Cigar Ratings & Reviews

How to Rate Cigars

There is more to a cigar than just smoking it. The making of the cigar itself is an art form in its own right. Smoking a cigar involves all of your senses, and most important including taste. All cigars have their individual tastes, smells, and textures. There are some that you will hate, others that you can tolerate, and some that will become your favorite. You can tell which ones you like by rating them. Rating a cigar lets you explore the many aspects of it such as taste, burn, tobacco, and other things. You should rate everyone you smoke because even the same type of cigar can taste different because external factors can affect how you feel about it. Here is how you rate cigars.
There are different factors you should record when smoking a particular stick. The taste can depend on external factors such as what you are drinking, what you are eating, or the last time you had something to eat. There are certain types of alcohols that accompany them. It is not unusual for cigar shops or lounges to have alcohol and cigar tastings together.

How To Rate Cigars -2After you have recorded anything you are eating or drinking at the time, you can move on to the next step of rating a stick. It is important to look at the cigar and examine the leaf and wrapping. How does it look to you? Are there any tears in the wrapper? Is the color light or dark? Does the stick appear to be smooth, have ridges, or veins from the leaf? Keep note of the appearance of the cigar.

After you look at the cigar, take time to smell it. The scent of the cigar will often hint at the flavor it has. Some sticks may be too potent or stout for you. Smoking them and enjoying a certain type is such a personal preference. Usually you will be able to tell if it is going to be spicy, bitter, or bland.

How To Rate Cigars -1After examining the cigar you are going to rate, now the best part comes in and you smoke it. Smoking cigars will affirm what you have examined or smelled about them. There are certain things that you can record about smoking the stick to help you rate it. What is the burn like? The cigar should stay lit easily and have a good draw. The burn of the stick should also be consistent. When you are smoking pay attention to the burn, draw, smoke, ash, and flavor. Does the smoke sting your mouth or is it smooth? Can you ash the cigar easily and does it stick together when doing so?

Rating a cigar can be based on a scale you make or on a 100 point scale. If you are rating on a point scale, give each category a 1-10 rating and then add up the points. Maybe you like to rate them on a more flexible scale of your own. Smoking them is a personal enjoyment, and so should be rating them. So spark up an Oliva cigar and give it a rating!

Leave a Reply

avatar
John Pullo

John Pullo

Editor in Chief

This is not his picture, nor does he even have a beard. A solid 'B' student and occasional low-fi musician, John is a medley of cynicism and sarcasm crammed into a wrinkled Oxford shirt who makes it nearly intolerable to watch reality television with him in the same room. Interestingly, his Social Security number is all ones.

Show all John Pullo's Articles
How to Use a Wineador NewAir CC-300H Wineador Review Cigar Advisor Cover

Cigar Advisor Review: NewAir CC-300H Wineador + How to Use a Wineador

Is your cigar stash growing? Learn how to use a wineador to store your cigars – and see our review of the NewAir CC-300H wineador, as this maybe your next storage solution. BONUS Promo code inside!

Read More
nowsmoking 300 manos 300 hands habano cigar review Cigar Advisor Cover

#nowsmoking: Southern Draw 300 Manos Habano Petite Edmundo

#nowsmoking the Southern Draw 300 Manos Habano, “the poster child for ultra-creamy cigars with a woody, full-flavored profile.” Click now to get our tasting notes, and everything else you need to know about this cigar in under 60 seconds…

Read More
aj fernandez new world puro especial cigar review cacover

Cigar Review: New World Puro Especial By AJ Fernandez

Join us for a deep dive on New World Puro Especial cigars by AJ Fernandez: get the specs, tasting notes and everything else you need to know about the blend that was chosen #12 cigar of 2017 – see it now!

Read More
Butane or Lighter Fluid

How to light a cigar with butane and lighter fluid

For lighting a cigar, it mainly comes down to using a lighter that fires on butane gas or lighter fluid. Learn how to light a cigar today by reading more.
Read More