I got this in the tin with another order, and I was really interested in trying it- it had good and bad feedback here. I'm happy to say I really liked it. It's mellow not over flavored and smooth. It's got a complex taste and unlike some of the other Acid flavors it wont flavor your mouth. Although I'm not a very experienced cigar smoker I give this highest possible ratings, I'm not sure what I like more this or the earthy cigar Acid makes.