Premium Cigars at Discount Prices! Order Toll Free: 1-800-564-2486 Contact Us
Sign Up

My Father Reviews

Showing 1 through 10 of 28 reviews

My Father No. 5
"Perfection"
What else can I say, I ve smoked hundreds of cigars from dozens of brands. My Father has always been my favorite but the #5? It is without doubt the best cigar I have EVER had the pleasure to enjoy. When you re looking for a perfect cigar look no further than a My Father #5
Jesse in New Jersey July 17, 2014
My Father Cedros Deluxe Cervantes
"Over rated"
This cigar is ok, but just ok. It is very overpriced for what it is, and there are a lot of cigars out there a lot cheaper, and much nicer. very muddled flavour profile, and not the most consistent burn.
Douglas in New Zealand April 29, 2014
My Father No. 1
"Smooth but lacking in complexity"
During the first third the flavor were jumping all over while never really taking a stand. There was a little cocoa, a little cedar, a little wood, but before you take another puff they re gone... The drying tobacco finally settled around the midpoint, with a medium body and very soft notes on the palate, and occasional flavors of cocoa and bitter chocolate. Sweet mint then started building up on the retrohale, reaching the sweet spot around the nub. In retrospect, I think this medium to full-bodied cigar would be best enjoyed on a warm evening. 89-90 points
Stefan in City by the Bay April 20, 2014
My Father LTD Toro 2012
"A must have in any collection! A++"
What a miraculous cigar! Bought a box for the birth of my daughter to give out to friends and family, so good I bought 3 more box s! Here s to father s every where. This cigar will make you proud!
Keith S. Bayer in Ohio, U.S.A. February 14, 2014
My Father No. 4
"Should be rated in the 90's"
One of my new favorites and in this size range and worth a try. Burns and pulls better then several other brands I have tried in this size. It has the familiar My Father taste and is most enjoyable.
Cody in MD December 18, 2013
My Father Special Robusto
"This is a great cigar!"
This is a bit of a departure for the Pepin clan. Great aroma of fermented tobacco from the unlit stick. It has a bit of tropical flower and smell of a good wine cellar. Smoke is smooth and creamy with light spices that develops into a rich and satisfying experience.
George in Sparks, Nevada October 29, 2013
My Father No. 4
"Great!"
Great cigar. Just like all the others that I smoked in the My Father line. Pantela size is real nice. You'll like it!!
SD in Long Island May 12, 2013
My Father Cedros Deluxe Eminentes
"Excellent"
A strong robust tasting cigar. Keeps getting better the longer you smoke it. Do not hesitate to buy this one!
SD in Long Island, NY April 19, 2013
My Father Cedros Deluxe Cervantes
"wonderful"
Got one of these in the My Fathers sampler from the monster.After sitting in my humi for 3 months I had this one last night.I love every cigar that Jamie Garcia makes and this one is a dream.Great flavor,lots of creamy smoke and a nice burn.Flawless construction as usual and a great full bodied smoke which I prefer. This one was my favorite in the sample box and will buy a box as soon as I get my new humi cabinet set up so I can build a reserve of fine cigars since it is uncertain what the future holds for the cigar industry with pending legislation. This is definately a cigar worth hoarding..lol
Tom in Cookeville,Tn December 24, 2012
My Father 8 Cigar Collection
"Not a dog among em."
While I usually smoke JUST maduro %26 oscaro, I was blown away by the taste and quality of all these cigars.It certainly raised the bar for the type of quality I want.
Larry in st. charles, mo December 16, 2012
Next
Closeout Deals! Save Big!
Rocky Patel Xtreme