Rocky Patel American Market Lonsdale 5 pack Reviews [view details]

Showing 1 through 1 of 1 reviews

"A "95" rating??? I beg to differ..."

I was really expecting..."Awesome"... especially because of the 95 rating...but this one is NOT a 95...not in my book. I think anyone could live with a cigar having a bit of an uneven burn, minor inconsistencies in appearance and even slight draw differences... but if it's lacking a smoothness or a great taste, why bother smoking it??? All factors were great...but it was harsh on the first few draws, but then got smoother. All throughout, it just lacked a nice taste. I bought a 5-pack and the one I smoked rest for about 2 months in my humidor...the other 4 will sleep for quite a bit longer with the hopes of improvements.

MD in NJ March 18, 2013

Customer Ratings


10	Burn (95)	100
Poor		Excellent

10	Consistency (97)	100
Poor		Excellent

10	Draw (95)	100
Poor		Excellent

10	Appearance (98)	100
Poor		Excellent

10	Taste (93)	100
Poor		Excellent

10	Construction (95)	100
Poor		Excellent

CigarMonster - New killer cigar deals every day!