Premium Cigars at Discount Prices! Order Toll Free: 1-800-564-2486 Contact Us
Sign Up

The Judge By J Fuego Blind Justice Reviews [view details]

Give us YOUR review!

Showing 1 through 10 of 20 reviews

Now my #1 smoke. This is now the cigar I judge others by. No pun intended.
Robert in Stroudsburg Pa April 16, 2014
"Definitely an EVERYDAY SMOKE"
Bought these when they first came out and loved them instantly! Need a year supply!
Nick in Chicago February 28, 2014
"Everyday Smoke!"
WOW! Bought at least 40 of these babies so far and they are fantastic every time! Easily an everyday smoke.
Nick P in Chicago February 22, 2014
"GREAT COMPLIMENT to the RP15 in the wingman"
great cigar almost on par with the Rocky Pateel 15th anni. in the wingman. go burn draw and no bite wonderful flavors. very close to the rocky.
DAWG in N.C. November 24, 2013
"Absolutely Amazing"
It truly is amazing that even though Ive never tried The Judge , I find my review of the discontinued Capoeria listed under The Judge .
Phil in NJ in New Jersey October 21, 2013
"well worth the money!"
Awesome for the money. I want to say that they're awful, so you leave more for me. Smoked one right off the truck and was surprised that my impatience was rewarded. Notes of rich tobacco and leather predominate, with accents of coffee, black walnut, and fleeting hints of anise. Ash held kn for a full two-thirds before falling. Will definitely be buying more.
john in colorado March 29, 2013
"Absolutely impossible to keep lit."
I got these as part of a sampler. Looks decent enough, was not too impressed with the flavor. But, I do prefer a milder smoke. But I had to keep lighting it, After I got about half way through it I could not keep it lit so after the 9th time I just tossed it. Definitely would never buy another.
Christ in Illinois January 23, 2013
"Too good to discontinue..."
One of the best smokes I've purchased from FSS. Great taste, burn, consistency and draw. No complaints here. Hope some other retailer picks them up.
Phil in NJ December 8, 2012
"Great smoke"
Great smoke
Dennis in Ark September 9, 2012
"Not impressed, tastes like tar"
I've tried two from the five pack I bought. The first had a draw so tight I could barely smoke it. I struggled through half of it before throwing it away, something I almost never do. The second had a good draw but I still smoked less than half because it tasted like tar. I will say it has some very strong dark flavors, but the most pronounced of them is what I can only describe as tar. That is not something I enjoy, maybe other people do. The construction is also suspect. The diameter varies quite a bit making the stick look like a real "stick" that was pulled off a tree and the cap was sloppy at best. I'm amazed by all the good reviews. I would be embarrassed to give these away. If you are someone that likes a very strong tar flavored cigar that you might be able to smoke if the draw isn't too tight, this is the one for you.
Andy in Huntsville August 17, 2012
Customer Ratings

10 Burn (87) 100
Poor - Excellent

10 Consistency (88) 100
Poor - Excellent

10 Draw (87) 100
Poor - Excellent

10 Appearance (86) 100
Poor - Excellent

10 Taste (84) 100
Poor - Excellent

10 Construction (87) 100
Poor - Excellent

Its time to PUMP UP the savings
5-Pack Frenzy...just got a lot crazier!