Cigar Buying Guides

CA Report: Connecticut Tobacco Roundup – Shade vs. Broadleaf Wrapper

Connecticut Tobacco Roundup: Shade vs. Broadleaf

By John Pullo

Connecticut tobacco has been grown in large quantities for two centuries. Think about that – for over 200 years, tobacco has been part of Connecticut’s agriculture backbone, supplying the premium cigar market with two of its tastiest ingredients. Drive through the Connecticut River Valley north of Hartford, and it wouldn’t be odd for you to see a field of Shade on one side of the road, and a field of Broadleaf growing right across the street – two very different plants, they could be growing just yards from each other. But for as close as they may be, they couldn’t be farther apart in taste, feel and flavor.

These two types of Connecticut tobacco get different treatment in the field, too: Broadleaf plants are topped (meaning the flower on top is snapped off); because the plant realizes it can’t produce seed anymore, the plant puts all its energy into producing big, thick and heavy leaves with very pronounced veins. The flowers on Shade plants get to bloom, because the grower is looking to get that thin, flawless tobacco.

Shade plants, like many other tobaccos (Connecticut, or otherwise), is primed – meaning the individual leaves are snapped off the plant, starting from the bottom. In Connecticut, the harvest is usually done three leaves at a time, every seven to ten days; the workers normally do five or six primings, for a total of 15 to 18 leaves.

Broadleaf is its own animal, however. Broadleaf started life as binder and filler, but now is also in high demand for wrapper – producing intense flavors and bold smoke. It’s grown in full sun to produce heavy, flavorful leaves that burn slowly. Instead of priming, the whole plant is taken near the base with the swing of an axe; this is why you hear the term “stalk-cut.”

Bonus stat for farming geeks: Broadleaf plants are spaced very far apart in the field, usually 24 inches on the row; Connecticut Shade plants are spaced 12 inches apart to provide extra cover for the lower priming leaves.

As demand for Maduro continues to increase, the lighter, mellower shade leaf is said to be losing its grip on the market; Crain’s Business Newsletter wondered out loud last year whether there “may be a Connecticut industry with zero producers of shade tobacco next year [meaning 2017].” Reports of Shade’s demise is decidedly premature, evidenced by the fact that shade-grown Connecticut tobacco has been – and still is – at the top of the quality heap. Look at Macanudo: consistent, mild and creamy-smooth, the flavor is everything a grower is going for with a good batch of CT shade. Dunhill Aged is another top shelf smoke that uses the real deal, making for a decadent cigar smoking experience that leans more towards the velvety side. Same goes for Don Diego, an often overlooked example of top grade Connecticut tobacco.

If this is your flavor wheel house, these five are a good jumping off point for cigars wrapped in Connecticut Shade:


buy Montecristo cigars connecticut tobaccoThe embodiment of Dominican luxury, the bar is set high – and it’s why the Connecticut wrappers come from a small farm that’s devoted to supplying the leaf for just 2 or 3 brands, Montecristo included. Nothing but the best because, well, it’s…Montecristo. Smoke it, and you’ll see why Connecticut Shade has cultivated such a renowned reputation.


Don Tomas Special Edition Connecticut

buy Don Tomas cigars connecticut tobaccoNormally, a CT shade wrapper starts hiking up the price on any premium; that flavor comes at a cost, as you know. But Don Tomas bucks convention with this smooth-smoking Special Edition Connecticut: first, it’s a special edition smoke for the price of an everyday burn. Second, it features a genuine, U.S.-grown Connecticut Shade wrapper atop the Dominican-Mexican-Nicaraguan long filler blend. Mild-medium, with creamy and toasty flavors. It’s a warm, not bitter, smoke.


Ashton Cabinet Selection

buy Ashton Cabinet selection cigars connecticut cigarsAs I mentioned, no surprise that you’re finding real-deal Connecticut Shade wrappers on many of the finer humidor selections…and it’s up here on the top shelf, that we find Ashton Cabinet. Again, mild-medium – and again, crafted with select aged Dominican tobaccos under the Connecticut Valley’s finest. Creamy-smooth, because this Ashton is aged a full year after it’s been rolled in the DR. A treat, for sure.


New World Connecticut by AJ Fernandez

buy New World Connecticut cigars connecticut tobaccoIf you have yet to step up to the plate with an AJ-made cigar, the time is right…New World Connecticut breaks from Fernandez tradition of big n’ spicy, combining aged Nicaraguan & Brazilian long fillers with a Mexican San Andres binder, all under a true U.S. Connecticut Shade leaf. Mellow, creamy and mild – yes, a radical departure from his usual recipes, but the New World CT falls into just about any smoker’s wheelhouse.


Rocky Patel Vintage Connecticut 1999

buy Rocky Patel Vintage Connecticut 1999 cigars connecticut tobaccoNot all Connecticut Shades are mild. Evidence: Rocky Patel Vintage ’99. The aged Dominican & Nicaraguan long fillers make the difference here, adding some toasty intensity and aroma while keeping the smoke thick, creamy and slightly sweet. The vintage CT wrapper is the cherry on top. An “accessible” smoke for newcomers, this is a Rocky that may make even the veterans rethink the move to full-bodied cigars.



Now to the Broadleaf…thick and juicy, it adds a punch of flavor and body that can take a blend to another level. On any given day, the INCH by EPC is a hearty smoking adventure; but when Ernesto Perez Carrillo gives the Inch blend a Connecticut Broadleaf wrapper, it’s a smoother, medium-to-full cigar. Smoking the Oliva Serie G Maduro is a similar experience, where this dark and oily Connecticut leaf takes this cigar from good to great. Broadleaf is no secret, however, as it’s used to great effect on the classics – like Hoyo de Monterrey, the spicy-sweet Onyx Reserve, and the uber-full bodied Henry Clay…Saint Luis Rey Serie G uses it as a wrapper and a binder, giving this true “double Maduro” a flavor that’s extra rich. Want some more Broadleaf ideas? Start with these:

Jaime Garcia Reserva Especial

buy Jaime Garcia Reserva Especial cigars connecticut tobaccoLike father, like son…a Pepin family affair, the Reserva Especial combines an all-Nicaraguan recipe of long fillers under the rich, sweet taste of Connecticut Broadleaf. Hearty is an understatement; big earth notes are tinged with spice, plus a component that reminds you of coffee – or maybe cocoa. Intense, and worth it.


Nica Rustica

buy Nica Rustica cigars connecticut tobaccoYou might think that the Liga Privada No. 9 would be the standard-bearer for Drew Estate broadleaf cigars, and you would be right…but not to be missed is Nica Rustica, in all of its rough-hewn glory. The Broadleaf wrapper has a (ahem) rustic look; the flavor is straight fire, smoking raw and full thanks to the San Andres Negro and Nicaraguan tobaccos underneath. Nica Rustica does nothing to dispel the notion that Maduro cigars are strong; it is, and adds some spicy-sweet notes to complete the package.



buy CroMagnon cigars connecticut tobaccoCroMagnon from RoMaCraft exhibits everything beautiful about Broadleaf: oily…toothy…dark…rough around the edges, it is perfect in its imperfection. As for taste? Brace yourself for full and complex flavors, by way of an all-Nicaraguan core touched with Cameroon. The aroma is impeccable, and just a true joy to burn; CroMagnon is a Connecticut tobacco treat that’s not to be missed.


LGC Serie R

buy La Gloria Cubana Serie R cigars connecticut tobaccoI’m thinking the R stands for “robust.” And why shouldn’t it? This La Gloria packs in the heavy stuff, a blend of Nicaraguan Ligero and Dominican Olor that’s wrapped in the genuine article: oily, U.S.-grown Connecticut Broadleaf Maduro. The surprise: this LGC smokes smooth with an ample aroma. A favorite, especially because of the big ring sizes.


Sancho Panza Double Maduro

buy Sancho Panza Double Maduro cigars connecticut tobaccoThe graybeards around these parts will tell you everything you need to know about Broadleaf in two words: Sancho Panza. An old-school smoke from Honduras, Sancho Panza was the whole package before there was such a thing…a 3 nation blend (Honduras, Nicaragua, Dominican) is done in a double Maduro (binder AND wrapper), where the capa is a Connecticut broadleaf aged 4 years and cured to a super-dark Oscuro color. Full bodied and delicious; we’ll leave it at that.


There are so many cigars made with great Connecticut tobacco that it pains me to keep my list at just five of each…I could easily do 25, and still be scratching the surface of great smokes. So if you want to tack on a recommendation for a good Shade or Broadleaf wrapper cigar, here’s your chance – comment below!

Leave a Reply

2 Comment threads
0 Thread replies
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
0 Comment authors
Joe CarterCharles Burns Recent comment authors
newest oldest most voted
Charles Burns
Charles Burns

Only the Montechristo Classic and the Vintage line still use USA Connecticut Shade. The “little farm” now grows only Broadleaf. Nearly all other Altadis “Connecticut Shade” wrapped cigars use the cheaper, inferior Connecticut Seed grown in Ecuador. Buyer beware

Joe Carter
Joe Carter

Rocky Patel’s Sungrown Maduro might be the best broadleaf wrapper cigar on the market at its price point

John Pullo

John Pullo

Editor in Chief

This is not his picture, nor does he even have a beard. A solid 'B' student and occasional low-fi musician, John is a medley of cynicism and sarcasm crammed into a wrinkled Oxford shirt who makes it nearly intolerable to watch reality television with him in the same room. Interestingly, his Social Security number is all ones.

Show all John Pullo's Articles
Top New Baby Cigars Best It’s a Boy Cigars It’s a Girl Cigars Cigar Advisor Cover

2019 CA Report: Top New Baby Cigars – Best It’s a Boy & It’s a Girl Cigars

It’s the most meaningful cigar you’ll ever buy: see our picks for best It’s a Boy & It’s a Girl Cigars, and learn the history of handing out cigars to celebrate the arrival of a new baby…

Read More
2018 perdomo cigars guide perdomo cigar reviews cacover

2018 CA REPORT: The Essential Cigar Advisor Guide To Perdomo Cigars

Curious about Perdomo cigars? The Cigar Advisors have answers, after poring over the entire range of their quintessential Nicaraguan blends. Browse through the Guide, and get the tasting notes now – and discover the Perdomo that fits you best.

Read More
How the #1 Cigar of 2018 Encore Majestic by EP Carrillo was made Cigar Advisor Cover

CA VIDEO: Behind the #1 Cigar of 2018 – Encore Majestic, with EPC

Want to know how EPC made the #1 Cigar of 2018? We dug into the CA Video Vault for a look back at our May ’18 sitdown with Ernesto, and learned everything there is to know about Encore Majestic by EP Carrillo. Watch now, and learn from the Master…

Read More
bigger is better 60 ring cigar buying guide

2015 CA Report: 60 Ring Cigar Buying Guide

In America, bigger is better - evidenced by the 60 ring cigar. We've picked 8 big ring smokes you need to try today - see our list of massive stogies now!
Read More