Cigars 101

How to Ash Your Cigar

It’s inevitable. You’re relaxing, enjoying the flavor and aroma of your cigar and suddenly the time comes to “ash” your cigar; in other words, tap the ash off into the ashtray. It’s possibly the most effortless thing you have to do with a cigar besides puffing. There’s no right or wrong way to ash your cigars, so let’s digress and look at the ash itself.

Cigar ashes vary in color, texture and firmness. The colors can range from a variety of light to dark grays, to a gray with black lines, to more of a marble-like pattern to almost black. The color of the ash is generally determined by the minerals in the soil in which the leaves were grown.

Ash texture can range from silky smooth, to a series of slim ringlets, to toothy, to very rough and jagged.

A firm ash is preferable to a flaky one. It will also burn longer before having to tap it off. (How many times have you let the ash go only to find it in your lap a few seconds later?) A flaky ash will sprinkle flecks on your clothes as you smoke, and if it’s windy, it will blow off before you even have a chance to tap it.

The sign of an “ideal” ash is, when you tap it into the ashtray what remains is a “cherry” (ball-like) or a cone-shaped ash (bullet-like). That means the cigar is burning well. A lot of times the ash breaks off more squarely. In that case, if you’ve still got about a quarter-of-an-inch or more of ash left, you can “roll” the ash along the inside of the ashtray to form a more cone-like ash. This can be done with longer ashes, too. Simply place the ash-end of the cigar anywhere the base and the wall of the ashtray meet, and gently turn it, rounding-out the sharp and flakier edge of the ash.

How do you know when to ash? It should be obvious, but let’s say about every ½ to ¾ of an inch or so depending on its firmness. If it’s really firm, about every inch. When you’re ready to ash your cigar, test the ash by very gently touching it against the side of the ashtray wall. If it has a decent amount of resistance, you can probably go a little longer. Some cigars will burn three, four, and even five-inch long ashes before they’re tapped or fall off under their own weight. If it’s soft, it will begin to break up once it makes contact, in which case it’s simply tap-tap and let gravity do the rest.

Gary Korb

Gary Korb

Executive Editor

Gary Korb has been writing and editing content for since its debut in 2008. An avid cigar smoker for over 30 years, during the past 12 years he has worked on the marketing side of the premium cigar business as a Sr. Copywriter, blogger, and cigar reviewer. A graduate of the Newhouse School of Public Communications at Syracuse University, prior to his career in the cigar business, Gary worked in the music and video industry as a marketer and a publicist.

Show all Gary Korb's Articles
nowsmoking H Upmann Connecticut Toro cigar review Cigar Advisor Cover

#nowsmoking: H. Upmann Connecticut Toro

The H. Upmann Connecticut is “smooth, smooth, smooth…” – it’s also a contender to be one of the best Connecticut cigars we’ve smoked all year. Want more? See what else you need to know about this cigar, when you click & read our super-fast H. Upmann Connecticut cigar review now…

Read More
5 things about pa broadleaf tobacco cacover

5 Things You Need To Know About… Pennsylvania Broadleaf Tobacco

Cheesesteaks, Yuengling (pronounced ying-ling), and potholes the size of moon craters are as Pennsylvanian as it gets – but what about the tobacco? We spent a day at the Drew Estate PA Barn Smoker which, as a life-long Pennsylvanian, led me down the rabbit-hole of what goes into growing and using this heavy tobacco in cigars – and why some say it’s making a comeback.

Read More
Nick Melillo foundation cigars interview podcast CACover

Master Blenders: Nick Melillo, Founder of Foundation Cigars

Nick Melillo is the founder of Foundation Cigar Company, and the man responsible for such highly-rated cigars as El Gueguense, Tabernacle, Charter Oak, and Highclere Castle, Nick (a.k.a. "Nick R. Agua") has accomplished in 15 years what takes some blenders to do in a lifetime. How'd he do it? Tune in and listen!
Read More

What are Cigar Tubes REALLY Used For?

Cigar tubes: why are they used, and how fresh do they keep your cigars? Click now to find out - and what to do with them after you smoke the cigars inside!
Read More