Supervisor Selection Torpedo Reviews [view details]

Give us YOUR review!

Showing 1 through 10 of 11 reviews

"No thanks"
I wish my experience was as good as others have posted. This cigar tases bad. I was hoping a month in the humidor would do some good. I won't be buying these again. As far as bundles go, I will stick with the Famous brand.
chris in minneapolis May 9, 2012
"Excellent Smoke"
I was very impressed. This is my everyday go-to Cigar.
Ed S in Jasper, Alabama December 6, 2011
"Outstanding!"
Got my bundle in the mail this afternoon. 19 went into the humidor, but one was lit immediately. Wow! Hard to believe a cigar this great came at such a low price. Agree with earlier post...take it slow. Well worth the time. Just shy of 2 hours and it was smooth the whole way. Great burn, good draw and killer flavor! I have gotten other bundles in the past only to be disappointed. Well not anymore. A must have for every humidor.
Barry in Holly Springs, NC October 17, 2011
"A Great Smoke"
Great cigar. I just ordered a bundle and had to try one out. The draw is really nice. Excellent draw, nice flavor and full rich smoke. Definitely a great buy. I can't wait to see how the develope with age.
John Hart in Racine,WI August 13, 2011
"Fantastic!"
Better than the Maxx traditional for me, full of flavor, rich and smooth strong, very unique. Great price for a premium cigar. I wasn't terribly impressed with the maxx traditional, but these were incredible, super fresh on arrival and great aroma. Highly recommended.
Jazzi in canada August 14, 2010
"Just like the Maxx Curve"
This is a terrific smoke. It has a great draw, burn and taste. There are three things you don't get with this cigar. (1) The box, (2) The band and(3)The price. It is identical. If you can't beat'em, smok'em. Truely a great smoke for the money. I have and will keep on buying them.
Bad Smokey in Saint Augustine, Florida February 25, 2010
"Slow down and enjoy"
The Supervisor Select Torpedos are super impressive! They beg to be smoked slow and not over heated, sipped not chugged. If you're in hurry and not paying attention, you might miss all the complexity this great smoke has to offer. If you smoke these fast, they will sour early, and may disappoint. So put aside a couple of hours, sit back with intent, and be prepared for 2 hours of a total mind and body experience, being rewarded with mouth watering flavors that will lay you back in your favorite chair hoping the moment never ends. These smokes are one of the best values out there, and have earned a permanent position in my humidor. Beautiful construction with a very tough but silk smooth wrapper, a great draw with an even burn. I feel like I'm stealing every time I buy these. Truly a great find. "Life is too short for a bad cigar"
Whupash in Milwaukie, OR August 4, 2009
"A mirror to the Maxx Freak!!"
Bought a bundle two weeks ago of the 6 x 60. I also have the Freak in my humidor. If you hold them up together the band is the only reason you can tell them a part. Taste is medium to full... very nice draw... taste very smooth lots of smoke. Not just another cigar for the price... It's just an outstanding cigar by any means.
Larry in MIchigan USA July 27, 2009
"A Really Great Cigar"
One fine cigar for the money. Slow burn, good draw, nice ash, smooth. This is one of those rare "surprises". Buy extras, you won't regret it.
R L in Texas January 16, 2009
"Rich tobacco taste"
I've had a few of these and what I've liked about them is the rich tobacco taste, with a bit of sweetness to it. A couple of weeks ago I had one that had a poor draw to it, seemed hollow in the center and did not burn or draw so well. Up until then, I thought they were close to perfect. So, I had to remind myself that these were seconds. Then last night, I pulled one out to watch the MNF game, and this one had about as nice a draw as one would want. With good flavor, easy draw, and even burn (medium to full bodied cigar but mild effect on the palate) ... it restored my previous positive assessment. That last poor one had to have been a fluke. This was a very good cigar. Thanks, FSS & AB!
S.P. in Northern Virginia September 30, 2008
Customer Ratings

10 Burn (83) 100
Poor - Excellent

10 Consistency (85) 100
Poor - Excellent

10 Draw (84) 100
Poor - Excellent

10 Appearance (87) 100
Poor - Excellent

10 Taste (88) 100
Poor - Excellent

10 Construction (86) 100
Poor - Excellent


Machine Made Cigars
New Cigars - See all Famous’ latest and greatest!