Onyx Reserve Reviews

Showing 1 through 10 of 174 reviews

Onyx Reserve Toro

"Great smoke"

I was searching for a maduro and liked the reviews for this cigar. I usually smoke Punch After Dinners. The appearance was excelleant. Draw was very good. The flavor was a nice mix of expresso and spice at the end. No off tastes, either. I would rate this equal to or slightly better than, the Punch.

Steve in Hyde Park, New York May 13, 2013

Onyx Reserve Robusto

""Very good! Not great""

Very good look and feel, good draw, but way to spongy! Maybe to overcome the bad draw issues, dark ash typical in piloto cubano, sweet,spicy and creamy...I will buy it again...

Carlos Pimentel in dominican republic April 7, 2013

Onyx Reserve Robusto

"A little over rated"

Appearance looked good, firm yet spongy to the squeeze. Handsome looking cigar. Elegant black gold and white banner. Good burn easy draw. It started out smooth and gradually gave its true blend. It released a gal/tar bitter taste throughout. I think this cigar will appeal to many pallets, but not mine. I?'ll stay with my PDR 1878 Reserva Dominicana Capa Habana.

Ed in Madison, Ohio March 18, 2013

Onyx Reserve Belicoso #2

"Didn't Disappoint"

I had seen this cigar sitting in the giant case humidor of the tobacco store I usually purchase my cigars from and it just kept calling to me. I thought due to it's color and I know it sounds silly but I thought it was going to be an awfully strong cigar but I gave in and I'm glad I did. It was a beautiful easy flavorful smoke not overly strong but not to easy on me either. An amazing smoke and would recommend it to anyone.

Shawn in Clarksville, TN March 5, 2013

Onyx Reserve Robusto

"great smoke but"

sometimes the roll is way to tight bad draw but when good the cigar is awesome.

coz in seattle January 25, 2013

Onyx Reserve #4

"Great little smoke!"

Someone gave me a sampler pack about 3 years ago and one of the sticks was this cigar. I was moving at the time and it ended up in my storage unit (Climate Controlled) in a cedar lined Otter Box. When I dug the box out, the humidity in the box was amazingly, 69%. I put the cigars in my home humidor and forgot about this for another month or so. I finally dug it out and smoked it out on my balcony. I wish I had tried it sooner as it was a great little smoke. It burned very evenly with a nice average draw. It was a little milder than I normally smoke but had a full body flavor. The wrapper was very well aged and had a hint of coffee smell that added to the overall experience. My next order will include a box of these for sure.

Dan in Middletown, CT October 8, 2012

Onyx Reserve #4

"Inconsistent burn"

Have smoked Onyx for years and this batch had the most inconsistent burn in a long time. Had to relight several times.

Steve in Spingport, MI July 25, 2012

Onyx Reserve Mini Belicoso

"Great Smoke"

This is one of my favorite smokes! Woody at the start moving to dark coffee in the final 1/3. Nicely contructed and burned evenly with an appealing appearance. Worth a try but a box is a must!

Joel in Orlando, FL June 2, 2012

Onyx Reserve Robusto

"Too tight"

The #4 is one of my favorites. However this one has too tight of a draw. the tobacco flavor isn't that great and its missing the cocoa and nut flavor that make me love the #4. Pass this one up for now. Its not that great.

Ian in Columbus,Ohio April 28, 2012

Onyx Reserve Toro

"Not bad, great for the price"

Mostly pepper with very faint hints of coffee. Burning wood, campfire like smoke.

Omar in Diamond Bar, CA April 11, 2012