Rocky Patel American Market Selection Robusto Reviews [view details]
Give us YOUR review!Showing 21 through 30 of 40 reviews
"Lives up to its reputation"
I read the reviews regularly but have never written one, but I bought a box of these based solely on these reviews (and the great deal being offered by Famous) and I was NOT disappointed. Yes, it is a mild smoke, and I am still finding my preferences in the mild-medium categories. But this stick is gorgeous with a lot of flavor happening. I can't normally describe cigars with "tasting" terms, but I swear I tasted vanilla notes, a mild spice, and a light leather as this gem progressed. I have only smoked 3 different Rockys so far, but this is the first to make me go WOW. Well done.
Bodhidhala in Columbus, OH August 5, 2009
"Very nice..."
Usually smoking medium to full bodied cigars, I got this one in a sampler pack and gave it a try. Very nice looking cigar as are all of Patel's - 'blonde'. The pre-lit fragrance was very light. The cigar didn't feel as tight and packed as normally found with Patel's line. The taste was light and a bit sweet - mellow up until the last inch - very pleasant. I enjoyed this cigar with Gentleman Jack - a nice experience.
Joe in Ottawa Canada August 3, 2009
"Rocky Knows How to Make Them!!"
A bit fast at the start, then it mellows down and has a great smooth flavor. Not overpriced at all. Burned great, amazing draw, looks amazing and never gave a hint of ripping apart. A MUST TRY FOR ALL ROCKY AFICIONADOS!
Kyle in Indiana July 20, 2009
"Rocky Knows How to Make Them!!"
A bit fast at the start, then it mellows down and has a great smooth flavor. Not overpriced at all. Burned great, amazing draw, looks amazing and never gave a hint of ripping apart. A MUST TRY FOR ALL ROCKY AFICIONADOS!
Kyle in Indiana July 20, 2009
"Worth every cent"
This cigar is a must--especially for the price.
Chloe in Lehigh Valley, PA May 12, 2009
"A bit weak, but a good cigar"
This cigar is definitely for those who prefer a mild smoke. Lots of smoke, but very mild. A bit flat on the flavor, but enjoyable. As is normal with Rocky Patel, the construction is excellent. This cigar earns an 85 for those who go mild.
Steven in West Palm Beach January 8, 2009
"A Rocky Knockout!"
The competition is down for the count - what a great value! I enjoyed my first robusto American Market when I received a nice box of RP Vintage 1990 Maduros. Although I generally smoke a Padron, the sampler pack that came with my Maduros was an eye-opener. My first RP's! I was floored by the mild but aromatic flavor and aroma. Build construction is very nice for this robusto. Draw is plentiful, with a delicious, chewy cap not long after the start. A lot of smoke with this stick. Superb for relaxing. Love the mild aftertaste. A definite winner.
Steven in West Palm Beach December 23, 2008
"A Smooth & Relaxing Smoke..."
Great flavor, smooth finish. Perfect cigar to relax with on a warm summer afternoon...
Scott S. in Wisconsin October 9, 2008
"Very Pleasant Cigar"
I am new to smoking cigars, but this will be a smoke that stays in my humidor. A perfect ten.
Cason in Youngsville September 13, 2008
"Great cigar"
This cigar is awesome, perfect draw, awesome taste, and great construction....couldnt have asked for more.
Steven in Michigan June 23, 2008






