Private Stock Reviews

Showing 1 through 10 of 79 reviews

Private Stock #14

"don't waste $80"

Worthless junk

Samvel in Jacksonville March 23, 2013

Private Stock #2

"Not A Bargain"

I am mystified by the generously high ratings this cigar has received. In my opinion, this smoke is no bargain: It simply has no personality, is devoid of all flavor. Likely, I'll end up tossing out the remaining 24 and place an order for some of my regular reliables.

Ry Austin in Salt Lake City February 11, 2013

Private Stock #1

"Very nice smoke"

Consistantly pleasing cigars. I found them several years ago on a trip to Amsterdam. tried many others but prefer these for an every day smoke

Mark in Fort Worth Texas November 5, 2012

Private Stock #1

"Best cigar"

I keep trying other brands but keep comming back to this one.

Yochanan in Los Angeles September 4, 2011

Private Stock #1

"Perfect Burn and Great Flavor"

I found these to burn and taste as good or better than some of my much more expensive Dominican sticks. No touch-ups required and great draw and flavor. Great construction as well.

Cliff J in Virginia July 25, 2011

Private Stock #14

"Damn fine cigar for the money!"

I've been buying several different cigars to determine my new favorites. I bought these based on the recommendations. I have to say that I was very pleasantly surprised to find these an enjoyable smoke. I can definitely see myself adding more of these to my auxillary humidor.

Scott in Indiana May 6, 2011

Private Stock #6

"Excellent Value"

If you like a milder, silky Dominican you'll like these. IMHO comparable the premium mild Dominicans for half the price. Tried a single--will now be odering a box.

Mills in Delaware April 8, 2011

Private Stock #2

"Excellent for the Price"

Been smoking them for a couple years now, have been a good smoke for the price. I agree, they do age well too.

Haus in CO April 1, 2011

Private Stock #14

"Fine Cigar"

These cigars are as good or better than most 94 or 95 rated cigars that I have smoked.

Ronald Wall in San Antonio March 17, 2011

Private Stock #1

"Great everyday Smoke"

Great everyday and golf cigar. Always consistant.

Ronald Wall in San Antonio March 17, 2011 February 23, 2011