Food & Drink

How to Make a Havana Cocktail + Cigar Pairing Recommendation

How to Make a Havana Cocktail – Plus Recommended Cigar Pairing

By John Pullo

Your cigar horoscope: we see a hot Summer day. Feet up. A mellow cigar. An icy Cuban cocktail.

If those are signs of times to come, things are definitely looking up.

While a trip to Cuba remains high on so many cigar lovers’ to-do lists, there are still so many hoops to jump through to enjoy a Havana drink in its namesake city…that’s why we’re bringing this Leaf Cigar Bar version of how to make a Havana to you – along with a smooth n’ easy-smoking Drew Estate blend to help you wash it all down. We’re also going to explore a little about the secret boutique ingredient that gives this Havana drink some extra oomph, and talk a bit about why it’s damn near impossible to get your hands on a sizeable stash of Havana Club rum.

This Havana Club recipe is a bit off the beaten path here…for one thing, we can’t use Havana Club rum. Yes, you can bring a few bottles back from your cruise stop in Cuba, but for us to be serving this OG Cuban rum is still verboten. The other thing that’s a bit different in this Havana cocktail is the vanilla vodka, making our version of this Havana Club cocktail more of a Moscow Mule-meets-Mojito – but still satisfies as a refreshing summer drink with both a Caribbean flair and a piratey edge.

About Havana Club Rum

Jose Arechabala S.A. created Havana Club rum in 1934, and this lush Cuban liquor flowed freely until the company was “nationalized” by Castro in 1960. Just like their Cuban cigar making counterparts, the Arechabala family fled the regime – and passed their rum recipe to Bacardi, who began producing their version of Havana Club in Puerto Rico in 1994. But the original Havana Club rum is one for the bucket list: a 7-year aged (añejo) Cuban rum, it’s known for having a rich and sophisticated flavor.

About Faber Vanilla Vodka

What sets this version of the Havana cocktail apart is the Faber Vanilla Vodka, a concoction distilled in nearby Bucks County, PA. We figured since we already went off the reservation with our Havana recipe, this was the perfect time to incorporate a local spirit renowned for its easy-drinking qualities: The vanilla infusion is pretty rich, and the taste offers a touch of cream soda. It’s also lightly gently sweetened with genuine cane sugar, so the finish is clean – meaning it doesn’t leave a syrupy aftertaste on the taste buds like some other infused liquors might.

Let’s try it…

Leaf’s EXCLUSIVE Havana Cocktail Recipe:

  • 2 lime quarters (squeezed)
  • 5 mint leaves
  • ¾ ounce of Captain Morgan Spiced Rum
  • ¾ ounce of Faber Vanilla Vodka
  • 1 scoop of ice
  • 3-4 ounces of ginger beer
  • Garnish with lime wedge and mint leaves

Here’s how Chad pulls it all together behind the bar:

How to make a Havana Club drink…start by squeezing in the lime quarters, then press the mint leaves and drop them in the glass. Add the Faber Vanilla Vodka, then the rum. Scoop in a generous helping of ice, then top the glass up with the ginger beer for a refreshing island sensation.

Havana Cocktail Cigar Pairing: Olde Penn by Drew Estate

If you’re going to learn how to make a Havana – a nice, slow-sipping drink – it helps to have match it with a nice, slow-smoking cigar. Olde Penn cigars by Drew Estate are a tribute of sorts to Pennsylvania’s long tobacco history. PA-grown crops helped to pay our young nation’s war debts, and at the height of the Golden Era of cigars – around the turn of the 20th century – there were approximately 4,600 cigar factories…that’s more than any other state in the Union, and went a long way in satisfying America’s appetite for a good smoke. Olde Penn’s flavors check in around the medium body mark, but it’s very easy-going – mellow-plus in strength, it’s very palatable to new cigar smokers as well.

buy drew estate Olde Penn nicaraguan cigars how to make a havana cocktailFlavors: leather, cedar, toasted nuts, light pepper.

How it Smokes

For Olde Penn, Drew Estate incorporates Nicaraguan long fillers rolled in silky-smooth Ecuadorian Connecticut wrappers. The wrapper choice helps these smoke with a little more gusto than your typical Connecticut Shade, and a little more creamy – which goes well with the sweetness from the vanilla. The Nicaraguan core makes for those leathery, aged wood sensations that go nicely with darker rums and the ginger beer; the occasional twinge of pepper running quietly beneath the surface is a treat, too.


So if you’re getting ready for smoking season, and you’re looking for a smoke-and-drink combo to call your own this summer – give this mellow-smoking Connecticut from Drew Estate a try, along taking a shot at Leaf’s way of how to make a Havana cocktail recipe…your taste buds will be rewarded. Cheers!

John Pullo

John Pullo

Editor in Chief

This is not his picture, nor does he even have a beard. A solid 'B' student and occasional low-fi musician, John is a medley of cynicism and sarcasm crammed into a wrinkled Oxford shirt who makes it nearly intolerable to watch reality television with him in the same room. Interestingly, his Social Security number is all ones.

Show all John Pullo's Articles
How Much of a Cigar’s Flavor Comes from the Wrapper Cigar Advisor Cover

Cigar Q&A: How Much of a Cigar’s Flavor Comes from the Wrapper?

Even the blending experts don’t always agree on how much of a cigar’s flavor comes from the wrapper leaf – learn why, plus we pay forward a cool trick you can try to test your favorite cigar to see how much its flavor comes from the wrapper leaf.

Read More
5 things about cigars and beer CACover

5 Things You Need to Know About… Cigars and Beer

Other than their fantastic taste, cigars and beer have a lot in common. We go to Free Will Brewery to get the dish on what our hoppy friends have in common with cigars - turns out that cigars, tobacco and hoppy beers can endure similar growing, production, flavors, and aging processes. Read all about it here!
Read More
h. upmann cigars guide h upmann cigar reviews 2018 CACover

2018 CA Report: The Essential Cigar Advisor Guide to H. Upmann Cigars

If you’ve passed on H. Upmann cigars, the Cigar Advisors have 9 reasons why this great Cuban heritage brand deserves a spot in your humidor – get the full smoking experience with our NC H. Upmann cigar reviews inside!

Read More
9 Luxury Cigars That Are Worth It

2015 CA Report: 9 Expensive Cigars That Are Worth It

The most highly rated cigars are often expensive cigars; see our list of “treat” smokes that don't come cheap, but are absolutely worth every penny.
Read More