Cigar Buying Guides

2018 CA Report: 10 Top “Vintage” Cigars You Should Be Smoking

They say you learn something new every day; and today, I have learned that the term “vintage” can mean a lot of different things depending on exactly what you’re referring to.

A vintage car, for instance, is often one that was made between the years 1919 and 1930. A vintage (or antique) piece of furniture is said to have been produced before the 1920’s. Vintage jewelry is basically 100 years old or more. And, as far as fine wines go, it can refer to several things such as the yield of wine or grapes from a vineyard or district during one season…or…wine usually of high quality, identified as to year and vineyard, or district of origin…or…it can be the year or place in which a wine was bottled.

example of Alabama vintage vehicle plate
Image via Alabama Dept. of Revenue

Now, when using the term “vintage” when it comes to premium hand-rolled cigars, well, it not only seems a little unclear, but you might even say a tad…controversial. I really wanted to know, what constitutes a vintage cigar (and it’s certainly not a cigar that’s over 100 years old). So, I contacted several “well-known” cigar makers/blenders (who will remain nameless) hoping they could set me on the straight and narrow, but unfortunately, that just didn’t happen for me… Damn.

When using the term “vintage” when it comes to premium hand-rolled cigars, well, it not only seems a little unclear, but you might even say a tad…controversial.

The first one I asked said it’s all a bunch of mumbo-jumbo marketing bull-shingles. And then, the first thing I thought was, “Well, that’s gonna make for a crappy little article.” This particular cigar maker was actually quite adamant, even when I pressed the matter further as he insisted that it means nothing and there was nothing more he could add…Great.

I moved onto cigar master number two who told me it was a great question and he had an answer. Okay, now we’re getting somewhere. He told me that in the past, a vintage cigar was one that was rolled with tobaccos (filler, binder and wrapper) all from the same year. He said it didn’t matter if they came from different countries or regions, it only mattered if they were grown and harvested all in the same year. Both interesting and cool as I had never heard this before.

In the past, a vintage cigar was one that was rolled with tobaccos (filler, binder and wrapper) all from the same year.

So, I called cigar maker number 3 in hopes of a definitive answer, and he said while it “used to” refer to tobaccos from the same crop year, he felt it didn’t really apply any longer…Terrific. He feels it refers to a certain amount of years that a particular tobacco within the blend has been aged. So, how many years did he feel constituted vintage tobacco? Well, he thinks it’s at least 5 years, but, I was told, “Just don’t quote me on it”…Ugh.

None the less, there are a number of cigars at Famous Smoke Shop that do indeed have the word “vintage” in their names. And, I can tell you this, they are all excellent smokes, several garnering some very high ratings and accolades. So, check out the list I’ve compiled and decide for yourself which vintage premiums you’d like to give a try.

Rocky Patel Vintage 1990

Origin: Honduras     Strength: Medium     Wrapper: Honduran Broadleaf

Shop Rocky Patel Vintage 1990 cigars at Famous Smoke Shop

It was all the rage when it debuted and people still clamor over this delicious medium-bodied treat. I refer to this as a triple play cigar, where it’s gorgeous looking, smells amazing, and tastes even better. Nuts, cocoa, and semi-sweet chocolate lace the palate on this smooth and very rich premium. There’s 5 highly rated Rocky Vintage cigars in total, including the mellow Vintage Connecticut 1999, the full-flavored Vintage 1992 and Vintage 2006, and the elegant and complex Vintage 2003 Cameroon.

Romeo y Julieta Vintage

Origin: Dominican Republic     Strength: Medium     Wrapper: Ecuador Connecticut Shade

Shop Romeo y Juileta Vintage cigars at Famous Smoke Shop

This is a luxurious and highly rated cigar line made by the people at Romeo. Just one look at that silky and oily wrapper, you just know this is going to be one hell of a smooth smoke. A cedary sweetness dominates this tasty medium-bodied stick with notes of coffee, and a hint of graham cracker. And guess what… it really is one incredibly smooth and tasty smoke.

H. Upmann Vintage Cameroon

Origin: Dominican Republic     Strength: Medium     Wrapper: African Cameroon

Shop H Upmann Vintage Cameroon cigars at Famous Smoke Shop

I would have to say that this Vintage Cameroon has been the longtime favorite in the H. Upmann line, and one of the first of this brand that I got really hooked on. While medium in strength, this is an extremely full-flavored cigar that’s very toasty both in taste and its sweet aroma. The inner leaves are an interesting mix of Nicaraguan, Dominican and Peruvian with a Nicaraguan binder. But it’s that luscious outer African leaf that gives it those special woody and cocoa flavors.

Macanudo Vintage 2006

Origin: Dominican Republic     Strength: Medium     Wrapper: Connecticut Shade

Shop  Macanudo Vintage 2006 cigars at Famous Smoke Shop

It’s a Macanudo and it’s amazing… yeah, I said it, dammit. This stick uses very finely aged tobaccos, featuring a true Connecticut shade 2006-grown outer leaf that gives this cigar a toasty, mellow profile, but a lot of sweet rich flavor notes of cedar, nuts, and a cappuccino-like creaminess. I’m telling you guys, for those who might turn their nose up at this brand name, I double-dog-dare you to smoke this because you will be more than pleasantly surprised how good it really is. Also, try the Macanudo Vintage 1997, a little mellower than the 2006, but like a fine wine that gets better and better with age.

Montecristo White Vintage

Origin: Dominican Republic     Strength: Mellow-Medium     Wrapper: Connecticut Shade

Shop Montecristo White Vintage cigars at Famous Smoke Shop

Ultra-fine premium tobaccos make this Montecristo a memorable, celebration type of smoke. While the inside utilizes a zesty blend of Dominican, Peruvian, and Nicaraguan leaves, the wrapper is an exquisite 2008 US Connecticut shade grown that makes for a nutty toastiness that is just so damned pleasant to both the palate and the olfactory senses. I think I need to remind some people that you don’t always have to smoke cigars that can grow hair on a catcher’s mitt, and the Monte White Vintage is the answer.

Fonseca Vintage Selection

Origin: Dominican Republic     Strength: Medium     Wrapper: Ecuador Connecticut Shade  

Shop Fonseca Vintage Selection cigars at Famous Smoke Shop

This Fonseca truly is a seriously underrated cigar, and the work that goes into making this hidden gem is amazing. The Dominican inner blend of leaves is aged for five full years in palm bark tercios, keeping the leaf oily and supple. The outer is a golden-brown Ecuadorian Connecticut shade making the cigar creamy in flavor, especially with its thick billowy smoke on the draw. You’ll get notes of coffee and wood with a pleasant hit of spice as well. Pair this with a Fonseca Port and life is gonna get good real fast.

Perdomo Estate Seleccion Vintage Sun Grown

Origin: Nicaragua     Strength: Medium-Full     Wrapper: Nicaraguan Sun Grown

Shop Perdomo Estate Seleccion Vintage sun grown cigars at Famous Smoke Shop

One hell of a cigar… well, that’s one hell of an understatement. While Nick Perdomo makes a number of high-level cigars, this one is exceptional in every way. The Nicaraguan tobaccos he uses are the cream of the crop, and that reddish-brown, Sun Grown Nicaraguan wrapper literally glistens with natural oils. And it is indeed a complex smoke that starts off with some pepper and spice, but then settles down with wonderful notes of coffee bean and a distinct woodiness. Employ a good bourbon to pair with this vintage and you just might refuse to get up for quite some time. There’s also the Connecticut version that’s toned down to be a tad mellower, and the Maduro version that has a little more pop with some nice sweetness to boot.  

Padilla Vintage Reserve

Origin: Nicaragua     Strength: Full     Wrapper: Pennsylvania Broadleaf

Shop Padilla Vintage Reserve cigars at Famous Smoke Shop

Sinfully dark, oily, and wow. Not long after lighting this up, you actually might hear Ralph Kramden shouting out, “Bam, zoom, right in the kisser” as that Pennsylvania broadleaf wrapper kicks into gear.  And, while it may be a flavor beast, Ernesto Padilla has tamed this beast into an elegant and complex one. Rolled at Tabacalera Oliva, it’s a very limited run offering with only 500 boxes made in each of its 6 sizes. Dark coffee, chocolate, and molasses jump on the taste buds along with a sweet spice that builds. A good mug of coffee, a whiskey, or a deep red wine, well there is simply no wrong answer for your pairing. This is a full-bodied, cigar lover’s dream, and I have become a huge fan.

La Aurora Puro Vintage 2007

Origin: Dominican Republic     Strength: Full     Wrapper: Dominican Republic

Shop La Aurora Puro Vintage 2007 cigars at Famous Smoke Shop

Now, here’s a premium cigar that I’d have to say wears the “vintage’ moniker with pride. This limited-edition cigar is a masterpiece hailing from La Aurora, blended with 11-year old (what they refer to as) “harvest-specific” tobaccos. It’s available in only one size, a distinct Salomon shaped stick weighing in at 6½ x 50/60. I’m admittedly a tad confused by the word “puro” in its name, as the fillers are from the Dominican Republic, Nicaragua, and Brazil with an Ecuadorian grown binder, but I’ll get over it. The flavor profile gives off a delicious combination of freshly ground coffee beans, cedar and spice, and the aroma is sweet and decadent. Only 6,000 boxes produced, so, you know what you’ve got to do.

La Fontana Vintage

Origin: Honduras     Strength: Mellow     Wrapper: Honduran Connecticut Shade

Shop La Fontana Vintage cigars at Famous Smoke Shop

The fact is that an awful lot of the cigar smoking public loves mellow-bodied, golden-colored, Connecticut shade smokes, and the La Fontana Vintage is one of the absolute best sellers for Famous. The smooth tobaccos in the blend, along with its silky Connecticut shade wrapper leaf and  “old Cuban-style” sweetened cap, make for a smoother and mellower Honduran-style smoke. So, no, if you are the Nic-bomb loving maniac who eats ligero leaf for breakfast, La Fontana is definitely not for you. But people who smoke this golden beauty give it some very high ratings and swear by it.

So, what do you have to say about these cigars, as well as the whole vintage thing? I’d love to see your comments posted below.

Leave a Reply

6 Comment threads
0 Thread replies
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
0 Comment authors
Bobby KnoxJonathan SnyderDoug E. StefanLance FarrerBob Langmaid Recent comment authors
newest oldest most voted
Lance Farrer
Lance Farrer

Great article all look to be top notch brsnds

Bobby Knox
Bobby Knox

Great read Zman. In your opinion, are “vintage “ cigars “special occasion “ cigars?

Bob Langmaid
Bob Langmaid

Great article. I have always felt that the term vintage in premium cigars should indicate that the tobacco was very well aged!

Jonathan Snyder
Jonathan Snyder

When you refer to vintage, are you speaking to the original release versions of the cigars, or the reproductions?

James Morrissette
James Morrissette

Very happy with the Rocky Patel vintage!

Doug E. Stefan
Doug E. Stefan

I am now on my second box of RP Vintage 1990’s

Tommy Zman Zarzecki

Tommy Zman Zarzecki


Tommy Zman, is an obsessive enjoyer of life’s leafy pleasures. Growing up in the bowels of northern New Jersey, parented by an eccentric Polish father and a neurotic Italian mother, what else could this man possibly be other than a humorist? ZMan’s a real throwback to a time when men were kings of the castle and smoking a cigar in public didn’t label you an outcast and a pariah. He’s an old–school down to earth guy - but when it comes to p.c. tyranny and nanny-state legislature, he’ll draw his sword and swing for the fences. Tommy gathered a faithful following as a longtime feature writer at Cigar Magazine, and his testosterone laden FaceBook community, CROMAG NATION™ is truly the last great bastion for Men’s Men.

Show all Tommy Zman Zarzecki's Articles
2019 top sleeper cigars Cigar Advisor Cover

2019 CA Report: 10 Top Sleeper Cigars You Need to be Smoking

The Sleeper Cigar is the one that doesn’t get the love it deserves in social media or by the cigar reviewers. Click NOW to get in on some ‘well-kept secret’ smokes, that should be known and smoked by cigar lovers everywhere…

Read More
10 Top Cigar Lighters to Fit Any Budget Cigar Advisor Cover

2019 CA Report: 10 Top Cigar Lighters to Fit Any Budget

There are lots of great cigar lighters to choose – but with so many different features and a wide range of price ranges, which is the best one for you? Get the low-down on the highlights of these 10 affordably-priced lighters, and see…

Read More

#nowsmoking: Aging Room Small Batch Quattro F55 Espressivo

Aging Room Small Batch Quattro F55 Espressivo: a spicy-full Dominican that’s box-pressed in a rare Sumatra wrapper, and is “curiously complex.” See what else you NEED to know about this cigar – click & read our quick Aging Room cigar review now…

Read More
best holiday cigar gifts 2017 CACover

CA Report: Best Holiday Cigar Gifts Buying Guide

It's our annual Christmas Buying Guide: find the best holiday cigar gifts for any cigar smoker, from Stocking Stuffers, Stogies, Storage, & Stash Supplies!
Read More