Cigar Buying Guides

Battle: 12 Sticks Reviewed by the Price of Cigars

Reading Time: 5 minutes

12 Recommendations Based on the Price of Cigars

Welcome to the Battle! If you’ve been flipping through Cigar Advisor looking for those “ratings” pages full of inflated numbers, slanted cigar reviews and stupid phrases like “pleasant subset” or “humble notes” – you’re out of luck. We don’t do that here. Instead, we give you the facts on each stick and leave picking the winners up to you. Now…how did we pick the smokes for the Battle? We just happen to like ’em for one reason or another. As for the descriptions, we’re going off of what flavor the fillers have, where the wrapper is from, and so on…and a little bit of personal experience, too. So we pick a few smokes, lay them out in a particular set of categories and let them fight it out.

For this first installment of the Battle, we’re going on price of cigars – we’ve got cigars under $4 per stick, under $7, under $10 and $10+. Because let’s face it – while sometimes you end up buying on price, nobody ever said you can’t have a good, handmade cigar for a couple singles.


Round 1 – Price of Cigars: under $4 a stick….Fight!

price of cigars j fuego origen cigars on saleJ. Fuego Origen Originals – the Samurai of the under $4 crowd – old world tradition with honed skills. Bold, 100% Corojo exudes the richness of the old country’s way of blending. Harnesses its full-bodied spiciness to slice through your lips like cold Japanese steel in the hands of a master.

[Ed. Note: J. Fuego Origen cigars are no longer in stock at Famous Smoke Shop; click the image to view other J. Fuego cigar options.]


price of cigars schizo cigars on saleSchizo Sixty – Like all serial killers, it’s always the quiet ones. All-Nicaraguan shortfiller tobaccos give it a mild to medium profile with a cool, clean taste. But give it an opportunity, and it becomes a killer – performing consistently well in burn, flavor, and aroma.


price of cigars trocadero cigars on saleTrocadero Honore – calm, cool and collected, like a fighter pilot. Sure, the Nicaraguan blend will take you for a quick, high-G turn from mild to medium body every once in a while – but this Top Gun has your 6, if you’re looking for medium-mellow. Wrapped in an Ecuador Habano Rosado leaf, it’s got more flavor than just any everyday smoke.


Round 2 – Price of Cigars: under $7 a stick….Fight!

price of cigars torano loyal cigars on saleTorano Loyal Robusto – it’s got your back! Our first fighter in the under 7 battle, Torano Loyal covers you better than a backup piece in your sock. Handmade with long fillers hailing from both Nicaragua and the DR, and they throw on a coat of oily Ecuadorian Sumatra wrapper for good measure. In a word, solid – like that 450lb bouncer at the door to the bar. Peppery to start, mellows once you get to know it.


price of cigars perdomo champagne cigars on sale 1Perdomo Champagne Noir Robusto – a Nicaraguan puro blended with Viso, Seco & Ligero in a Cuban-seed Maduro wrapper. But Perdomo puts the Champ in Champagne, triple-fermenting the leaves for over 14 months…then giving them another 6 month workout in oak bourbon barrels. The result: lean, clean and mean. A sweet, medium-bodied smoke with rich flavors.


price of cigars muwat baitfish cigars on saleMUWAT Bait Fish – Drew Estate + Joya de Nicaragua = firepower! It’s a banger: Brazilian Mata Fina Oscuro, Nicaraguan Esteli Ligero, Nicaraguan Seco Jalapa and Nicaraguan Viso Condega longfillers are locked and loaded into CT Broadleaf Maduro binders, and wrapped in San Andreas Negro capas. Damn.



Round 3 – Price of Cigars: under $10 a stick….Fight!


price of cigars aging room small batch m356 cigars on saleAging Room Small Batch M356 Major – made by Boutique Blends, it’s the bareknuckle boxer of the under $10 group – rare these days. The tobaccos inside lay untouched in the factory until one fateful Monday in December, 2008 – which makes it an instant classic. Smoking one is a memorable experience: there’s plenty of strength, complemented by a refined flavor and aroma. Get in the ring!


price of cigars davidoff grand cru cigars on saleDavidoff Grand Cru No. 5 – Davidoff is known as a lover, not a fighter – but the fact that you can stumble into their top tier of smooth, ultra-refined Dominican quality for under ten bucks in this petite corona size makes this stick a knockout choice. It’s some of Davidoff’s best tobacco working hard, here.


price of cigars trinidad paradox cigars on saleTrinidad Paradox Churchill – Paradox is a brawler with balance – brass knuckles on one hand, a blackjack in the other and smile on his face. Handcrafted with Nicaraguan longfillers, Dominican binder and a Mexican San Andres Criollo ’98 wrapper. The flavors offer great balance with that smile of sweetness in the mix.


Round 4 – Price of Cigars: over $10 a stick….Fight!


price of cigars camacho diploma cigars on saleCamacho Diploma Figurado – This diploma? Earned on the street. Made with a rare blend of 1997 vintage Corojo leaf grown in the Jamastran Valley of Honduras, the tobacco is fermented for 2 full years to deliver a smooth, full-bodied smoke. It’s got rhythm, and it’s got flow – and it’s taking you to school, son. Respect!


price of cigars padilla miami cigars on salePadilla Miami Maduro Torpedo – Miami Maduro operates like a page straight out of “The Art of War.” Using special tactics, Padilla lures you in with a medium start – then sneaks up on you in a rush, as the Nicaraguan longfillers wrapped in a San Andres Maduro bodysuit strike out in a full-bodied pepper shot to make you its concubine. And like an ancient Chinese warrior, it’s rare – only 1500 are made each month.


price of cigars rocky patel 15th anniversary cigars on saleRocky Patel 15th Anniversary Toro – Rocky Patel calls this heavyweight prizefighter “a Decade on steroids.” It’s handmade using a blend of Nicaraguan longfillers from a “special” farm in Esteli…like a top secret, underground training compound, we guess. Completing the blend are a Nicaraguan Jalapa binder and Ecuadorian Sumatra wrapper. With a full body and plenty of strength, it’s the Ivan Drago of the bunch – elegance and balance, but with a punch that puts it over the top. It must break you.


Notify of
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
John Pullo

John Pullo

Editor in Chief

This is not his picture, nor does he even have a beard. A solid 'B' student and occasional low-fi musician, John is a medley of cynicism and sarcasm crammed into a wrinkled Oxford shirt who makes it nearly intolerable to watch reality television with him in the same room. Interestingly, his Social Security number is all ones.

Show all John Pullo's Articles
cigar advisor how long it takes to make a cigar - cover

How Long Does it Take to Make a Premium Cigar?

Reading Time: 6 minutes How long does it take to make a cigar? It’s an easy question with a complicated answer. Managing Editor, John Pullo takes you from seed to shelf covering every process along the way, plus a short video!

Read More
cigar advisor top new cigars july 10, 2023 - cover

Top New Cigars (July 10, 2023)

Reading Time: 2 minutes Another day, another cigar! The latest sticks from Macanudo, PDR, and Villiger have impressed my palate. Will they do the same to yours? Click now for my quick reviews and find out!

Read More
cigar advisor news – crowned heads announces release of las calaveras el 2023 cigars – release – cover image

Cigar News: Crowned Heads Announces Release of Las Calaveras EL 2023 Cigars

Reading Time: 2 minutes One of the most highly anticipated limited editions released each year is the Las Calaveras series by Crowned Heads cigars. This year, the three vitola line has returned to using a Connecticut Broadleaf wrapper, plus one more surprise. Read all about it here.

Read More
#nowsmoking Southern Draw Rose of Sharon Desert Rose Famous Exclusivo Toro cigar review Cigar Advisor Cover

#nowsmoking: Southern Draw Desert Rose Exclusivo

Reading Time: 4 minutes Gary reviews the new Southern Draw Desert Rose Famous Exclusivo, a Toro made expressly for Famous Smoke Shop in a limited release. Slightly tweaked for extra body, see how this LE blend compares to the original Desert Rose – and discover some interesting peculiarities.

Read More