Premium Cigars at Discount Prices! Order Toll Free: 1-800-564-2486 Contact Us
Sign Up

Siboney Reserve Reviews

Showing 1 through 10 of 12 reviews

Siboney Reserve Robusto
"Very tasty...good quality for the $"
I have purchased several boxes of these and I find them to be a really good smoke for the bucks.
Ron in TN June 14, 2012
Siboney Reserve Robusto
"Nothing Special"
Not to happy with this stick. Very little flavor and a bad burn.
Chris in New Jersey October 12, 2011
Siboney Reserve Robusto
"Fairly impressed...good value"
Very relaxing, but not overpowering. The taste itself wasn't the best and it did go out 3 times, but got a good 1.5 hour smoke out of 5" cigar and enjoyed it. Better than most. Worth considering for cheap off-brand cigar.
David B in Austin TX June 8, 2011
Siboney Reserve Test Flight
"Save your money"
Tried one of these cheap cigars,threw the rest in the burn pile. I will buy quality from now on.Rocky Patel/Nub..Cant go wrong.
Thomas in Placerville Ca. February 18, 2011
Siboney Reserve Test Flight
"Save your money"
Tried one of these cheap cigars,threw the rest in the burn pile. I will buy quality from now on.Rocky Patel/Nub..Cant go wrong.
Thomas in Placerville Ca. February 18, 2011
Siboney Reserve Robusto
"Good Smoke"
I got a few of these in a sampler and I must say I was impressed by the good burn and mild yet full flavor. Not a bad smoke for the money.
Zach S in Ventura CA February 15, 2011
Siboney Reserve Churchill
"good taste, terrible burn"
I picked up the test flight on the auction house. The taste was good but the burn was terrible, I couldnt keep it from canoeing for the life of me and the draw was difficult.
david in kent, wa January 2, 2011
Siboney Reserve Churchill
"Skip it"
There is a reason Rosado wrappers are rarely used anymore: the taste. I realize taste is subjective and these are definitely unique tasting smokes. However, different is not always good. They taste primarily of dried wood, and the smoke is very thin. Buy something else as even at auction prices this smoke isn't worth it.
A.D. in Rochester, NY November 19, 2010
Siboney Reserve Churchill
"a new addition to my favorites"
A great smoke at twice, maybe even 3 times the price. As a fan of fine cigars, I usually have to scale back my expectations when I have a less expensive cigar, but Siboney Reserve proves to be a fine cigar at an everyday price. Good draw, nice smoke, even burn, and a great flavor all the way through. And for those like me who are impatient, they're great right off the truck, although time in the humidor has proven to bring out the flavor nicely.
Brian in Camarillo, CA August 16, 2010
Siboney Reserve Churchill
"A Very Pleasant Smoke"
Pepin fans will find this cigar a bit tamer than his usual fare, as I would consider it in the medium-to-full category. As one would expect, there's a bit of spice and a healthy dose of leathery, woodsy flavor. The taste is consistent from first puff to the nub. The draw is easy and produces a thick volume of smoke. It provides an exceptionally smooth smoking experience and a near-perfect burn. All-in-all, this cigar is an excellent value.
Don R. in Pensacola, FL July 1, 2010
Next
La Floridita Fuerte
Rocky Patel Xtreme