Cigar Humidification

Cigar Q&A: Does a Cigar Humidor Have to be Airtight?

Q. Does a wooden cigar humidor have to be airtight? I put a flashlight inside mine, and can see the light rays coming out of the gaps along the lid. Is this OK, or does the humidor have to be tight as a submarine hatch?
– Nick V. (U.S Navy)

A. Technically speaking, yes, cigar humidors should be as air-tight as physically possible. When I came into the cigar business, someone told me about a “the dollar test;” if you couldn’t slip the edge of a crisp dollar bill in-between the lid and the base, the humidor had a good seal.

Another method is to open the humidor and place the dollar perpendicular to the edge (as you would feed it into a vending machine) so that half of the bill is on the inside and the other half out. Close the lid, then try to pull the bill out of the humidor. If the humidor has a good seal it should be very difficult to pull the dollar out short of tearing it. Moreover, this test should be done on all four sides of the lid.

In your case, the bigger question should be: despite the gaps, is the humidor keeping the cigars fresh? If your box is within the “normal” range 65-75 degrees x 65-70% relative humidity (RH), then I wouldn’t worry too much about the gaps. If the gaps are exceedingly wide, they will cause problematic variances in your temp & RH. Make sure you have a good digital hygrometer/thermometer to monitor the conditions in the humidor, too.

Finally, if the humidor is brand new and the seal is noticeably out of alignment, return it.

Gary Korb

Gary Korb

Executive Editor

Gary Korb has been writing and editing content for CigarAdvisor.com since its debut in 2008. An avid cigar smoker for over 30 years, during the past 12 years he has worked on the marketing side of the premium cigar business as a Sr. Copywriter, blogger, and cigar reviewer. A graduate of the Newhouse School of Public Communications at Syracuse University, prior to his career in the cigar business, Gary worked in the music and video industry as a marketer and a publicist.

Show all Gary Korb's Articles
nowsmoking H Upmann Connecticut Toro cigar review Cigar Advisor Cover

#nowsmoking: H. Upmann Connecticut Toro

The H. Upmann Connecticut is “smooth, smooth, smooth…” – it’s also a contender to be one of the best Connecticut cigars we’ve smoked all year. Want more? See what else you need to know about this cigar, when you click & read our super-fast H. Upmann Connecticut cigar review now…

Read More
top strong cigars cigar advisor cover

2019 CA Report: 10 Strong Cigars That Should Be On Your Bucket List

Ready to step up to 10 cigars that’ll kick your ash from here ‘til Tuesday? Here’s our picks for the top strong cigars that you need to smoke at least once – bonus points, if you can finish all 10.

Read More
Aganorsa Casa Fernandez Cigar Review

Cigar Advisor Panel: Aganorsa Leaf / Casa Fernandez Reserva Miami Maduro Cigar Review – Video

What happens when Cuban seeds are grown in Nicaragua's richest soil, then cured and aged in the most authentic Cuban tradition? You get Aganorsa Leaf Casa Fernandez cigars. We smoked the full-bodied 6"x54 Miami Reserva Maduro - did this Miami-made delicacy pass the test? Click for our notes, and watch the video now!
Read More
moocher cigars for moochers

2015 CA Report: Moocher Cigars You Won’t Want to Share

Because a cigar moocher appearance at your next outdoor event or gathering is a sure bet, be ready with these 10 tasty ( and very reasonably priced) cigars.
Read More