Cigar Ratings & Reviews

My Weekend Cigar: Private Selection 70th Anniversary by Rocky Patel Robusto

It all started at about 4:00 P.M. on Thursday, Dec. 31. One of my coworkers had just picked up a box of Private Selection 70th Anniversary by Rocky Patel Robusto and was kind enough to hand me not one, but two! Interestingly enough, this is one of the few 70th Anniversary cigars I had not smoked in its final version. That was reason enough to go for it.

Now I know there’s always the risk of sounding like a shill when I review a private blend cigar, but damn if this wasn’t one of the best cigars I smoked all year, and you can think whatever you like. (If I had smoked it sooner I probably would have mentioned it in Our Most Impressive Cigars of 2009 article.)

Rocky’s cigars seem to improve year after year, and it looks like there’s no ceiling in sight. This limited edition 70th Anniversary selection offers an extra-long-aged longfiller blend of various Nicaraguan tobaccos, a Honduran binder and a gorgeous Ecuadorian-grown Cuban seed wrapper leaf that adds a lot of flavor to this full-bodied blend. If that sounds a bit cryptic, blame Rocky; I think he wanted to keep the 70th by Rocky Patel cigars blend in his designer suit pocket. Moreover, just today read the following applicable quote by Rocky in a recent online cigar review: “I don’t make a blend and give it to 10 people – I trust my palate and I know what I’m looking for.” (Why am I not surprised?)

From the first puff this cigar was right in my wheelhouse. The smoke was intensely aromatic and flavorful; rife with earthiness, sweet spices (nutmeg, for sure) all underscored by a rich woodiness. Each puff was amazingly creamy, easy, and every bit as flavorful as the one before. The ash was very firm with a clean burn, too. I paired it with a glass of Tawny Port, which made a great match, as well.

I let the cigar rest between puffs. There was no way I wanted it to get tarry or bitter and it paid-off. Even by the last third the cigar remained smooth and creamy and glowing with caramelized flavors. If you like complex flavor, there’s plenty here for you. I’ll stop there, only to add that I hope your first cigar of the New Year was as enjoyable as was mine. Now I can’t wait to try the other one.

Scores:
Appearance – 9
Construction – 9
Draw – 9
Burn – 9
Aroma – 9
Flavor – 9
Balance – 9
Total Score: 9.0

Feel free to chime in on your New Years cigar.

~ Gary Korb

Leave a Reply

avatar
Gary Korb

Gary Korb

Executive Editor

Gary Korb has been writing and editing content for CigarAdvisor.com since its debut in 2008. An avid cigar smoker for over 30 years, during the past 12 years he has worked on the marketing side of the premium cigar business as a Sr. Copywriter, blogger, and cigar reviewer. A graduate of the Newhouse School of Public Communications at Syracuse University, prior to his career in the cigar business, Gary worked in the music and video industry as a marketer and a publicist.

Show all Gary Korb's Articles
#nowsmoking Siboney Reserve cigar review - lonsdale - april 24 2019 Cigar Advisor Cover

#nowsmoking: Siboney Reserve Lonsdale

We’re #nowsmoking Aganorsa Leaf in this Siboney Reserve cigar review: “smooth and creamy with sweet spice and everything nice.” Is this Lonsdale your next smoke? Click to get the details delivered in under 2 minutes…

Read More
Now Smoking Rafael Gonzolez Cigars

#Nowsmoking: Rafael Gonzalez Churchill

The Rafael Gonzalez Churchill offers a long, smooth, and mellow smoke with dominant notes of cedar, nuts and a pinch of sweet spice. A terrific starter cigar – click to see more of our review.

Read More
Liga Privada Cigars Guide Liga Privada cigar reviews 2018 - CACover

2018 CA REPORT: The Essential Cigar Advisor Guide to Liga Privada Cigars

Liga Privada cigars have risen to “classic” status for a long list of reasons, starting with rich Nicaraguan flavor. And upon their first release in 2007, Liga Madness gripped the cigar world instantly – making Drew Estate fans out of millions. But if you’ve yet to indulge in these “Private Blends,” the Cigar Advisors have taken the liberty to introduce you: click now to see our reviews!

Read More
Punch Gran Puro Nicaragua Cigars Offer Cigar Smokers an Unprecedented New Taste Experience

Punch Gran Puro Nicaragua Cigars Offer Cigar Smokers an Unprecedented New Taste Experience

Punch is debuting a new cigar brand, Punch Gran Puro Nicaragua featuring Nicaraguan tobacco. Due impart by the increased popularity of Nicaraguan cigars
Read More