| View Cart | [0 Items | $0.00] |
Saint Luis Rey Reviews
Showing 21 through 30 of 120 reviews
Saint Luis Rey Rothchilde
"My favorite cigar hands down!"
Saint Luis Rey Rothchilde (non cello)
I don't remember where I had heard about this cigar, or if I had just won it in auction, but I am sure glad that I tried it! The look of this cigar pulls you in first. It is a solid cigar, perfect size, appealing label. Once I lit it, I was like "WOW!". Great burn, strong gray ash, and great taste! All this for a $2 stick? Incredible! I smoke all kinds of cigars, but this is my home slice!
Jim in Indianapolis, IN February 6, 2010
"Best Bang for the Buck!!!"
Saint Luis Rey Rothchilde (non cello)
I have smoked between 10 and 20 of these and I have never had one that burned bad or tasted bad. In fact, from my experience, this cigar burns better than cigars 5x the price! This cigar is always welcome in my humidor and you'll normally find it there!!
Jim in Indianapolis, IN January 29, 2010
"Great Cigar @ a Great Price!"
Saint Luis Rey Luisitas (10)
This is one Great cigar! Awsome flavor, aroma and price. Has a nice creamy taste and loads smoke. I gave some to my father for CHRISTmas and he was very impressed with it too. I found a new everyday smoke.
Jeffrey in Crawfordsville December 25, 2009
"One of my Favorites"
Saint Luis Rey Luisitas (10)
To start off, I'm no connoisseur of cigars; I tend to focus on the cheaper end of things to begin with, excepting the occasional CAO or Macanudo when I'm in the mood. As such, I'll admit my main reason for purchasing these to begin with was the fact it was a Maduro wrapper at a low price. Once tried, however, it proved far better than expected.
It's a harsh smoke; not going to lie and claim otherwise. If you like your smokes mild, avoid it like the plague. The flavor, however, is impeccable. Rich, thick, albeit not always very multifaceted. It burns at a decent speed, and I've never had one go out on me, albeit I tend to puff more regularly than most. I also tend to suffer from my cigars unraveling or canoeing, and I've never had one of these things do either.
The only real criticisms I can mention are the rather harsh flavor (Which I personally prefer) and a somewhat difficult draw. This thing certainly isn't the greatest cigar ever made, but if you're in the mood for a maduro of this size, and don't want a bleeding wallet, this thing is your best friend.
Highly recommended. Though, to my (limited) experience, this does not always continue to other cigars by the same company.
Darrin P. in NY November 23, 2009
"Eh....."
Saint Luis Rey Rothchilde (non cello)
Very tightly rolled, and hard to keep lit. Once you do get it to burn, the taste ain't bad. Hard to enjoy a cigar you when its so hard to draw. Like sucking a really thick milkshake thru a skinny straw. Don't think I will puchase these again.
Benjamin in The Dalles, OR November 20, 2009
"Where have these babies been?"
Saint Luis Rey Rothchilde (non cello)
I am always in search for that one great cigar for a good price. Tried a box and now I am hooked. Great taste, good draw and burned well down to the nub. I will always have these in my box. I can now rest.
PapaG in Tampa FL November 14, 2009
"Disappointing is an Understatement"
Saint Luis Rey Churchill
Very Disappointed in this smoke. Had 2 of them after sitting in my humidor for a while. Both were extremely hard to draw. Not much flavor at all on the Cigar. Aroma was non-existent. Did not really find anything rewarding about the cigar except its unlit appearance. I would say pass on these duds.
James in NH October 20, 2009
"Cigar Aficionado"
Saint Luis Rey Rothchilde (non cello)
This my 100 cigar of this brand I have not seen a blank This a Excellent cigar of the price the only thing that is not of stellar quality is the burn which occasionally ma not be even but other than that is exquisite, well constructed and very balance flavor is an enjoyable cigar in a very good price. extremely consistent in flavor and construction
Bob in FL October 12, 2009
"Good smoke for the price"
Saint Luis Rey Corona
Good smoke for the price! Nice, smooth taste as you get down to the nitty gritty. Burn could be a little uneven, but for the price, it is a good value.
William in Illinois August 28, 2009
"great taste, not so great burn"
Previous Next
These cigars taste great but the first two that I lit up did not burn evenly. I had to fight with the burn the whole time which made it a little frustrating to smoke. Im hoping I just got a bad batch because I like the taste of these.
Jeff in South Korea August 9, 2009
Loading...