Food & Drink

How to Make a Bloody Mary + Cigar Pairing Recommendation

How to Make a Bloody Mary – Plus Recommended Cigar Pairing

By John Pullo

Want to learn how to make the best Bloody Mary without a Bloody Mary mix (aka, “cheating”)? Ours is a mouth-watering treat…and so is the cigar we’re matching it with: Sucker Punch, by Punch Cigars.

Whether you overdid it at last night’s Christmas party, or you just want a different kind of drink to enjoy with your cigar – we’re looking at a time-honored drink that will help dull any pain: the Bloody Mary. And for today’s sweet bonus, we’re going to give you the secrets to our award-winning Bloody Mary recipe.

Based on the number of questions that we receive about what to drink while smoking cigars, and how we’ve covered the basics in our drink and cigar pairing guides – the time seemed right for this quick primer on how to make the perfect Bloody Mary. So today, we have the how-to, along with the Bloody Mary drink ingredients to make ‘em the way we do at Leaf Cigar Bar and Restaurant, right next door here at Famous Smoke Shop headquarters in Easton, PA. With a few extra twists from our in-house pros, this ultimate Bloody Mary will be sure to satisfy – especially once we show you our handpicked cigar recommendation to go with it.

History of the Bloody Mary Drink

If you’re going to go all-in with the perfect Bloody Mary, it’s important to learn a little bit about this drink first (besides the fact that it’s a flavor bomb). History is a little unclear on the Bloody Mary’s true origin, but the experts have narrowed it down to (a) that it’s named for Mary Tudor, royal murderer of Protestants and daughter of King Henry VIII, or (b) Fernand Petiot. Fernand mixed equal parts of tomato juice and vodka while tending bar at Harry’s New York in Paris, and served it to a guy who said it reminded him of a girl named Mary at Chicago’s Bucket of Blood Club. Petiot’s original Bloody Mary recipe eventually got an overhaul in NYC, when lemon juice and all the spicy stuff (cayenne pepper, black pepper, Worcestershire sauce and Tabasco) were added.

For the drink we serve at Leaf, our Bloody Mary ingredients list is even more involved; so we’ve again turned to our master mixer Chad, and asked him to show you how it’s done. If you want to learn how to make a Bloody Mary his way, here’s your shopping list:

Leaf’s Best Bloody Mary Drink Ingredients:

  • 2 Teaspoons of dill pickle juice
  • 1 Dash of salt and pepper (to taste)
  • 1 Teaspoon of Worcestershire Sauce
  • 1 Heaping teaspoon of horseradish
  • 1 Teaspoon of Sriracha sauce
  • ½ Lemon squeezed
  • ½ Lime Squeezed
  • 4 Ounces of V8 Original juice
  • 1 ¼ Ounces of Tito’s Handmade Vodka
  • 1 Scoop of Ice
  • Garnish with celery, tomatoes, olives, cheddar cheese, and a slice of bacon

Watch how it’s made:

How to make a Bloody Mary, as above: add all of the ingredients, in the order they’re listed, to a pint glass. And because you’re not just eyeballing the vodka, this is a great opportunity to learn how to properly use that drink jigger that’s been taking up space in your kitchen drawer. Once you’ve added the ice, cover with a shaker and mix vigorously – then pour back into the glass.

Now, garnish with whatever you feel makes it right…to do ours, Chad hits up three of the 5 major food groups: meat (bacon), dairy (cheddar cheese) and vegetables (celery, tomatoes, et al).


Bloody Mary Cigar Pairing: Punch Sucker Punch

When you’re learning how to make a Bloody Mary, you know you’ve hit it right when the finished product hits all the taste buds with a complex set of tastes throughout. It’s also important to point out that vodka is not a very common drink with which to pair cigars; but once that Bloody Mary is fixed with all the trimmings, it ends up being an exceptionally smooth cocktail that’s big on the palate, consistent from beginning to end, and finishes with a kick. That’s the same MO as the Sucker Punch: a smooth-smoking Ecuador Connecticut wrapper and a Cameroon binder contribute a creaminess to the smoke. And thanks to a good helping of Nicaraguan Ligero at its core, you’ll certainly feel the pepper and spice punch through and linger for a bit. That’s why these two make such a great cocktail and cigar pairing.

How to Make a Bloody Mary Drink cigar pairing Punch cigars BIN

How It Smokes

Sucker Punch isn’t your Grandpappy’s Punch: whereas Punch cigars “live up to their name,” this version starts out medium bodied and more mild-mannered – at least until it starts dishing out Nicaraguan spice with each puff, when the Ligero kicks in.

The smoke is nice and thick, with hints of earth and sweetness to accompany the developing flavors and intensity. Sucker Punch finishes full, but don’t worry – it’s not a total knock-you-off-your-feet powerhouse…think of it more as a brushback fastball. And by all accounts from our customers’ reviews, it’s a deliciously consistent smoke from start to finish.

Tasting Notes: leather, cocoa, sweet wood.


Smooth, satisfying and full of flavor: now that you know how to make a Bloody Mary like a pro, pair it up with this great pick from Punch – and let us know if it worked as well for you, as it did for us. Merry Christmas – and cheers!

John Pullo

John Pullo

Editor in Chief

This is not his picture, nor does John even have a beard. Interestingly, his Social Security number is all ones. All we can say is " "You will know him by the mullet he wears." "

Show all John Pullo's Articles
5 things about maduro cigars cacover

5 Things You Need To Know About… Maduro Cigars

Maduro-nados: Besides the fact that you love this sweet, dark leaf, what else do you know about this delicious cigar choice? Go deep in the weeds with us as we dig out 5 fun facts about this fetching, extra-fermented tobacco, and why it’s such a fan favorite.

Read More

CA Happy Hour: Goose Island 312 + Plasencia Reserva Original Cigar Pairing

This Happy Hour calls for a cold one: Goose Island 312 Urban Wheat Ale is combined with Plasencia Reserva Original for a beer and cigar pairing that's on your side of the battle against the summer heat. Click now to get the tasting notes and try it today!
Read More
aging room small batch quattro f55M cigar review CA Cover

My Weekend Cigar: Mar. 12, 2018 – Aging Room Small Batch Quattro F55M Vibrato

Looking for a cigar that goes great after dinner, or pretty much after anything? It's the Aging Room Small Batch Quattro F55M, and it's My Weekend Cigar. If you love cigars rolled in top-grade San Andrés maduro wrapper, this cigar delivers - see what else I have to say about My Weekend Cigar, in this short review!
Read More
cigar questions and answers part 10

More Cigar Questions: Answered (Pt. X)

Make smoking cigars a learning experience: the Advisors answer 4 more of the most often-asked cigar questions from their readers. Watch now! 
Read More