Cigar Buying Guides

How to Shop Smart for Cigars

Reading Time: 3 minutes

An educated consumer is our best customer.” That’s the motto for SYMS, the nationwide clothing store chain. Fortunately, the internet allows consumers to price check at warp speed, making that motto even more relevant for just about everything we buy, and that includes premium cigars.

So how do you find the best buys in premium cigars? Surely there’s no lack of online discount cigar websites. And although the most popular online cigar stores have a pretty loyal following, the majority of cigar smokers seem to go wherever they can find the lowest price for their favorite cigars. (“Sorry I cheated on you baby, but I still love you more than anyone else.”)

With regard to the big guns like Famous Smoke Shop, et. al., the difference in price can be as little as $1. I actually had a customer who would buy Partagas at a competitor’s site because they were a buck cheaper. However, on my suggestion he would try new cigars, sometimes more expensive, but more often less expensive than his beloved Partagas. So trust, though primarily a loyalty factor, also plays a role when it comes to good buys; that is, as long as the person making the suggestion is trying to save you some cash.

Trust ties into one of the most important factors when shopping for cigars online or off – customer service – which begs the question: Would you rather buy from an unknown entity just to save a couple of bucks, or buy from a company who’s going to help you out of a jam when you really need it?

Unless they phone-in their cigar orders, most online customers don’t usually have to deal with customer service until there’s a problem. So, Rule #1 is: Try to find an online cigar store that not only has fair prices, but also provides excellent customer service.

Now let’s take a look at some of the ways you can actually find good quality cigars online and keep your budget in the black.

Look for less expensive alternatives to your current favorites. Experimentation is part of the fun of smoking premium cigars. By trying something comparable to cigars you already enjoy, you may discover some cigars you like just as much or even more. Famous Smoke Shop has a Value Priced Alternatives page on the site featuring exclusive cigar brands. The upside is most of them are made by the premier manufacturers, too. Alternatives don’t have to be “house brands,” but beware of online cigar stores that compare apples-to-apples.

Start with a 5-Pack. This is especially important when trying new or alternative cigars. There’s no point in shooting your load on an entire box (or bundle) of an unknown entity. This is especially important when buying house brands.

Another good reason for buying 5-packs is, when you want to have some pricier cigars in your collection, but the box price is cost-prohibitive. Even if the pack equates to $10 a cigar, it’s better than spending roughly $200 for 20.

When it comes to 5-packs, Famous offers a couple of choices: A page where you can buy 5 cigars for the price of 3, and 5-Pack Frenzy, where for every four 5-packs you buy, one is free.

Read the copy. The better online cigar stores have descriptions for the cigars they stock. Read it carefully so you know what you’re getting. Do the cigars have the right strength, wrappers, flavor properties, etc. you’re looking for? Does the item come with free shipping or other offers? Missing details can be the difference between a return customer and one who will flame a store on the boards for not being on the up-and-up.

Look for deals & offers. As noted above, you can get a lot of bang for your buck if you find cigars that come with free shipping, free cigars, accessories, or deeply-discounted promotions. Even if the box is being sold at full weight, a free 5-pack or sampler goes a long way. Famous also has two pages on the site specifically dedicated to such offers: A page on which all the brands come with free shipping on box orders, and a page on which all of the brands include “Free Stuff.”

Name brand hits and collections. If you’re a strict name brand buyer, Famous has a Best Of page offering samplers from practically every major cigar brand in the industry at reasonable prices. It’s a great way to discover the line extensions most brands have to offer, again, without committing to a box.

So, what if you’ve already found some great new cigars in a particular size, but you’re curious about how the other sizes taste? There is a difference, and a solution! It’s called a “Test Flight” – a sampler of one specific brand containing all (or mostly all) of the sizes & shapes in that edition, usually at a nice price point.

Experienced cigar smokers have figured out all kinds of ways to get good deals. It just comes with the territory over time; sort of like how a hitter trains himself to discern between a curve ball and a slider. Unless you have unlimited cash supplies and price is no object, hopefully some of the above will help you keep a little more money in your wallet.

Notify of
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Mike K.
12 years ago

I concur with the 5-pack suggestion and the 5-for-3 deals. These are also great ways to stock a humidor with your favorite smokes when the cost of a box is too high or a box of 20 or more may be too much for you at one time. I like different cigars and 5-packs have been the best way for me. One time, was going to order a 5-pack of Perdomo Lot 23 Natural robustos, then I saw that the same cigar in the toro size was the same price, so I got them! Just take time to look and see if there is a 5-pack of one size that is the same price as the same 5-pack that is the same brand, wrapper, etc, but is the same price as the smaller size cigar.

Kevin Michaels
12 years ago

You will never know the consistency of a brand unless you buy a full box, try a box of 10 or 12 to start and go from there, 5 packs are OK for taste test and that’s about it.

Kevin Michaels Cigars

John Pullo

John Pullo

Editor in Chief

This is not his picture, nor does he even have a beard. A solid 'B' student and occasional low-fi musician, John is a medley of cynicism and sarcasm crammed into a wrinkled Oxford shirt who makes it nearly intolerable to watch reality television with him in the same room. Interestingly, his Social Security number is all ones.

Show all John Pullo's Articles
cigar advisor #nowsmoking cigar review montecristo 1935 anniversary edicion diamante - cover

NowSmoking: Montecristo 1935 Anniversary Edición Diamante

Reading Time: 3 minutes For this review, Gary has a rendezvous with the Montecristo 1935 Anniversary Edición Diamante Robusto. Touted as “a diamond nurtured with time and honed to perfection,” watch now and see what makes this luxury class cigar tick.

Read More
cigar advisor top new cigars february 6, 2023 - cover

Top New Cigars (February 6, 2023)

Reading Time: 3 minutes With spring just around the corner, it’s time to get back into the mindset of smoking outside. What better way to pique your taste buds’ interest than with some new cigar blood? Check out fresh reviews from Macanudo, Foundation, and Warped inside!

Read More
cigar advisor #nowsmoking cigar review dissident bloc - cover

#NowSmoking: Dissident Bloc Robusto

Reading Time: 4 minutes This week we’re reviewing Dissident Bloc Robusto—a boutique blend that’s flown under-the-radar for too long. Watch the review to see if it’s worth a try!

Read More

CA Report: Top New Cigars (Aug 17 2020)

Reading Time: 2 minutes Check out this edition of Top New Cigars that features Henry Clay’s latest release, and Joya’s new and fun approach for a limited edition Antaño 1970!

Read More