Cigar Buying Guides

2018 CA Report: 10 Best Cigars to Start Smoking Cigars … Again

Reading Time: 7 minutes

10 Best Cigars to Start Smoking Cigars – Again

(Or, How to Get Your Cigar Groove Back)

By Gary Korb

Have you ever found yourself having to stop doing something you really enjoy – like enjoy…a lot? Slamming on the brakes can be pretty devastating, and not knowing when you’ll be able to return to one of your favorite activities can be equally frustrating. Well, I’ve been there.

I smoke cigars for both enjoyment and a living, and for me it was a screwy streak of health issues that prompted a nearly six month hiatus. Moreover, I bet there are at least a few of you who’ve had to give your cigar cutter and lighter  an extended vacation whether it was absolutely necessary or simply voluntary. Sound familiar?

Well, after I recovered, you can imagine how much I was itching to get back to the flavor and aroma of a fine cigar. Besides, I had received a lot of new cigar releases to review and my humidor was almost stacked to the rafters.

Since it would be sort of like starting over, I thought about what cigars would be best to recapture my groove when it was time to start smoking cigars again. Which cigar would be my first? Which one would follow that, and so-on, until I had a virtual list in my head.

Then it hit me. . .

The list didn’t have to be just for cigar smokers who’ve been sitting out the game for a few weeks, months, what-have-you; it could also serve as a guide for new cigar smokers who might be interested in a roster of so-called, “starter cigars” that range from mellow to full-flavored smokes at-a-glance.  The result?

Ten cigars that include a lot of my personal favorites, some I’d been curious about, and some new cigars that I hadn’t gotten around to.

So, let’s get down to it. . .

There’s no article in the cigar-smoking constitution that says new cigar smokers have to choose something from the mellow column when they start smoking cigars. But whether you’ve been intentionally resting your palate for a while or recently decided to take the plunge, starting with a lighter smoke will help flex your taste buds, and prepare them for the sequence that follows.


Toraño 1916 Cameroon Robusto (5½” x 52)

Strength: Mellow

start smoking cigars again Torano 1916 Cameroon cigarsDraped in a plush African Cameroon wrapper that caps a blend of Nicaraguan and Honduran long fillers, this tasty morsel from Toraño has always been a reliable favorite of mine for its smoothness, balance, and chorus of sweet cedar notes that sing from end-to-end. Whenever I’m in the mood for a change-of-pace cigar, the 1916 Cameroon Robusto has never let me down, which is why it’s a great choice for first in the list.


Cunning by Joya De Nicaragua Toro (6″ x 50)

Strength: Mellow – Medium

start smoking cigars again Cunning Joya De Nicaragua cigarsConsidering Joya de Nicaragua’s reputation for hearty smokes, I found this cigar to be a really pleasant surprise. Finished in a buttery Ecuadorian Connecticut wrapper, the Cunning Toro’s Nicaraguan core gives it a slight turn up in volume. The well-balanced smoke issues notes of earth, white pepper, and cedar with hints of nuts and caramel making their presence known along the way. If you want a little more spice in a mellower cigar, Cunning’s got it, and the price is nice, too.


Rocky Patel Rosado Robusto (5½” x 50)

Strength: Medium

start smoking cigars again Rocky Patel Rosado cigarsHere’s one that continues to impress me. A 5-year-aged Ecuadorian Sumatra Rosado wrapper caps a well-rounded filler blend that kicks-off with some sweet spice, cedar, and pepper enhanced by chocolatey aroma. Moving down the line, the cigar locks-on to a continuous stream of pepper and cedar as notes of coffee, leather, sweet spice, and tart fruit slip in at various intervals. All I can add to that is, if you’re going to start smoking cigars that are a little richer – the Rocky Patel Rosado Robusto is a great training ground for discovering what “complexity” is all about, too.


CAO CX2 Rob (5″ x 52)

Strength: Medium

start smoking cigars again CAO CX2 cigarsAs an admirer of Cameroon wrapper, I thought this modern classic from CAO would make a good groove restorer. Placing an African Cameroon wrapper and binder over Nicaraguan and Colombian tobaccos, the CX2 Rob (short for Robusto) offers a voluminous and velvety smoke with an amalgam of earth, sweet cedar, nutmeg, some herbal notes, and dried fruit. Hints of leather, coffee bean, and honey also work their way in along the journey making the CX2 a delectably versatile treat you can enjoy morning, noon, or night.


Padrón 6000 Maduro (5½” x 52 Torpedo, box-pressed)

Strength: Medium – Full

start smoking cigars again Padrón 6000 Maduro cigarsI was introduced to this figurado by one of the guys I work with some years back, and it’s become one of my regular go-to’s. The 6000 draws perfectly, issuing gobs of that signature Padron character – earth, cedar, coffee bean, cocoa, and spice – plus, the maduro wrapper brings some added sweetness to the table. The smoke is full-bodied, but never becomes top-heavy. As Nicaraguan puros go, you can’t miss with any Padron cigar, but the 6000 maduro is especially distinctive within the brand’s core line.


Villiger La Vencedora Churchill (7″ x 50)

Strength: Medium – Full

start smoking cigars again Villiger La Vencedora cigarsThis is one of the newer cigars I missed during my hiatus and was really looking forward to. Teaming-up with Dr. Alejandro Martinez Cuenca of Joya de Nicaragua Cigars, La Vencedora (“The Victor” in Spanish) is a puro and what Villiger has dubbed, their “first full-bodied cigar.” Full-flavored is more accurate, since the smoke stops short of absolute full while cranking-up the volume on complexity and depth. Skillfully rolled in a dark, opulent Habano Oscuro wrapper, the cigar opens with an earthy-peppery overture, then transitions to some citrusy elements escorted by syrupy flavors of honey, caramel and cinnamon. The voluminous smoke becomes bolder and spicier in the last act for a stunningly scrumptious finale.


Perdomo 20th Anniversary Maduro Epicure (6″ x 56, box-pressed)

Strength: Full

start smoking cigars again Perdomo 20th Anniversary Maduro cigarsI took to this Perdomo line extension immediately and fell for the Sun Grown Epicure, which is now a staple in my humidors. However, I was curious about the 20th Anniversary Epicure in the maduro wrapper because it has a Nicaraguan-grown Broadleaf that I’ve enjoyed on some other Perdomo cigars. In this case it’s a toothy, high priming, barrel-aged leaf. The smoke has a lush, creamy texture loaded with caramelized flavors of cedar, coffee, cocoa, and a more generous helping of pepper and sweet spices. Here again, the cigar is more full-flavored than full-bodied, making this maddie well-equipped for cigar smokers of every experience.


Camacho Ecuador BXP Robusto (5″ x 50, box pressed)

Strength: Full

start smoking cigars again Camacho Ecuador BXP cigarsI think I’ve had just about every Camacho cigar in the core line, but the Ecuador has always been a standout for me due to its big bucket of flavor and superb balance. Capped in spicy Ecuador Habano wrapper, this vitola has a sharp Cuban-style box-press that makes it even more mouthwatering. I also like the use of the Brazilian binder and Honduran-Dominican core, which gives this cigar its startling complexity. Kicking-off with earth and pepper, the smoke gradually settles down to reveal a tapestry of oak, leather, some fruity tanginess, nutmeg, and other spices with some light pepper on the finish. Best enjoyed in the late afternoon or evening.


RoMEo by Romeo y Julieta San Andrés Toro (6″ x 54)

Strength: Full

start smoking cigars again Romeo San Andres ToroFor the past few years, I’ve been trying just about every premium cigar with a Mexican San Andrés wrapper I can get my hands on. What can I say – I’m practically addicted to the leaf’s naturally sweet-spicy flavor. Not all have been hits, but this new RoMEo blended by the gifted AJ Fernandez is a knockout. The Toro is solidly built and the wrapper is closer to an Oscuro in color. The pre-light offers a good indication of what’s to come with faint notes of coffee and bittersweet chocolate. The cigar is front-loaded for an exhilarating earth and pepper combo when lit, but once that fades, the curtain opens on notes of nuts, leather, coffee, tart fruit, white pepper, and plenty of sweet spice from foot-to-head. This is a primo tobacco banquet that should be enjoyed when you have a good two hours to appreciate it.


Encore by E.P. Carrillo Majestic (53/8″x 52, box-pressed)

Strength: Full

start smoking cigars again Encore by E.P. Carrillo cigarsFinally, the Encore is another one of the new cigar releases I couldn’t wait to try. This all-Nicaraguan blend is deftly handcrafted and box-pressed with tobaccos aged in palm bark bales, or tercios. This traditional Cuban method draws much more flavor out of the tobaccos, and when done by Ernesto Perez-Carrillo, well. . .nuf’ said. When lit, the smoke offers a distinctive aroma brimming with a toasty and sweet-woody redolence. Out of the gate come notes of earth, pepper, cedar and spice that constantly shift positions like a horse race keeping the palate entertained without ever losing their balance. Although he named it “Majestic,” Ernesto could just as easily have called it “Magnificent.”


If you enjoyed reading this article, please share your thoughts by leaving a comment.

Notify of
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Dennis Wilder
5 years ago

Once again I’ll make the suggestion that when you have recommendatons like this, Famous-Smoke should put together a sample pack of them to make it easy to get them. I for one would always be inclined to make that puchase.

Stan Walker
5 years ago

Had a similar thing going from mid-February until early May this year. Convinced myself I was okay and smoked a couple during, but paid for it. Started out as a nasty cold and finally figured out I had an allergy I never had before. Couldn’t wait to smoke again and been making up for lost time ever since. Nice article on something I never really considered before. Nice choices too.

Wayne Wright
5 years ago

It’s nice to see a list that includes smokes I can actually afford, and have enjoyed. I did not realize when I started this enjoyable ‘habit’, it would take me so long to find cigars that I enjoy enough to buy more. A couple of my regular smokes made this list.

Gary Korb

Gary Korb

Executive Editor

Gary Korb has been writing and editing content for since its debut in 2008. An avid cigar smoker for over 30 years, he has worked on the marketing side of the premium cigar business as a Sr. Copywriter, blogger, and Executive Editor of Cigar Advisor. A graduate of the Newhouse School of Public Communications at Syracuse University, prior to his career in the cigar business, Gary worked in the music and video industry as a marketer and a publicist.

Show all Gary Korb's Articles
cigar advisor master blenders pt. 2 nick melillo, founder of foundation cigars - cover

Master Blenders Pt. 2: Nick Melillo, Founder of Foundation Cigars

Reading Time: 2 minutes Foundation Cigar Co. prez, Nick Melillo, returns for this Master Blenders podcast episode to talk about Olmec, Metapa, two new blends from Charter Oak, and more, including how the inspiration for new blends comes from different cultures.

Read More
cigar advisor top new cigars-5-29-23 - cover

Top New Cigars (May 29, 2023)

Reading Time: 3 minutes The Best New Cigars are here at Famous. Check out the freshly released Romeo y Julieta House of Capulet Nicaragua, Caldwell’s One Night Stand, and a lighter from Firebird that can light your grill as easily as it lights your cigars!

Read More
cigar advisor #nowsmoking cigar review ferio tego timeless series - cover


Reading Time: 6 minutes Why review one Ferio Tego Timeless when we can review them all?! We sat down with Ferio co-founder, Michael Herklots, for a no-holds-barred review of each Timeless blend. See the video and our reviews by clicking now!

Read More
cigar advisor nowsmoking cigar review indomina by aj fernandez cover

#NowSmoking: Indomina by AJ Fernandez

Reading Time: 4 minutes Not all economy cigars are created equal…AJ Fernandez’ fiery Indomina blend is here to prove it. Standing on-par with top shelf smokes three and four times its price, this Nicaraguan-made premium is a no-brainer on paper. See our video cigar review to find out if it’s as good with a flame!

Read More