Cigar Ratings & Reviews

My First Great Cigar

My quest for cigar knowledge began with my first two cigars. One was very good (a Cuban I was told), and the other very bad (also supposedly a Cuban). This led me to wonder what makes one cigar better than another. As a layperson, I always believed a Cuban cigar was the best, so then how could I have smoked a “bad Cuban?” It didn’t take long to find an abundance of internet articles about counterfeit Cuban cigars, and this really spurred my curiosity. With Cuban cigars as a starting point I was led through the world of growing, blending, rolling, and selling not only Cuban cigars and tobacco, but cigars from all over the world. Reading all this material was exhilarating, intimidating, and endlessly fascinating.  I was determined to find out what made a cigar great.

It wasn’t until I smoked my first great cigar that I was able to begin finding some answers. I had been reading about Tatuaje cigars and how Pete Johnson and Don Pepin Garcia had set out to recreate a Non-Cuban (NC) cigar that captured the best elements of a great Cuban cigar (CC).  I jumped at the chance to smoke a cigar that was, by all consensus, considered to be truly great. Living in Los Angeles gave me access to many high-end cigar retailers and a local cigar store full of Tatuaje vitolas. I bought three Cojonu 2003 cigars and, as I had read, let them sit a few days in my 70/70 humidor (I was doing everything by the virtual book). When the much-anticipated time came, I sat back, lit the cigar, and had an experience that was nothing short of an epiphany…now THIS is what a good cigar is supposed to taste like! The aroma and flavor was divine.  The first flavor that hit me was pepper and I remember stating out loud how spicy it was.  Then the complexity came through like a symphony of flavors that were almost visible.  It was at that moment that I was determined to smoke every good cigar that I could get my hands on. But the question still remained, what makes one cigar better than another?  Not content to rely on the opinions of others, I have since been on a quest for my own answers by gaining knowledge first hand. This was the birth of the Empirical Cigar Smoker.

*   *   *

 This article has been reposted by permission of the author. Copyright © 2011 | Robustojoe: Online Cigar Magazine. All rights reserved.

Gary Korb

Gary Korb

Executive Editor

Gary Korb has been writing and editing content for CigarAdvisor.com since its debut in 2008. An avid cigar smoker for over 30 years, during the past 12 years he has worked on the marketing side of the premium cigar business as a Sr. Copywriter, blogger, and cigar reviewer. A graduate of the Newhouse School of Public Communications at Syracuse University, prior to his career in the cigar business, Gary worked in the music and video industry as a marketer and a publicist.

Show all Gary Korb's Articles
master blenders klaas kelner davidoff cigars interview cacover

CA Master Blenders Video Podcast: Klaas Pieter Kelner, Davidoff Brand Ambassador

His father is one of the cigar industry’s legendary master blenders; Avo was his adopted uncle, he knows the cigar business inside and out. He’s also just a really nice guy: Klaas Pieter Kelner, Davidoff Cigars Brand Ambassador, who talks with us about growing up at the heart of the business, the appreciation of a fine cigar, and more

Read More
archetype axis mundi cigar review MWC CACover

My Weekend Cigar: Mar. 19, 2018 – Archetype Axis Mundi Toro

Heaven meets Earth in this stellar cigar - and it found its way to #13 on 2017's Top 25 cigars list. It's the Archetype Axis Mundi, made at the Drew Estate factory in Nicaragua for Ventura Cigars, and it's My Weekend Cigar that went GREAT with a cup of coffee. Get my tasting notes and more in this short cigar review!
Read More
5 things about cigars and beer CACover

5 Things You Need to Know About… Cigars and Beer

Other than their fantastic taste, cigars and beer have a lot in common. We go to Free Will Brewery to get the dish on what our hoppy friends have in common with cigars - turns out that cigars, tobacco and hoppy beers can endure similar growing, production, flavors, and aging processes. Read all about it here!
Read More
Operation Cigars For Warriors Survey cacover

Operation Cigars For Warriors Survey

We have a brief cigars for warriors survey for members of the military to comment We donate more the 50,000 cigars annually to benefit military personnel.
Read More