Romeo Y Julieta 1875 Reviews

Showing 11 through 20 of 176 reviews

Romeo Y Julieta 1875 Bully

"Perfect 10 out of 10"

All i have to say is WOW! very good cigar for the price, Very earthy,peppery and leathery flavors.

ian in Santa Fe NM July 31, 2012

Romeo Y Julieta 1875 Petit Julieta 5/8

"Nice small cigar"

This is one of my favorite 3 small cigars. Slighty sweet but good taste and very nice aroma. Smoked over five 40 packs in the last several years. Wish you other smokers would stop bidding up the cost of this auction item

PSN in Kaneohe, Hawaii June 28, 2012

Romeo Y Julieta 1875 Bully

"No "there!" there."

I must have smoked a bad one. I noticed nothing noteworthy in a good way about this smoke except, it burned good. Very dry tasting smoke. The wrapper fell apart in one spot but stopped. Not too harsh but no flavor that I could detect. Disappointing. Very bland and blah. I've had worse but, I won't bother with these again.

Terrance in El Dorado June 9, 2012

Romeo Y Julieta 1875 Churchill Tubo

"Mandatory for any smoker!"

My absolute favorite, If you don't have a couple of these in your humi - I don't know why you have one...

Aaron in Modesto,CA April 28, 2012

Romeo Y Julieta 1875 Romeos Court

"Just okay."

Not a bad smoke, just not epic. Good tobacco flavor, but without any spice. A little toast, and mildly astringent on the back of the throat. These were aged 1+ year in humidor out of the tubes. The prelight aroma is very nice.

JD in So.Cal. April 15, 2012

Romeo y Julieta 1875 Magnum

"Good Smoke"

good burn,very consistent,very good draw,great appearance,taste ok,very good construction,over all a very good Cigar!

Christopher in New Mexico April 13, 2012

Romeo Y Julieta 1875 Bully

"$4. entree fee to Nirvana..."

Nice pre cut cap. Nipped it by tooth. Came out perfect. Nice even burn and spicy start that mellows in the second third. Slow it down during the last third, or it will get hot. Over all, was smooth with light to medium and slightly complex. Finish varied from beginning to the nub. These are great with coffee. For the price, I guess I'm hooked.

splattttttt in Boston April 6, 2012

Romeo Y Julieta 1875 Clemenceaus

"Hopefully I Just Got a Bad Cigar"

I was not pleased with the particular cigar I purchased, but I will be fair to both the cigar and Romeo y Julieta. I really like Romeo y Julieta's Reserve Real and I do like their cigars in general. The particular cigar I purchased would not burn evenly, the very center of the filler would not burn hardly at all, and it produced so little smoke I couldn't taste it. I have to be honest and overall the only thing that was nice about the cigar was it's appearance. To be fair it probably was just a bad cigar I got, and I did purchase another one with it. I'm going to let the other one age and stay in my humidor for a few months and go from there. I'm by no means an expert on cigars and I've only been smoking cigars since last August. So, I'm still figuring out what I like and my tastes. Like the saying goes, "Take the bad with the good" and that's especially true with cigars.

E Motley in Virginia April 4, 2012

Romeo Y Julieta 1875 Bully

"Perfect"

New cigar smoker, I smoke one almost every Sunday while cooking and by far great flavor, burn and aftertaste. Super with few Sam Adams. Not much of nicotine taste "I do not inhale"

Tanner in New York March 10, 2012

Romeo Y Julieta 1875 Julietas (10)

"great cigar for poker breaks.....12 min burn"

nice cigar at fair price for a person that has under 15 minutes for a good smoke

rufus p in ohio February 29, 2012

Previous Next