Premium Cigars at Discount Prices! Order Toll Free: 1-800-564-2486 Contact Us
Sign Up

My Father Reviews

Showing 21 through 29 of 29 reviews

My Father Cedros Deluxe Eminentes
"bedt opus x alternative"
Fantastic smoke. Firm draw even burn excellent taste that lasts for the entire smoke. Less expensive than the opus x. I love it.
An anonymous smoker October 28, 2011
My Father No. 1
"Excellent, but you need to sit while smoking"
I am generally a maduro guy, but I have to say "WOW" to the My Father No. 1. Draw was perfect on all in the 5 pack I bought. Very full flavor, so you better grab a seat for this one. This is definitely a box worthy smoke.
Rick in Prairieville, LA October 27, 2011
My Father No. 4
"Pleasantly surprised"
I was definitely pleasantly surprised by this cigar. I was worried that a full bodied smoke like this would be too harsh for a novice like myself. I'm by no means an expert but the taste, aroma and burn of this cigar make it a "must smoke". I'll be purchasing more of these in the future for sure.
Joe in Fremont, Ohio August 24, 2011
My Father Limited Edition Toro
"Perfect Cigar"
This is the best cigar made in 2010 hands down! It's even better now that I got the full story behind this cigar from the man himself; Don Pepin at the Hispanic Cultural festival in Coral Gabels. I enjoy this cigar and recommend it to everyone!! If you have a chance get a whole box there is only 2400 of these EVER made. They are unique and will soon be no more. Why are they so special? These were rolled by two of the "cuban finest" Don Pepin and Jaime Garcia. Price? Dont worry about the price is well worth spending it; it will be wonderful experience. Pepin/Jaime Muchas gracias por su producto. Que Papa Dios le de mucha salud y fuerzas para que continuen con sus talento.
Wil Salgado in Marine Corps September 30, 2010
My Father Limited Edition Toro
"Great Cigar"
I smoked one on Friday and another on Sunday. For a fresh cigar it was very good and I believe they will be great cigars after aging for at least a year or two. They were hard to locate but I wound up getting my hands on 5 boxes. After trying the first two I went on a hoarding mission and got as many boxes as I could. The first box cost me $250 but the four others averaged $700 each and will stay in my humidor for the next few years. My friend thought I was nuts until he tried one. Can't wait to see how well they turn out. I would have rated the taste around 95-97 but it only allows for increments of ten. I'm sure it will be 100 after aging.
Rich in Rockaway, New York September 15, 2010
My Father No. 1
"Fantastic"
I first read about this stick in Cigar Aficionado's top 25 list for 2009. I believe this stick came in the top 10 but don't quote me here. I smoked one yesterday at my local cigar lounge. Let me tell you folks, this was a fantastic smoke. I smoked it nearly to the end. I am definitely planning on keeping a box of these in my humidor for personal use ONLY- be selfish with these babies!
Aaron in Little Neck, NY August 1, 2010
My Father No. 1
"Very Enjoyable"
This cigars was recommended to me by a gentleman in a cigar shop in Palm Springs while we were there recently on vacation. So smooth and yet full of flavor. Great draw with a plethora of smoke. This has become my new favorite. Saving my pennies to buy a box!
PJ in Central Oregon July 20, 2010
My Father No. 4
"Pepper builds"
Extremely well made, enjoyed flavor of first half, but way too much pepper for me, in the back of the throat, as I worked through the 2nd half. Don't try on an empty stomach!
Steve in Cincinnati May 2, 2010
My Father No. 2
"Delivers as a premium smoke"
I'm a bit partial to Padron 64's, but I decided to pick up a My Father No.2 the last time I visited my local cigar shop. The cigar appeared great - a medium-brown wrapper with inconspicuos veins. After cutting it, I experienced a perfect pre-light draw, which remained so after lighting from start to finish. The cigar greets the palate with cream, leather, and coffee notes. A medium bodied smoke IMO, without any bitterness or unwanted aftertastes. A very even burn until the final third - It required a quick "touch up" to even itself out. The cap cracked when I initially cut it, but it did not seem to have any appreciable effects on the burn or flavor of the cigar. I will be trying these again soon and I recommend them without any reservation.
Tony in Rochester, MI October 25, 2009
Previous
Best Of - Samplers from your favorite manufacturers!
Amilcar Perez Castro