Showing 1 through 5 of 5 reviews
I have smoke 4 out of the box so far and 2 would not stay lit. The taste is just OK but with the construction issues, I would grade this cigar an F.
Ed in New England June 14, 2014
I had this in my humidor for about a month before I tried it. Burn was excellent until I got down to the band then it was hard to keep lit for some reason. Flavor, draw, and construction were all excellent.
Brian in STL May 7, 2014
"Excellent cigar for the $$$$"
Excellent cigar for the $$$$, great taste, consistently great burn! Go for it and take a chance.
Patrick Garrity in Massachusetts January 22, 2014
The taste and aroma of this cigar was good. It has a mild flavor that did get a little stronger towards the end. However, it burned unevenly the entire time. Also, it felt like it was not wrapped very well, by gently pinching it I could tell it was very loose. Also, when taking a draw I could feel the heat on my finger tips and in the smoke. Overall I'm disappointed with this one. I bought the "test flight" w/ six and we save the remaining 4 and just burn them when I want the aroma only.
AJ in La March 29, 2013
Save your $. Bought a box of Fat Churchills and smoked half so far. They look nice, draw okay and light easily, but keeping them on an even burn is a constant battle. I gave them a high rating for consistency because they consistently burn poorly. The taste is mild, but they do pick up in strength as they smoke down (Duh!) and then start to get a bit too sour near the end. What a shame...
Joe in San Diego, CA September 13, 2012