Cigar Ratings & Reviews

Cigar Review: Punch Rare Corojo 10th Anniversary Connecticut

Retrohale: Very peppery. Whew!

Base flavors: Creamy, smooth, earthy and a little nutty with some toffee-like flavors.

Aroma: Sweet, not too overpowering

Ash/Burn: In the first half inch the ash was sharp, firm and marbled in color. The burn was pretty even, and the first ash fell off at about the 3/4-inch mark on both samples.

General Observations: Notes of pepper and cream in the first inch. Into the second inch, I picked up a little nutmeg flavor. For some reason I expected this cigar to be a little sweeter. Into the second half, both cigars really started to sizzle with more spice, dark tobacco flavors, and a trace of espresso in the mix. My second sample turned bitter in the last act, but the first tasted good down to an inch.

Summary: Sort of mixed emotions here. I have a feeling this cigar met all of General’s expectations in terms of what they wanted to do with the 10th Anniversary blend. I also feel this cigar has a lot going for it, but, speaking from personal preference, I think I like the original Ecuadorian Sumatra leaf better. Definitely a must-smoke for Punch fanatics and those who like a spicy, complex smoke with a very full flavor.

Final Rating: ??½

To see all Punch Rare Corojo cigars click here.

Rating scale
? = Fair to Midland
?? = Good
??? = Excellent
???? = Outstanding

Gary Korb

Gary Korb

Executive Editor

Gary Korb has been writing and editing content for CigarAdvisor.com since its debut in 2008. An avid cigar smoker for over 30 years, during the past 12 years he has worked on the marketing side of the premium cigar business as a Sr. Copywriter, blogger, and cigar reviewer. A graduate of the Newhouse School of Public Communications at Syracuse University, prior to his career in the cigar business, Gary worked in the music and video industry as a marketer and a publicist.

Show all Gary Korb's Articles
nowsmoking fratello oro cigar review cacover corona

#Nowsmoking: Fratello Oro Corona

The Fratello Oro Corona offers a creamy, anytime-of-day smoke teeming with notes of cedar, spice and white pepper.

Read More
ryj romeo montague by AJ Fernandez cigar review video CACover

Cigar Advisor Panel: Romeo y Julieta Montague by AJ Fernandez Cigar Review

When AJ Fernandez puts his name on a cigar, you can bet it rips with flavor - so this month's Cigar Review Panel tests that theory with RyJ Montague by AJ Fernandez. On paper, this Maduro Romeo looks like their most potent RyJ smoke ever - but does it meet up with the AJF reputation? Watch our review now and see!
Read More
2018 top father's day cigar gifts

2018 CA Report: Top Father’s Day Cigar Gifts

Stumped on a Father`s Day gift? No problem: treat Dad to some Father’s Day love, cigar style! The Advisors have hand-selected 12 Father's Day cigar gifts that are guaranteed to please and won’t dent your wallet. See our curated gift picks and get your Dad what he really wants: a good cigar, and some honest relaxation!
Read More
CA master blenders jose blanco

Master Blenders: José Blanco – Dominican Cigar Maker, Educator, and More (’16)

Hear José Blanco - cigar legend - talk about life in the cigar business, the cigars he's created, the ongoing battle with the FDA, Cuban cigars, and more.
Read More