Perdomo Lot 23 Reviews

Showing 1 through 10 of 134 reviews

Perdomo Lot 23 Churchill

"Excellent consistent stick"

There are a lot of nutty reviews for this cigar. It seems most folks have smoked one or two and think they know the cigar. I have smoked 7 boxes of the "natural" and I can attest to their consistent quality construction, appearance, burn, draw, and very tasty flavor. It is my golf cigar because of its consistency. I don't want a stick that I have to fiddle with during a round, either cleaning up a bad burn, loosening a bad draw, or distracting me with a varying taste. I've experience two sticks that I can remember that didn't burn and draw perfectly. And despite what a few reviewers have said, they NEVER get harsh in the final stages. I smoke every one until I can't hold it any longer with two fingertips. If they are well cared for, they will deliver.

garman in San Anselmo, CA March 9, 2013

Perdomo Lot 23 Churchill

"Awesome."

Bought a 5 pack on a whim and was pleasantly surprised. Smooth classic creamy Maduro taste, great construction. Was down to one in the box and just had to get more. A must have for Maduro fans!

Carlo in NYC January 8, 2013

Perdomo Lot 23 Robusto

"very nice smoke"

I have to say this robusto is in my top 5 list.full of flavor with lots of smoke and a finish that lingers in the palate.has a nice even burn and didn't have a bitter taste after relighting it.I am very happy with this one.

Paul in upstate New York July 22, 2012

Perdomo Lot 23 Churchill

"Nice smoke, not a 90+"

The 90+ rating for this cigar is insane, that said the extremely negative ratings are insane as well. This is a very good mild-to-medium cigar of excellent construction and consistantly good though not all that exciting flavor. It is a good lower cost cigar to stock the humidor with and is well worth the premium over the no-name el-cheapos from Famous and others. I always keep a box or two around.

Macrophylla in NC June 9, 2012

Perdomo Lot 23 Robusto Connecticut

"Great cigar for the price"

Wow this is such a nice cigar. Very nice flavor and burns well. These were worth every penny.

B in KC, KS May 28, 2012

Perdomo Lot 23 Robusto

"Save your money!!!"

What a letdown. Big Perdomo fan , but this was horrible!!!! No Taste, No character!!!!

Scott in Mesa AZ May 25, 2012

Perdomo Lot 23 Robusto

"Let em rest!!"

My revised review. Let these rest a minimum of 4-5 months, and you will be pleasantly surprised.

Ryan May 9, 2012

Perdomo Lot 23 Churchill

"Smokeable"

Not much to say about this one. Its smokeable. Nothing close to a 90+ rating. I'd give it a 85 at most. I've had some cheap churchills for a few bucks less with a lot more flavor and a way better finish than this. It was a rather boring tobacco flavor all the way down to the last 2" where it got so harsh and gross I finally put it out. Will not buy again. It also went out on me a few times and I am not horridly sparing with my puffs. After the halfway mark it needs to be puffed a little too often to make it stay lit.

Ian in Columbus,Ohio May 1, 2012

Perdomo Lot 23 Gordito

"Flavorful....."

Wow! Been smoking Cigars for about a year and this stick is my fave thus far. Ranked up there with the Cuban Cohiba I recently bought in Mexico. Try it!

Joel in Aurora, CO April 26, 2012

Perdomo Lot 23 Churchill

"Whoa, whoa, whoa....hold on a minute"

I'm not saying this is a bad stick. I"m not saying that at all. What I am saying is that there is no way this is a 90+ rated stick. It's mild, the flavor profile is boring, and it is way over priced at 5.00 per cigar. This is a good value in the 2-3 dollar range. I'm genuinely puzzled by the rave reviews this is getting.

Omar in Diamond Bar April 24, 2012