Food & Drink

2018 CA Report: Top 10 Red Wine and Cigar Pairings

The 10 Best Cigars to Pair With Red Wine

By Tommy Zman Zarzecki

Ah, cigars… those tasty tobacco packed cylinders that pair so amazingly well with a whole lot of the finer things in life… good friends, great food, hearty coffee, and as far as libations go, we’re always talking about matching them up with the brown liquors and our favorite beers (relax, buddy, just calm the hell down – nobody said anything about Coors Light, all right?!). But for one reason or another, you don’t see wine talked about very much, which is a bit perplexing – because red wine, in particular, is the perfect match-up with a premium hand rolled smoke. Make no mistake, red wine and cigar pairings are to be taken seriously.

The deep fruitiness and the complexities of some of my favorite vinos make for one hell of a companion to my nightly relaxing smoke out on the back patio. And what’s really interesting is that the way wines are made is incredibly similar to the way cigars are made, and I often talk about those similarities when explaining cigar making to newbies who want to know more. There are many different types of grapes, grown in various countries, in various regions with different climates and conditions, just like when it comes to growing and cultivating cigar tobacco. Then there’s the fermenting, blending and aging processes, which lead to a wine’s body and flavor profiles – again, very comparable to cigars.

Today I give you five reds that I really enjoy and recommend to you when firing up a good smoke:

  • Shiraz – A very popular dinner wine from Australia and South Africa. It’s spicy, peppery, deep red in color, complex and full-bodied with notes of blackberry and plums. I’ll have this with a nice hearty steak dinner.
  • Zinfandel – No, not “White” Zinfandel, the pink sugar water that neophytes and young cackling hens fawn over. I’m talking about the delicious red that is the standard from California. Very complex with notes of black cherry, raspberry, blackberries and raisins.
  • Cabernet SauvignonCalifornia’s finest, dense, thick and full-bodied, coating the palate with purple and black currants and black cherry. Great with heavier meals, but equally delicious all on its own.
  • Pinot Noir – Many come from northern California, but the state of Oregon has really become the premiere growing region. It’s generally a more medium-bodied wine that goes great with things like chicken and seafood. Notes of cherries, blackberry and plum.
  • Tawny Port – A dessert wine that’s made for sipping and one of my favorite drinks to accompany a cigar. True Port is made with grapes grown in Portugal. I like Tawny better than Ruby Port as it offers an array of more subtle, complex flavors like blackberry, raspberry, caramel, cinnamon and chocolate.

 

So let’s take a look at my cigar picks for pairing with red wines:

Arturo Fuente Don Carlos

Belicoso (5 3/8″ x 52)   Wrapper: African Cameroon   Inside: Dominican

red wine and cigar pairings Arturo Fuente Don Carlos cigarsThe Don Carlos is rich, spicy, and very full-bodied, and a favorite of Fuente Family fans, with notes of espresso, dark chocolate, wood and pepper. It pairs so well with an Australian Shiraz (love Penfolds) as its spiciness holds up to this bold Fuente’s flavor profile. This is a stellar combination.

 

Aging Room Solera Sun Grown

Belicoso (6 1/8″ x 57)   Wrapper: Dominican Sun Grown   Inside: Dominican

red wine and cigar pairings Aging Room Solera Sun Grown cigarsThis is a medium-bodied stick that boasts one hell of a lot of full flavor! Delicious notes of espresso, citrus, and a nice nuttiness – and since the tobaccos are blended in a style that’s similar to the Solera method used in Spanish wines, this Aging Room is a natural for almost any red wine and cigar pairings. I think a fruity, medium-bodied Pinot Noir matches up nicely here, and the Twill Stormy Morning out of Oregon is an exceptional choice.

 

EP Carrillo La Historia

E-III (6 7/8″ x 54)   Wrapper: Mexican San Andres   Inside: Dominican, Nicaragua & Ecuador Sumatra

red wine and cigar pairings EP Carillo La Historia cigarsThis dark, box-pressed beauty was the #2 Cigar of the Year back in 2014 because it is simply outstanding. Notes of dark chocolate, nuts and espresso lace this full-flavored, complex work of art. Cap the end of the day off with this and a rich and flavorful Cab and you’ll be in heaven. An impeccable selection would be a California Jordan, a wine that is like drinking liquid silk.

 

Gran Habano #5 Corojo

Gran Robusto (6″ x 54)   Wrapper: Nicaraguan Corojo   Inside: Costa Rica & Nicaragua

red wine and cigar pairings Gran Habano 5 Corojo cigarsThe Gran Habano has been a longtime go-to stick of mine with its sweetness coming from that gorgeous Corojo outer leaf. Its flavor profile gives off wonderful notes of coffee, nuts, and a creamy earthiness. The complexity of a Zinfandel with its berry and raisin components makes it the perfect mate to the #5. Quivira Dry Creek is a top pick Zin.

 

Java by Drew Estate

The 58 (5″ x 58 Robusto)   Wrapper: Brazilian Mata Fina   Inside: Nicaragua

red wine and cigar pairings Java by Drew Estate cigarsThe Java is one of my favorite after-dinner cigars that I always enjoy pairing with a sweet Tawny Port to make for the perfect dessert. This medium-bodied premium square-pressed delight gives off a luscious scent of coffee beans, as the sweetness of the port taken in small sips makes it one of those dream red wine and cigar pairings. Skip the cheesecake and go for a Taylor Fladgate 20 year old. I guarantee you send me a thank you email.

 

Tatuaje Miami

Reserva Gran Cojonu (6 ½” x 60)   Wrapper: Ecuador Habano   Inside: Nicaragua

red wine and cigar pairings Tatuaje Miami cigarsThis Tatuaje is a full-bodied, full-flavored Nicaraguan complexity that ranks high on many lists, with a peppery start that quickly fades into the taste of rich coffee beans and dark fruit. A great vino to go with the Miami is a Zinfandel that is loaded with dark berry flavors. Damn, what a wonderful pairing – Peachy Canyon makes some terrific Zins.

 

Inferno Flashpoint Maduro

Torpedo (6 ½” x 52)   Wrapper: Mexican San Andreas   Inside: Nicaragua

red wine and cigar pairings Inferno Flashpoint Maduro cigarsThis Flashpoint, made by Oliva, is a deliciously smooth cigar that hails from Nicaragua with a spicy Mexican San Andres wrapper. Full-bodied, but not strong, it’s earthy with notes of coffee bean and dark wood. Love smoking this with a nice spicy Shiraz as the flavors marry so nicely. Boland Cellar of South Africa makes some damned tasty reds.

 

Trinidad Esteli by Plasencia

Belicoso (6 ½” x 52)   Wrapper: Nicaraguan   Inside: Nicaragua

red wine and cigar pairings Trinidad Esteli by Plasencia cigarsNestor Plasencia Jr. has knocked it out of the park with this Nicaraguan-made offering. It is extremely complex and full-flavored, but not strong or overpowering by any means. The smoke is creamy, thick and smooth on the palate with notes of sweet spice, earth, and a deep woodiness. I smoked it with a sinfully delicious Sterling Vineyards Cabernet and I never wanted it to end.

 

Rocky Patel 20th Anniversary

Toro (6″ x 52)   Wrapper: Honduras   Inside: Honduras & Nicaragua

red wine and cigar pairings Rocky Patel 20th Anniversary cigarsThe Rocky 20th is a hell of a decadent cigar, dark, box-pressed, full-bodied, and silky-smooth. Pronounced notes of wood, espresso, and cocoa lace the palate with a sweet smack of cinnamon. When I light up an ultra-premium cigar of this caliber, it’s often after a hearty dinner and paired with a Tawny Port for dessert. Go for a Fonseca 20 year old with its warm fruit, cinnamon and butterscotch notes and life will have a hard time getting any better than this.

 

Romeo y Julieta Reserva Real

Magnum (6″ x 60)   Wrapper: Ecuador Connecticut   Inside: Dominican Republic & Nicaragua

red wine and cigar pairings Romeo Y Julieta Reserva Real cigarsWhile the Reserva Real sports a smooth, creamy, lighter colored Ecuadorian wrapper, the inner blend is spicy and full, giving the cigar a nice medium-bodied profile. It’s woody and nutty with a hint of peppery spice. The perfect pairing would be with a nice, medium-bodied Pinot Noir, and Holdredge Russian River Valley from California makes a wonderfully fruity concoction with ripe cherry flavors.

 

So, I hope I got your palate ready to shake things up a bit from the usual whiskey or beer nightcap, and try some super flavorful red wine and cigar pairings. The comment section is below, and we’d love to hear what you think!

newest oldest most voted
Kap Kaplowitz
Guest
Kap Kaplowitz

Tawny Port is the moolah.

Pete Graziano
Guest
Pete Graziano

I Smoke most cigars paired with my homemade wine. It’s the bomb.
In the winter a good port and a Maduro is a great combo.

Giles Light
Guest
Giles Light

Interesting, though I normally prefer a stick with beer or whisky. As an aside, the article describes Java as “This medium-bodied premium …” while the Famous Smokel Shop describes it as “a mild to medium-bodied box-pressed…”

Ron Tramazzo
Guest
Ron Tramazzo

I love sipping a good wine with my cigars!

Angela Jeffery-Alexander
Guest
Angela Jeffery-Alexander

Excellent article and resourceful information worth hold on to, you really did a great job pairing cigars and wine 🍷

Chris Eckstein
Guest
Chris Eckstein

Totally agree a nice medium+ cigar pairs well with the reds. Great reference to use for cigars I’ve not had the opportunity to try yet. Keep up the good work as this was as good read!!

Curt Renow
Guest
Curt Renow

Can totally agree with you Z-man on the Tatty, Romeo, and the Don Carlos #2. Those 3 are well stocked in my humidor. I also love the Montecristo #2 (Cuban) with my red wine.

Jon Leffew
Guest
Jon Leffew

Ever try a Kristoff with a nice tawny port?……SUBLIME

Bożena Dragosz
Guest
Bożena Dragosz

Cigars are also interesting in combination with white wines like Italian pinig grigio or champagnes :-)

Tommy Zman Zarzecki

Tommy Zman Zarzecki

Editor-at-Large

Tommy Zman, is an obsessive enjoyer of life’s leafy pleasures. Growing up in the bowels of northern New Jersey, parented by an eccentric Polish father and a neurotic Italian mother, what else could this man possibly be other than a humorist? ZMan’s a real throwback to a time when men were kings of the castle and smoking a cigar in public didn’t label you an outcast and a pariah. He’s an old–school down to earth guy - but when it comes to p.c. tyranny and nanny-state legislature, he’ll draw his sword and swing for the fences. Tommy gathered a faithful following as a longtime feature writer at Cigar Magazine, and his testosterone laden FaceBook community, CROMAG NATION™ is truly the last great bastion for Men’s Men.

Show all Tommy Zman Zarzecki's Articles
best cigars for manning the grill Cigar Advisor Cover

2019 CA Report: Best Cigars When You’re Manning the Grill

Whether you’re actually manning the grill or busy devouring all that barbecued goodness (or both) – here are the best cigars to pair with it all. WARNING: Read with caution; this may cause you to eat your monitor.

Read More
happy hour lagunitas ipa montecristo relentless cigar pairing cacover

CA Happy Hour: Lagunitas IPA & Montecrusto Relentless Cigar Pairing

A solid Fall pairing: let’s savor these last few weeks of cigar weather by enjoying a cigar with a little extra flair, and kick a beer in there while we’re at it. Monte meets IPA, in this edition of Happy Hour.

Read More
2018 top thanksgiving cigars cacover

2018 CA REPORT: Thanksgiving Cigars – Different Smokes for Different Folks

Just as there are many tasty food choices for Thanksgiving dinner, not every dish suits every palate; the same goes for your Turkey Day smokes. See our top hand-rolled premium picks for Thanksgiving cigars that will satisfy every kind of smoker on your holiday guest list!

Read More
gran habano #5 Corojo cigar review MWC CACover

My Weekend Cigar: Jan. 29, 2018 – Gran Habano #5 Corojo Gran Robusto

The Gran Habano #5 Corojo has been a tried-and-true go-to cigar since I discovered it 15 years ago...and to this day, still doesn't disappoint. See my Gran Habano review and get my tasting notes to find out more about My Weekend Cigar!
Read More