Cigar Ratings & Reviews

CAO Italia Positano

CAO Italia Positano Cigar

Score: 8.8

By Hayward Tenney

On the docket today is a CAO Italia, which has been described as a unique, aromatic, must-try type of cigar. Skeptic that I am, I guess I’ll have to find out the old-fashioned way. Boy, is my job tough….Will it live up to its reputation? Or will my Friday afternoon suffer from un Rocket di Doggi? Will Superman reach Lois Lane in time? Read on to find out.

The Toro is visually impressive. Its smooth Honduran Connecticut wrapper is a rich, reddish-brown, with minimal veins. I find no soft spots, and the head and foot seem to be in order. It clips easily, revealing a round patch of sweet-smelling longfillers.

While the cold draw is tight, its unique sweet tobacco flavor echoes the aroma from the head and foot. The cigar lights up nicely, producing a steady, if slightly anemic, stream of smoke. By no means are my neck’s blood vessels bursting, but neither am I bathing in a stinky, creamy cloud (my personal preference).

A couple puffs in, its aroma is unlike anything I’ve smelled from a cigar, and for once in my life I’m at a loss for words. The best comparison I can muster is sweet, damp earthiness…think poppy seed filling. Maybe there’s something to be said for Italian tobacco – this cigar’s aroma is absolutely intoxicating. As the tightly rolled tobacco fades into evenly mottled white and grey ash of about an inch, I’d call the cigar medium-bodied. While its well-balanced flavors mirror its aroma, I’m left wishing I could draw more smoke.

But by the beginning of the second third, things are really getting interesting. The flavors have caramelized, and in addition to this enhanced complexity, an easier draw rewards me with more smoke. The burn line has improved to a razor-sharp ring, working its way down nice and slow (another personal preference). Just before the final third, I’m greeted by notes of coffee, a perfect complement to an already dynamite flavor profile.

At the last 2 ½ – 3″, the smoke has settled in the medium to full-body range. Its unique sweetness has deferred to the caramelized coffee flavors accenting its baseline earthiness. The cigar burns perfectly right down to the nub.

If nothing else, I find the cigar an accurate portrait of the Italian lifestyle: aesthetically pleasing, deliberately indulgent and down-to-earth, yet free-spirited. I will likely pick up a box of these. If you haven’t gotten the chance to try one yet, I highly suggest you do so soon.

Appearance: 9
Construction: 9
Burn: 9
Draw: 8
Aroma: 10
Flavor: 8
Final Score: 8.8

Gary Korb

Gary Korb

Executive Editor

Gary Korb has been writing and editing content for CigarAdvisor.com since its debut in 2008. An avid cigar smoker for over 30 years, during the past 12 years he has worked on the marketing side of the premium cigar business as a Sr. Copywriter, blogger, and cigar reviewer. A graduate of the Newhouse School of Public Communications at Syracuse University, prior to his career in the cigar business, Gary worked in the music and video industry as a marketer and a publicist.

Show all Gary Korb's Articles
nowsmoking avo maduro 30th anniversary cigar review ca cover

#Nowsmoking: Avo Maduro No. 2 30th Anniversary

The Avo Maduro No.2 30th Anniversary is an affordably-priced maduro with well-rounded flavors of cedar, dark chocolate, spices, and more. Click to see the rest of the review

Read More
Trinidad Esteli cigar Review video CACover

Cigar Advisor Panel: Trinidad Esteli Cigar Review – Video

Just off the boat from Nicaragua, Trinidad Esteli cigars are here - and the Advisor Review Panel has smoked it and recorded their critiques. Our expectations were pretty high for this full-bodied blend...but the question is, did the new Trinidad Estelí live up to them? Find out by clicking NOW to watch our review!
Read More
Mothers day cigars cigar smoking moms CACover

2018 CA Report: Cigar Recommendations from Cigar Smoking Moms

This Mother’s Day we’re taking a look at the Cigar Smoking Moms of the Cigar Industry – the "leading ladies of tobacco," if you will. Join us for a sit-down with the matriarchs of the premium cigar world to find the best cigars for you to smoke this Mother’s Day. When it’s comes to cigars, Mom’s the word.
Read More
my favorite barrel aged cigars

2015 CA Report: Five Top Barrel Aged Cigars

Barrel aged cigars are the cigar world's newest, tastiest trend; see how oak barrel aging tobacco has such a huge effect on the flavor of these 5 cigars!
Read More