Premium Cigars at Discount Prices! Order Toll Free: 1-800-564-2486 Contact Us
Sign Up

Saint Luis Rey Rothchilde (non cello) Reviews [view details]

Give us YOUR review!

Showing 11 through 15 of 15 reviews

"Made my mouth water!"
I wasn't expecting this cigar to be as enjoyable as it was by the price I paid. It was a beautifully made cigar, and the pre-light smell was nice. From start to finish this was a fantastic full bodied smoke. It really got my mouth watering too, which is a good sign. Based on this experience, I would invest in a box.
Eric D. in Maryland October 19, 2006
"Great Full Bodied Flavor - A Keeper!"
Have been smoking the Punch - Double D - Roth for over five years and in last five months found them to be terrible at best. Inconsistent draw, burn and especially taste. Tried the St. Luis Rey Roth and have fallen in love. Nice full bodied smoke, burn and draw have been great and consistent and best of all it not only looks great, it is, this one's now "A Keeper".
Len Crouch in Albany, NY July 30, 2004
"What a smoke!"
I saw these in the smoke shop humi and had to give them a try. The rothchilde is a whopper of a smoke not overpowering.I burned mine alway to the nub and it never got spongy. Draw was a little tight in the middle but got better as it went on. The aroma is sweet and the flavor is top notch in this price range.
J.C. in Madison,WI July 25, 2004
I gave these a try and was very glad I did. I don't know what the line was like b/4 as I am new to this game but I found these to be great. Meaty is the best way I can describe them. Very filling. Hints of dark coffee, and molassases. Another one that will go great with a good cup of french roast coffee.
JOHN B in MONROE NY July 9, 2004
"Rapidly becoming my everyday favorite!"
This cigar has it all: full flavor, even burn, tight ash, and beautiful packaging. When you smoke this number, you better have an hour or more to just relax and enjoy. The flavorful smoke shouts spice and wood with delicate hints of cocoa. The ash holds together and does not flake all over you. Even with a poor uneven light, this cigar fixes that and maintains an exceptional burn right down to the nub. I'm always just a little bit sad when I finally have to put this one down because my fingers begin to feel the heat. Thank goodness there is another one in my humidor. For me, this is nearly a perfect 10 and is rapidly becoming my new everyday favorite.
Steve Cassell in Citrus Heights, CA March 13, 2004
Customer Ratings

10 Burn (85) 100
Poor - Excellent

10 Consistency (85) 100
Poor - Excellent

10 Draw (85) 100
Poor - Excellent

10 Appearance (91) 100
Poor - Excellent

10 Taste (89) 100
Poor - Excellent

10 Construction (88) 100
Poor - Excellent

Create-A-Sampler - Create YOUR ultimate sampler and save!
Closeout Deals! Save Big!