Premium Cigars at Discount Prices! Order Toll Free: 1-800-564-2486 Contact Us
Sign Up

Montecristo Classic Churchill Reviews [view details]

Give us YOUR review!

Showing 1 through 7 of 7 reviews

"best cigar in a long time"
This is the best smoke I ve enjoyed in a long time! Smooth, flavorful, not overbearing.
njh in san francisco November 26, 2013
"One of my favorite smokes."
This is a mild but very flavorful smoke that has been a consistently excellent smoke for me for at least the last decade. I can't afford to smoke them all the time but I buy a few boxes a year and smoke them when I have friends or family over. They never disappoint. Nice flavor, beautiful aromatic smoke. The least constant thing has been the ash but its not that important to me. For me this cigar is an affordable and enjoyable luxury.
GM in Fort Worth, TX May 3, 2013
"Overrated and overpriced"
At the time of this review the rating for the Classic Churchill natural is a 97. This just seems way too high of a rating. That's next to perfect. Huh!!!??? The cigar seemed to be well constructed, cut easily, but was a little slow to light. The burn was OK, mostly burning consistantly and the draw was very nice. The ash didn't hold up very well as it dropped very early, held a while, then dropped quickly again. This didn't seem to effect the taste though as it has for other cigars I have smoked. The aroma was nice and the taste was good but not "Oh my God" good. A pleasant enough smoke although I was getting bits of tobacco in my mouth regularly. Not that big a deal. It stayed lit with no sign of quiting on me. Overall it wasn't a bad smoke, in fact it was good, but to be rated so high and sell for over $10 a stick I was expecting MUCH more. Taste being subjective, I am glad others like it so much, but for me, I'll pass for cheaper and equally good cigars.
Tony M in Plano, TX July 7, 2012
"Excellent cigar"
This is one of my favorites. Great taste (though mild), great burn, and overall just a great cigar.
John in Columbus November 24, 2011
"Smooth thru Every Draw. No harsh. No bitter. Wow!"
I wanted a Mild cigar. Compared this to the mildest Ashtons, Macanudos and CAO. Only the CAO was close. And, while the CAO had a wee bit more flavor, the Montecristo Classic was consistently smooth from first draw to last. No bitterness at the end, and no disappointing change in texture or creamy smoothness at any third of the stick. Simply put: the smoothest and mellowest and most pleasant smoke available among premium cigars (not including Cuban or Davidoff) - in my experience. There is absolutely nothing wrong with it. And, everything was right. The KING of mild premiums.
Scott in Boston, MA April 17, 2011
"A great cigar at a great price."
Montecristo is a name you can count on for the best in cigar quality.
Barry Pagano in IL May 10, 2008
"a great cigar at a great price."
Montecristo is a name you can count on for the best in cigar quality.
Barry Pagano in Il May 10, 2008
Customer Ratings

10 Burn (95) 100
Poor - Excellent

10 Consistency (96) 100
Poor - Excellent

10 Draw (97) 100
Poor - Excellent

10 Appearance (99) 100
Poor - Excellent

10 Taste (95) 100
Poor - Excellent

10 Construction (98) 100
Poor - Excellent


Cigar Auctioneer - Name your price and catch auction fever!
Amilcar Perez Castro