Cigar Buying Guides

2018 CA REPORT: Thanksgiving Cigars – Different Smokes for Different Folks

Reading Time: 7 minutes

I was watching a Thanksgiving special on the Food Network the other day, and the host kept saying that it’s all about food and family. Well, when you hang around my neck of the woods (which will have 28 ravenous people descending upon my home this Turkey Day) it’s always going to be about a little something more than just food and family. Everyone knows that I’m a cigar-a-holic, and I don’t just serve up after-dinner smokes – I also break out the premiums for appetizers, and between courses.

Hey, don’t get me wrong, I’m an admitted gluttonous sociopath when it comes to the massive variety of chow we serve at my abode. We seriously pig-out on a wide array of appetizers like cheeses, salami, pepperoni, chips and dips, buffalo wings, tiny hotdogs in their cozy lil’ blankets, cream cheese chili-dip, and so much other pre-game fare, bloating us all until the main courses are ready hours later. Which makes for the perfect time to invite the manly primordial beasts out into the garage to light up cigars along with our libations of choice.

2018 thanksgiving cigars after dinner smoke eating turkey
Zman Thanksgiving: 28 people, 25lb turkey. And a ham. And a tray of lasagna. But no holiday binge is complete without a good spread of smokes.

First off – I’ll light up a stick before any of my guests arrive, a mellower kind of appetizer smoke, something to get the palate prepared for a long day of textures and flavors. Then, when I head to the garage between courses, I’ll smoke something more medium bodied. And when dinner is done and I’m in beached whale mode, a tasty, full-bodied dessert cigar will be chosen, one with enough oomph to cut through the cornucopia of dinner and dessert insanity. For the main courses, we do a big-ass turkey in the 25lb range, but there’s also a ham and a tray of lasagna.

But it’s the endless side dishes that go deep into the realm of epicurean overkill. The wife’s stuffing seasoned with ground Italian sweet sausage is the yearly staple. There are mounds of whipped mashed taters slathered in butter. My mother-in-law’s homemade, mayo-laden coleslaw is amazing, and as always, her Polish powered kielbasa in kraut continues to tip the scales. Can’t forget the sweet potato pie with them melty little marshmallows, and my daughter’s homemade cranberry sauce, much to the chagrin of my pop, who actually likes the jellied cranberry slop from a can. Sweet creamed corn makes its way around the table along with the broccoli n’ cheese casserole, and my Italian mom always brings her meatballs in red sauce. Holy good God, I’m stuffed just writing this. Say… did I forget to mention dessert? There’s at least a dozen pies, cookies, cakes and confections that has every guy’s pants unbuttoned while we’re all rubbing our Buddha-like bellies as we’re gasping for air.


 “Just like each dish served on Turkey Day isn’t for everyone…not everyone smokes the same kind of cigars.”


Ahhhhhh, it’s now time for some premium hand-rolled goodness. What’s actually pretty cool is that at least 7-8 of the guys enjoy a cigar after dinner, but there are different levels of smokers. Just like each dish served on Turkey Day isn’t for everyone, well, not everyone smokes the same kind of cigars. So, kind of the same way I treat wedding cigars, I’ll have 3 choices for my guests: mellow gars for the newbies and occasional smokers, medium-bodied for the guys that do enjoy a nice stick, and full-flavored for the hardcore aficionados.

So, for this article, I’ve chosen 9 cigars that I’m recommending for Thanksgiving Day: 3 mellow, 3 medium, and 3 full. There’s a good cigar here for everybody and I’ve picked each one with a reasoning behind them.


Mellow-Bodied Offerings


Lonsdale/6 1/4″ x 46 – Wrapper: Connecticut

2018 top thanksgiving cigars foundation cigars charter oak cigars bin

The Charter Oak is getting rave reviews from so many because it just has so much damned flavor for a Connecticut wrapped cigar – using real-deal US Connecticut shade-grown leaf. What’s amazing is that Nick Melillo of Foundation Cigars is working with very high-quality leaf but sells these treats at an incredibly low price. They are drop-dead delicious with prominent notes of cedar, honey and sweet ripened fruit. This is the one I’ll be kicking off Turkey Day with and I’ll be damned if the newbies will get their greasy mitts on them.



Robusto/4 ¾” x 49 – Wrapper: U.S. Connecticut

2018 top thanksgiving cigars creme de jamaica cigars bin

While this is the perfect stick for the newbie or the once-in-a-while smoker, it really does have a lot of nice mellow flavor because of the genuine US shade leaf (grown in the Connecticut River Valley) that covers the Dominican filler and Indonesian binder. It’s very creamy and cedary tasting, with a slight nuttiness. Perfectly constructed, it lets off a lot of sweet smoke that even the non-smokers will enjoy – except my wife’s uncle Ned, a stick in the mud whiner who seriously needs to be uninvited every damned year. The guy’s a tool and I really don’t give a shit if he reads this.



Toro/6″ x 50 – Wrapper: Honduran Connecticut

2018 top thanksgiving cigars baccarat cigars bin

Baccarat cigars are a top seller, year after year for Famous. Face it, a whole lot of people like mellow cigars and these are as easy going as it gets. The Honduran filler is held in a Mexican binder and wrapped with a golden Honduran Connecticut Shade outer leaf. The cap has a slightly sweetened tip and fans of these cigars can’t get enough of them. They are perfect cigars for serving the beginner smoker who wants to give it a go with everyone else.


Medium-Bodied Offerings


Perfecto/4 7/8″ x 56 – Wrapper: African Cameroon

2018 top thanksgiving cigars arturo fuente hemingway work of art cigars bin

The Hemingway line has true medium-bodied cigars that deliver an awful lot of smooth tobacco flavor. This pudgy perfecto is aged for 6 full months in cedar-lined rooms after Fuente’s top torcedors are done rolling them. It’s those silky-sheer African Cameroon wrappers that deliver notes of sweet cedar, nuts and coffee with a nice bit of spice. This is an elegant smoke and a perfect addition to the holiday dinner line-up.



Toro/6″ x 50 – Wrapper: Nicaraguan Habano

2018 top thanksgiving cigars trinidad esteli cigars bin

While the Trinidad name isn’t on the tip of every smoker’s tongue, this fairly-new, well-made offering has surprised a heck out of a lot people. While it shows some nice complexity and is wonderfully full-flavored, it’s not a classic Nicaraguan powerhouse. It’s smooth as silk on the palate with woody notes and some earthiness and sweet spice. That oily, golden-brown Nicaraguan Habano wrapper is gorgeous and lets off a sumptuous, woody aroma. Absolute yum.



Magnum/6″ x 60 – Wrapper: Nicaraguan Rosado

2018 top thanksgiving cigars montecristo relentless cigars bin

Monte took a nice mellow Connecticut wrapper cigar and upped their game by creating a newer blend with a whole lot more pop in the flavor department. You won’t see a lot of all-Nicaraguan Montecristos around, and this exception to the rule is buttery-smooth and extremely flavorful. Notes of coffee bean and sweet wood are prominent throughout as it delivers straightforward rich tobacco flavor from start to finish.


Full-Bodied Offerings


Belicoso Fino/5 ½” x 52 – Wrapper: Indonesian Besuki

2018 top thanksgiving cigars southern draw cedrus cigars bin

Now THIS new offering from our friend, Robert Holt at Southern Draw is truly the perfect after Thanksgiving dinner smoke for a few good reasons. First off, it’s full-flavored with a whole lot of very interesting and unique tastes going on. There are five different types of premium aged leaf in there producing a full-bodied complexity that will have you enjoying a dark, rich sweetness, with an herbal quality that is so damned pleasant and delicious. It’s created by AJ Fernandez and the quality is impeccable. I will definitely be puffing this one come Turkey Day and many days after.



Gordo/6″ x 60 – Wrapper: Honduras

2018 top thanksgiving cigars alec bradley magic toast cigars bin

Alec Bradley is seriously cranking it out of the park as of late, and with the release of the all-new Magic Toast, the hits just keep on coming. The first thing you’ll notice is that incredibly oily, deep, dark Honduran outer wrapper leaf that gives this stick a sweetness that is so smooth from the second you light it to the moment you let it go out. There are notes of dense, dark chocolate, espresso, and the sweetness reminds me of rich molasses on the taste buds. This is another one I’ll be smoking on T-Day as it is beyond perfect for cutting through the cavalcade of food I’ll be pounding.



Robusto/5″ x 54 – Wrapper: Nicaraguan Habano

2018 top thanksgiving cigars f75 by padron cigars bin

When we set out to make a 75th anniversary cigar for Famous, we knew it had to be uber-special, and what’s more special than a 1926 Padron? With tobaccos aged five full years, this natural version is exploding with flavor in its square-pressed robusto size. The flawless, almost perfect Nicaraguan Habano wrapper gives off an aroma that is toasty and just perfect for a post dinner bourbon or Scotch. You’ll find notes of cocoa, sweet spice and coffee beans that please your palate. This one is decadent, and why not treat yourself to something so special on America’s favorite holiday.

So, how about posting your comments and suggestions below? And a Happy Thanksgiving to you all.

Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Matthew Awad
4 years ago

Nice article and great number of cigars. Going on a gar run today and the charter oak and magic toast are on the list!

Martin Koren
4 years ago

Dude, for me its gotta be the the Anejo Shark from Fuente. .so special and so perfect for the holidays.. pairs great with everything. Post Turkey day football and fun, give me Oliva V Melanio,then for the nighttime activities the LFD Andalusin Bull . New Years eve, Cuban Montecristo Number 2. GOOD ARTICLE. NUFF SAID AND HAPPY TURKEY DAY, MERRY XMAS AND HAPPY F’ING NEW YEAR!!

Tommy Zman Zarzecki

Tommy Zman Zarzecki


Tommy Zman, is an obsessive enjoyer of life’s leafy pleasures. Growing up in the bowels of northern New Jersey, parented by an eccentric Polish father and a neurotic Italian mother, what else could this man possibly be other than a humorist? ZMan’s a real throwback to a time when men were kings of the castle and smoking a cigar in public didn’t label you an outcast and a pariah. He’s an old–school down to earth guy - but when it comes to p.c. tyranny and nanny-state legislature, he’ll draw his sword and swing for the fences. Tommy gathered a faithful following as a longtime feature writer at Cigar Magazine, and his testosterone laden FaceBook community, CROMAG NATION™ is truly the last great bastion for Men’s Men.

Show all Tommy Zman Zarzecki's Articles
cigar advisor news – punch jumps into year of the rabbit with limited edition spring roll cigar release - cover

Cigar News: Punch Jumps Into Year of the Rabbit with Limited Edition Spring Roll Cigar

Reading Time: 2 minutes With 2023 being the Chinese ‘Year of the Rabbit,’ Punch Cigars is releasing the Punch Spring Roll cigar. The fifth in the line’s limited edition series, it’s been called “the yin” to the original Punch Egg Roll’s “yang.” Learn all about it here.

Read More
cigar advisor best humidor hygrometers - cover

CA Report: Best Humidor Hygrometers for Cigars

Reading Time: 4 minutes The most unsung heroes of our cigar accessories, hygrometers keep tabs on our stash so we don’t have to. Check out our definitive list of the best humidor hygrometers and discover how to choose one, adjust it if necessary, and learn why it’s more important than any other tool.

Read More

CIGAR NEWS: DT&T Adding Muestra De Saka ‘The Bewitched’

Reading Time: 3 minutes If you don’t think Steve Saka gets too excited about the cigars he creates, then wait until you read about the Muestra de Saka ‘The Bewitched’ that’s coming to a limited number of cigar stores this summer. Learn more about its real magical story here.

Read More
bulleit bourbon baccarat cigar pairing rev

CA Happy Hour: Bulleit Bourbon and Baccarat Cigar Pairing

Most bourbons lean on the sweet side - especially Bulleit. So for this Happy Hour, we match the spicy-sweet Bulleit Bourbon Frontier Whiskey with the sweet-n-smooth Baccarat Churchill for our must-have Happy Hour cigar pairing. A creamy combo that's full of flavor - try for yourself and see!
Read More