Cigar Buying Guides

How to Choose the Right Gifts for Cigar Smokers

Reading Time: 4 minutes

Choosing the right gift for someone is never truly easy; I’d argue that Ph.D.-level mathematicians have an easier time making a go of writing abstract geometry theses, than the experience we’ve all faced when trying to buy great gifts for cigar smokers. And make that twice as hard when you’re not quite sure what your cigar smoking pal enjoys. Triple the challenge if you plan to buy the gift from an online cigar store, because it’s hard to “take it for a test drive” – you’re relying on personal experience, or what you’ve heard or read online. So, maybe – just maybe – it’s a good time to stereotype your giftee, and choose the right cigars by matching them to his or her personality. Here are a few that you may know…

El Cheapo Cheap Cigars


Everyone knows El Cheapo: He’s the guy that buys wine by the box, his clothes only when there’s a “Buy 1 Get 3 Free” sale, and crows about how Wal-Mart’s prices are “still too damn high.” When it comes to cigars, he only smokes bundle brands, and raves about how “that finger-burning goodness only cost me 87¢ a stick!”

You may be tempted to play right into his wheelhouse; don’t. Before you decide to buy cheap cigars at a mere 20 bucks a bunch, remember that there are plenty of bundle cigars for sale that actually offer an opportunity for your pal to step it up in the quality game.  Do El Cheapo a favor and gift a treat he may not ordinarily buy…especially bundles with well-respected brand names such as Perdomo Fresco, Rocky Patel Factory Selects, or even Gran Habano. Not only will you save a few bucks, but you can buy with confidence. Click on any of them to see more…



cigar showoff

Certainly, you’ve run into this guy: he drinks Starbucks coffee exclusively (everything else is crap), only wears shirts with the manufacturer’s company emblem on the pocket (everyone else’s is crap), plus he’s always washing his BMW crossover in the driveway; you know, the one with the college decal on the back windshield and a plethora of bumper stickers touting his awesomeness. The Showoff also leaves the band on his cigar as long as possible just to make sure everyone around him has seen it. But he’s still a friend, and he’s on your gift list.

Obviously, this type of person likes to advertise just about everything they use. Alrighty then…show the Showoff you can play his game, and score him something like a XiKAR Room 101 X11 Bling Tastic cutter, or the Perdomo Lotus cutter with the Perdomo Cigars logo on it.

A fancy humidor would certainly be in order. Since the Showoff wants – no, demands – that you know what cigars he smokes, the Countertop Display 150 Count Humidor has a top-to-bottom glass front, making it almost impossible to miss out on seeing his precious primos. Further up the scale, the Showoff would probably love to have the Padrón 1926 40th Anniversary Hand-carved Cedar Chest humidor. (Come to think of it, if you have the means, you might as well buy it for yourself – it’s a nice piece.) Click one to learn more:

If you want to go the cigars route, go with the big guns like Opus X, Davidoff, Montecristo, and Cohiba cigars (click one to learn more):


cigar fanatic

If this guy isn’t one of your friends, he’s probably a friend-of-a-friend. You know, that guy who is so pumped about his favorite team that his closet is full of T-shirts and hoodies with the logo on them. He’s got an alphabetized CD collection that could fill The Smithsonian, including his favorite bands in every recorded format – including 8-Tracks. His cigar collection is a fully-stocked 3,000 ct. cabinet humidor with the brands separated by manufacturer and country of origin, plus, he keeps all of his cigar bands in a big 3-ring binder…with notes.

Remember who we’re talking about here….this is the guy who made it his mission to have checked off all 360 craft beers on the local brew pub menu. Because he must get his hands on one of everything and try it, the Fanatic would love getting cigar samplers or cigar lighters. (Chances are he has a collection of them, too, including every Zippo lighter ever made.) The Vector Tri Pump Triple Flame cigar lighter would be right up his alley. Or, if you want to get him something similar for a lot less money, go for the Blazer Big Buddy Tabletop torch lighter.

As for cigar samplers, if he likes a particular brand, strength, or wrapper leaf, give him a “Best Of” cigar sampler. These packs include the best cigars from one or more of the aforementioned categories. Since the Fanatic is drawn towards large numbers of things, you may want to buy him a giant-sized sampler with anywhere from 15 to 40 cigars. Click any of these to buy them, or learn more:


A few years ago, when Cigar Advisor did a poll asking if cigar smokers were planning on giving cigars as gifts, the majority said “No.” I was taken aback by this response since I thought one of the tenets of BOTL’s was to share, and wouldn’t the Holiday season be the perfect time to thank those who’ve shared cigars with you during the year? I hope, since then, the majority has shrunk considerably and most of us will be paying it forward. If you plan on doing so, now you’ve got some ideas to play with.

Notify of
1 Comment
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
2018 CA Report: The Essential Cigar Advisor Guide to H. Upmann Cigars
1 year ago

[…] hand rolled cigars in Spanish cedar boxes. These were often given out to his banking clients as gifts and helped promote the […]

Gary Korb

Gary Korb

Executive Editor

Gary Korb has been writing and editing content for since its debut in 2008. An avid cigar smoker for over 30 years, he has worked on the marketing side of the premium cigar business as a Sr. Copywriter, blogger, and Executive Editor of Cigar Advisor. A graduate of the Newhouse School of Public Communications at Syracuse University, prior to his career in the cigar business, Gary worked in the music and video industry as a marketer and a publicist.

Show all Gary Korb's Articles
cigar advisor news – Trinidad Espiritu no.3 captures the spirit of mexico - release – cover

Cigar News: Trinidad Espiritu No.3 Captures The Spirit of Mexico

Reading Time: 2 minutes Aimed at being “a culmination of Trinidad Espiritu’s epic journey through years of diverse cigar cultures,” The Trinidad Espiritu No.3 now gives a nod to Mexico by using a specially-aged Mexican San Andrés wrapper. Get the full story here.

Read More
cigar advisor top new cigars 5-1-2023 - cover

Top New Cigars (May 1, 2023)

Reading Time: 3 minutes Fresh cigars have arrived at Famous, including Romeo y Julieta House of Nicaragua, the latest in their exclusive House series. Plus, we review even more new cigars from H. Upmann and A. Flores. See them now!

Read More
cigar advisor #nowsmoking cigar review don reynaldo regalos by warped - cover

#NowSmoking: Don Reynaldo Regalos by Warped

Reading Time: 3 minutes This review of the Don Reynaldo Regalos by Warped might be more appropriate for Father’s Day. The limited production cigar was created by Kyle Gellis as a tribute to his father who loved Cuban cigars. Read on to see if he hit the mark.

Read More
cigar advisor top new cigars july 11, 2022 - cover

CA Report: Top New Cigars (July 11, 2022)

Reading Time: 2 minutes Summer’s heating up and so is the new cigar release list! This week, we’re reviewing smokes from HVC, Chogui, and El Rey del Mundo (with an AJ Fernandez twist). Which one’s a match for your taste buds? Read now to find out!

Read More