Private Stock Reviews
Showing 21 through 30 of 79 reviews
Private Stock #14
"What a nice surprise"
Private Stock #2
I read the great reviews for this cigar so I thought I'd give it a try. I wasn't expecting alot from it considering the price. Boy was I proven wrong. This cigar is the best value out there. It was an awesome smoke, it had a great flavor and it produced nice thick, smooth smoke. Please try it for yourself, you wont be disappointed.
Chris in Maryland July 20, 2009
"Enjoyable, good draw and taste!"
Private Stock #2
Smoked the Davidoffs on special occasions-excellent cigars. The Private Stock ll is a very enjoyable smoke at a great price. Will add more to the humidor.
Gregg in Columbia SC July 10, 2009
"Great Value"
Private Stock #2
Bought a box of the #2 and what a great value. Like to smoke higher end sticks and for everyday use ranks up their with much more expensive cigars. Will be making this a regular buy. Can't miss.
Bill in Marinette, Wi March 10, 2009
"Tasty lunch time treat"
Private Stock #2
Just had a robuston natural at lunch on a cold chicago day with a nice cup of coffee and what a treat. I am no aficianado but man that hit the spot. Price is right.
Tom C in Chicago January 6, 2009
"very fine cigar, however some with sour/acrid tast"
Private Stock #14
the natural #2 is an overall fine cigar. Recommend aging for one month or more for smoother taste.
csl in florida December 30, 2008
"New Number One!!"
Private Stock #14
I received my first box this Christmas and I was not at all disappointed. The quality is that of an AVO or Davidoff, but the price is very reasonable. The smoke was an awesome experience with a nice draw, tons of thick beautiful smoke, and flavor that was sophisticated, yet pleasant. I am a bargain mild to medium guy and this one is now my all time favorite. Thanks Famous Smoke!!
-Scot Ashton
P.S. See you at the 2009 BBQ Bash!
Scot Ashton in Burlington, KY December 27, 2008
"Nice smoke with an equally nice price"
Private Stock #2
No complaints here. As good if not better than many more expensive smokes.
Paul in Longview Washington October 28, 2008
"One of the best, for the price"
Private Stock #2
I have tried CAO gold, AVO, Ashton 898, Romeo Y Julieta Reserva Real, PS#2 is the absolute show, Mild, flavorful, Excellent notes of PB, Cedar, Light toasted almonds. MY #1 FAV,Great all aroud home stoge or a handout. Dave COLUMBIA SC.
Dave in South Carolina October 24, 2008
"Consistently a smooth mild smoke."
Private Stock #14
Construction sometimes vary, but in general, a reliably smooth, mild smoke.
Michael in Newnan, GA October 8, 2008
"What a shade-wrapped cigar is all about."
Previous Next
Excellent mild toast-leather flavors that build through the length of the cigar. This is one flavor profile Cuba still hasn't got right. After half the cigar you'll stop and notice the great
leathery flavor in the middle of your tongue. Wow.
Steve in The Village July 12, 2008



