Cigar Ratings & Reviews

How I Rated the Famous Private Selection Rocky Patel

Tonight, after dinner, I enjoyed the Famous 70th anniversary Private Selection Rocky Patel cigar. I am a big fan of Rocky Patel and frequently enjoy the Vintage 1992. I was excited to try this particular smoke because it is a new one to me. I went through the rating’s categories to give a final rating for this stick. Here is how I rated the cigar.

Before I lit the cigar I examined the look and feel of it. It was generally smooth with tiny veins from the wrapper. There was not any bumps or lumps, and did not have big chunk veins which most likely means it was rolled with a top quality leaf. The manufacturer probably took the time to remove the big veins from the leaf. The stick was kept in my humidor that had a humidity reading of 69% and 74 degrees Fahrenheit. The stick was spongy feeling and not at all hard.

After examining the cigar, I then cut and lit it. I used a guillotine cigar cutter to make a straight cut. It was very easy to cut. When I was lighting the stick, I used a butane torch lighter. I do admit that I coughed a few time while lighting it because the first few puffs were a bit strong. Most cigars seem strong at first when they are being lit. I did not assume the rest of the smoke would be as strong after it was initially lit.

I could tell the burn of the cigar was going to be good because it was easy to light. Indeed, I was right. The burn of this stick was very even and consistent. The draw was not tight at all. The ash stuck together which also backed up the evidence of a good burn.

The flavor of this cigar was strong. It was a stronger than what I usually smoke, but well nonetheless. The flavor of it lingered on the tip of my tongue and stayed on my lips. It was mildly spicy too. There were hints of leather and oak in the flavor. The aroma was pleasant and not overbearing. The character of the cigar changed as I smoked it. It was more robust in the beginning and became smoother later on. I also did not notice the taste of tar buildup as I got further down the stick.

I should also mention that I smoked this in the evening after I had eaten dinner. This could have affected how I rated the flavor and aroma of this one. I was drinking water and did not pair it with scotch, brandy, or wine. A lot of smokers pair their cigars with a good scotch.

I would give this cigar a final rating of 88 out of 100. It was an above average cigar that I thoroughly enjoyed.

John Pullo

John Pullo

Editor in Chief

This is not his picture, nor does he even have a beard. A solid 'B' student and occasional low-fi musician, John is a medley of cynicism and sarcasm crammed into a wrinkled Oxford shirt who makes it nearly intolerable to watch reality television with him in the same room. Interestingly, his Social Security number is all ones.

Show all John Pullo's Articles
How Much of a Cigar’s Flavor Comes from the Wrapper Cigar Advisor Cover

Cigar Q&A: How Much of a Cigar’s Flavor Comes from the Wrapper?

Even the blending experts don’t always agree on how much of a cigar’s flavor comes from the wrapper leaf – learn why, plus we pay forward a cool trick you can try to test your favorite cigar to see how much its flavor comes from the wrapper leaf.

Read More
cao signature cigar review video cacover

CA Review Panel: CAO Signature Series Cigar Review (Video)

Dressed in a dual ring, CAO Signature Series cigars are a full-flavored step up from their popular CAO Gold selection; they share one of the same bands, but the blends are miles apart. While the Gold Series has been a long time recommendation for new smokers, the Signature Series is more of a follow-up cigar.

Read More
top new cigars may 18 2018 CACover

CA Report: Top New Cigars – May 18 2018

You’ve already endured the sweaty days of mowing, power washing and weeding; so kick back, take a break and let us bring you the top new cigars this week: a soon-to-be-classic from Henry Clay, a rare Romeo, a C&A boutique gem, and a festive limited edition from our friends at CAO. Add these picks to your humidor now!
Read More
CACover XIKAR PRODUCT REVIEW PuroTemp Digital Gauge Hygrometer HumiFan Air Circulator

Cigar Advisor Review: PuroTemp Hygrometer & HumiFan Xikar Product Review

Known for their patented Xi cigar cutters, Xikar has more humidor tools to help keep your cigars fresh n' ready to smoke: read our Xikar product review of their Xikar PuroTemp™ Digital Gauge Hygrometer and Xikar HumiFan™ Humidor Air Circulator - and see if they stand up to the Cigar Advisor test!
Read More