Cigar Ratings & Reviews

Cigar Review: PDR 1878 Cubano Especial Robusto Capa Madura

Reading Time: 2 minutes

Construction and Overall Appearance: At the risk of sounding redundant, I just LOVE those sweet curlicue pigtails on some cigars, and according to Abe Flores, his are done by one of the best in the business. The chocolaty brown Mata Fina wrapper was thick with an attractive, shimmery patina and even in tone. Cigar was well-packed and rolled.

Draw: Very good. No problems here.

Pre-light flavor: Very spicy and a bit salty

Toasting & Light: Excellent

Base flavors: dark wood, earthy, mild pepper, and a hint of sweet tobacco

Retrohale: Woo! Creamy, yet potent.

Aroma: Very inviting with a unique malty quality

Burn / Ash Quality: Even-Steven burn, resulting in a very firm grey marble ash.

Balance of flavors: Excellent and impressively complex

Consistency: Excellent

General Observations: I cut the pigtail at the base, and though it looked like it was still sealed, the cigar drew well. The first few puffs weren’t spicy, but the malty aroma really stood out. Shortly after, some pepper entered the picture leaving the back of my throat a little prickly. That said, the smoke was impressively smooth. At just under an inch the pepper faded, and all I could say for the first act was “Wow.” The smoke was very creamy with plenty of earthiness, plus some light peppery notes that didn’t overpower the lighter flavors. The finish was long with some pepper remaining on the palate

At the midpoint the flavor was more like that of dark wood, with light peppery notes and a hint of sweet tobacco. Looking at the clock, I noticed this cigar had been burning for a long time, which was most likely due to the choice of dark tobaccos and the excellent packing.

By the last third, the cigar bloomed into a very robust smoke. Mostly very dark woody, charry flavors while the pepper, though not overpowering figured more prominently in the mix.

Summary: I really enjoyed this cigar and smoked it down to the last inch. Even then, it never turned bitter, had great balance all the way, and the cigar burned perfectly, even after surviving three re-lights. Though I paired it with spring water, and smoked it during the afternoon, I think this cigar would be wonderful as an after dinner treat with a good Port to give it some extra sweetness, or a fine single malt to dovetail with the cigar’s earthier elements. Not for rookies, as this blend may be a bit too heavy for those new to cigars. Suffice it to say, you will really get your money’s worth out of this reasonably-priced cigar.


Rating scale?
? = Fair to Middling?
?? = Good?
??? = Very impressive
???? = Excellent
????? = Spectacular!

Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Gary Korb

Gary Korb

Executive Editor

Gary Korb has been writing and editing content for since its debut in 2008. An avid cigar smoker for over 30 years, he has worked on the marketing side of the premium cigar business as a Sr. Copywriter, blogger, and Executive Editor of Cigar Advisor. A graduate of the Newhouse School of Public Communications at Syracuse University, prior to his career in the cigar business, Gary worked in the music and video industry as a marketer and a publicist.

Show all Gary Korb's Articles
cigar advisor #nowsmoking cigar review muestra de saka the bewitched - cover

#NowSmoking: Muestra de Saka The Bewitched

Reading Time: 4 minutes One of the more anticipated releases in the PCU (the Premium Cigar Universe) are the Muestra de Saka cigars from Dunbarton Tobacco & Trust. Here Gary reviews ‘The Bewitched.’ So, did it captivate his palate? Check it out now and find out.

Read More
cigar advisor #nowsmoking cigar review of cao cameroon l'anniversaire - cover

#NowSmoking: CAO Cameroon L’Anniversaire

Reading Time: 4 minutes Released in 1999, the CAO Cameroon L’Anniversaire is considered a classic selection, and Gary’s got the scoop on the Toro for this cigar review. Dressed in bright new bands, has this medium-bodied box-pressed cigar held-up over time? Watch now and read all about it.

Read More
cigar advisor news - cao cigars rick rodriguez retires - cover


Reading Time: 2 minutes CAO Cigars blender and brand ambassador, Rick Rodriguez, is retiring from the label after 22 years. His early mentors, Benji Menendez, Daniel Nuñez, and Ernesto Perez-Carrillo, helped put him on a path that would win Rick top rating scores and scores of good friends.

Read More
cigar advisor best medium bodied cigars - cover

CA Report: 10 Best Medium Bodied Cigars

Reading Time: 7 minutes Check out our guide to medium-bodied bliss with top cigar reviews from Romeo y Julieta, Rocky Patel, Drew Estate, Oliva, and much more!

Read More