschild

"Over rated"

Perhaps this was not a "normal" box of Macanudo. These cigars did not burn evenly and when they did they smoked very fast. They did not have a consistant taste and were an overall disappointment. Will NOT buy these again.

Daniel in Memphis October 6, 2012