I tried Punch before when just starting out a...more

I tried Punch before when just starting out and didnt care for the peppery taste that I experienced. Now more experienced thought I'd try the 5 pack roth natural. Still dont care for it as it still tatstes peppery with a slight hint of caramel. I work evenings so I dont have a meal right before a cigar, so I have one with usually a rum and coke or maybe brandy. Just doesnt go well with my taste and I go mild to full. I can see this being a cigar for an after dinner like a steak or seafood( something rich to complement the cigars peppery taste). I'm not knocking this cigar cause I can tell this is a good cigar but I dont match well with it. So far, no problems with burn although ash doesnt hang very long for me. I'll let them sit in humidor until nothing left to see if anything changes, you never know. less

This cigar tasted horrible. I am used to smok...more

This cigar tasted horrible. I am used to smoking medium to full flavored cigars, but this one tasted... It didn't even have a flavor, it just tasted bad. The construction is good and the burn is decent. I would not recommend this cigar to anyone unless your already a fan of the brand. less

I couldn't smoke one of these every day altho...more

I couldn't smoke one of these every day although I have friends that could. I like variety and that includes a premium cigar every now and then. Out of my supply of everyday smokes I occasionally select a Punch Rothschild or Champion. I have always found them to be a good medium smoke that is slightly sweet and spicy but not harsh. My only complaint is that the wrappers are sometimes fragile on the rothschild especially if you age them. A very good cigar for the money. less