Cigars 101

How to Ash Your Cigar

It’s inevitable. You’re relaxing, enjoying the flavor and aroma of your cigar and suddenly the time comes to “ash” your cigar; in other words, tap the ash off into the ashtray. It’s possibly the most effortless thing you have to do with a cigar besides puffing. There’s no right or wrong way to ash your cigars, so let’s digress and look at the ash itself.

Cigar ashes vary in color, texture and firmness. The colors can range from a variety of light to dark grays, to a gray with black lines, to more of a marble-like pattern to almost black. The color of the ash is generally determined by the minerals in the soil in which the leaves were grown.

Ash texture can range from silky smooth, to a series of slim ringlets, to toothy, to very rough and jagged.

A firm ash is preferable to a flaky one. It will also burn longer before having to tap it off. (How many times have you let the ash go only to find it in your lap a few seconds later?) A flaky ash will sprinkle flecks on your clothes as you smoke, and if it’s windy, it will blow off before you even have a chance to tap it.

The sign of an “ideal” ash is, when you tap it into the ashtray what remains is a “cherry” (ball-like) or a cone-shaped ash (bullet-like). That means the cigar is burning well. A lot of times the ash breaks off more squarely. In that case, if you’ve still got about a quarter-of-an-inch or more of ash left, you can “roll” the ash along the inside of the ashtray to form a more cone-like ash. This can be done with longer ashes, too. Simply place the ash-end of the cigar anywhere the base and the wall of the ashtray meet, and gently turn it, rounding-out the sharp and flakier edge of the ash.

How do you know when to ash? It should be obvious, but let’s say about every ½ to ¾ of an inch or so depending on its firmness. If it’s really firm, about every inch. When you’re ready to ash your cigar, test the ash by very gently touching it against the side of the ashtray wall. If it has a decent amount of resistance, you can probably go a little longer. Some cigars will burn three, four, and even five-inch long ashes before they’re tapped or fall off under their own weight. If it’s soft, it will begin to break up once it makes contact, in which case it’s simply tap-tap and let gravity do the rest.

Leave a Reply

Gary Korb

Gary Korb

Executive Editor

Gary Korb has been writing and editing content for since its debut in 2008. An avid cigar smoker for over 30 years, during the past 12 years he has worked on the marketing side of the premium cigar business as a Sr. Copywriter, blogger, and cigar reviewer. A graduate of the Newhouse School of Public Communications at Syracuse University, prior to his career in the cigar business, Gary worked in the music and video industry as a marketer and a publicist.

Show all Gary Korb's Articles

#nowsmoking: Warped Edition One Cloud Hopper No. 485

We’re #nowsmoking the boutique stuff: join us for a video tasting of a Warped cigar with generous flavor, as our Edition One Cloud Hopper cigar review reveals some scrumptious tasting notes. Is this your next smoke? Click to get the details…

Read More
fan mail cigar questions answered part 26 cacover

Fan Mail: Your Burning Cigar Questions, Answered (Part 26)

More Fan Mail: with more readers’ cigar questions coming in, the Cigar Advisors lighten the load and answer their top 4 burning questions with a trick for cutting cigars, what your cigar’s ash color means, keeping your cigar lit and premium vs. machine made. Watch our videos now!

Read More
Gary's White Christmas cigars for the Holidays Cigar Advisor cover

2018 CA Report: 12 Dream Cigars for the Holidays

Gary Korb takes one more look at the Holidays with his list of top shelf cigars adorned with fancy white & gold bands. Whether it’s a last minute gift idea or a humidor-worthy primo to ring-in the New Year, you’ll find 12 of them all dressed-up and ready to smoke.

Read More
Top Aromatic Cigars

2015 CA Report: Top 11 Most Aromatic Cigars

Aroma plays an important role in enjoying cigars; now read our list of aromatic cigars that you’ll enjoy as much for their scent, as you do for their taste.
Read More