Macanudo Cru Royale Reviews
Showing 1 through 10 of 10 reviews
Macanudo Cru Royale Robusto
"Not a Fan"
Macanudo Cru Royale Robusto
Everything was great on this cigar except the taste. About 3/4 of the way through it became just plain nasty.
John April 4, 2013
"Not bad"
Macanudo Cru Royale Collection 2012
I've enjoyed these on several occasions, burn was a little off on a couple of em but taste was pretty good, rich taste. The burn corrected itself, no touch ups. A Benji Menendez blend, so I guess being a Partagas fan may be the reason I'm a fan of these. Not a mild smoke, has a little kick to em, nothing earth shattering. Definitely worth a look. Happy smoking!
Marty M in Chicago January 10, 2013
"Great Ashtray! Great Cigars! Great Deal!"
Macanudo Cru Royale Robusto
Great Ashtray! Great Cigars! Great Deal! The drawer makes it a cool little self contained cigar station!
T.J. Hill in Santee, CA USA December 26, 2012
"YUK"
Macanudo Cru Royale Toro
I'm not generally a macanudo fan but these are nasty harsh. shame cause everything else about them is nice just really dry and harsh. Glad I didn't buy a whole box!!
Lee in Phila Pa May 27, 2012
"Uneven burn"
Macanudo Cru Royale Gigante
This cigar would not burn even. Every single one I smoked-10 in all! I have smoked 100's of cigars and never had trouble like this one. I will not buy again!
Robert D. in Michigan May 6, 2012
"super A"
Macanudo Cru Royale Poco Gordo
Loved it... will get more!
Mark H in tyler November 15, 2011
"Whoa!"
Macanudo Cru Royale Gigante
This was the first Rothschild cigar I tried and I got to say I'm impressed. The only thing I'd do differently is to do a punch cut. The draw was too loose for my taste but the aroma and taste were really good and I worked on this cigar well over and hour with some beer. This one is a must try!
Big Moose in Lawrenceville, IL. October 5, 2011
"Great Smoke"
Macanudo Cru Royale Toro
Being a new smoker I tried samplers, and wasn't super impressed by the taste of some. Went to a local shop and bought 2 of these based on a recommendation. While more expensive it was a quick way to get the stick. Excellent smoke. It was great all the way past the label and I can see more ordering a box from FS for the price they are offering these at. So far this stick is one of my fav's along with the San Cristobal and Padron 1964 Anniversary. Waiting to try a few of the Rocky Patel's (1990 and 1992) and the "Edge". But I can tell you this is going to be in my humidor for a long time coming.
Andy H August 29, 2011
"Just a fantastic & smooth cigar."
Macanudo Cru Royale Toro
Just a fantastic & smooth cigar.
Payman K. Afaghi in Stuttgart, Germany March 1, 2011
"A little mild.."
This cigar is not bad, but a little too mild for me. I used to smoke a lot of Mac's when I started smoking cigars but I've grown to like the fuller bodied stronger cigars now. All in all it's not a bad smoke though. The draw is a little tight but I usually don't mind that as I like to nurse a cigar. It did have an ok flavor but very subtle for my tastes. I tried it because I used to smoke a lot of Mac's and wanted to try some of their newer lines. I would recommend it but only if you like a milder flavored cigar. It's nice looking and construction was nice. Burn was also very good, no touch ups needed. A nice cigar I wish it was stronger cause evry thing else was very good about it.
Rock in Milwaukee December 4, 2010



